World History › Section S · Latin American independence › Topic S.2

Independence in Spanish North America

Mexico's independence came in two very different waves: a mass rebellion of peasants and miners led by village priests, which was crushed, and a conservative bargain among elites, which succeeded. Comparing them shows whose independence it finally was.

New Spain in 1808

New Spain, the viceroyalty that included Mexico, was Spain's richest colony, the world's leading producer of silver. When Napoleon seized the Spanish throne in 1808, creoles on Mexico City's council proposed an assembly to govern in the captive king's name, and the viceroy, José de Iturrigaray, seemed willing to listen. In September 1808 a group of peninsular merchants and officials, fearing creole power, arrested him and installed a more pliant viceroy. The coup showed that peninsulares would use force to keep control, and it closed the legal route to self-government.

Hard times and a conspiracy

Drought and failed harvests between 1808 and 1810 pushed up the price of maize, the staple food, while unemployment rose in the mining districts. A royal decree of 1804 had ordered church funds, much of them lent to landowners and merchants, to be called in and sent to Spain, and its enforcement hurt many creole borrowers. In Querétaro, a group including the militia captain Ignacio Allende and the priest Miguel Hidalgo plotted a rising. When officials discovered the plot in September 1810, Josefa Ortiz de Domínguez, wife of the town's magistrate, sent warning, and Hidalgo decided to act at once.

The Grito de Dolores

Hidalgo, an educated creole and parish priest of Dolores, rang his church bell on the morning of 16 September 1810 and called his parishioners to rise. His exact words were not recorded, but accounts agree that he denounced bad government and the peninsulares while still proclaiming loyalty to Ferdinand VII. This Grito de Dolores, or Cry of Dolores, is celebrated as Mexico's Independence Day. The rebels marched behind a banner of the Virgin of Guadalupe, who, by tradition, had appeared to an Indigenous man, Juan Diego, in 1531. Long venerated by Indigenous and mixed-race Mexicans, she made a powerful symbol of an American, rather than Spanish, identity.

Hidalgo's insurgency

Within weeks tens of thousands joined, most of them Indigenous and mestizo peasants and mine workers. On 28 September 1810 they stormed the public granary of Guanajuato, where Spaniards and wealthy creoles had taken refuge, and killed many of those inside. Late in 1810 Hidalgo decreed the abolition of slavery and of Indigenous tribute. After winning a battle near Mexico City, he turned back without attacking the capital, and in January 1811 royalists routed his army at Calderón Bridge. He was captured in March and executed in July 1811. The violence convinced most creoles, even sympathisers, that a mass uprising threatened them more than Spanish rule did.

Morelos and the Sentiments of the Nation

Leadership passed to José María Morelos, a priest of mixed descent from a poor family, who built a smaller, disciplined army in the south. In 1813 he summoned a congress at Chilpancingo and set out his programme in a document called the Sentiments of the Nation. It declared America independent of Spain and any other power, placed sovereignty in the people, divided government into branches, made Catholicism the only permitted religion, abolished slavery and caste distinctions, and replaced tribute with a light tax. The congress declared independence in November 1813 and adopted a constitution in 1814. Morelos was captured and executed in December 1815.

Worked example: reading the Sentiments of the Nation

1. Author and moment: a rebel priest in 1813, writing to guide a wartime congress and win support. 2. Points for the poor majority: ending slavery, caste distinctions and tribute would appeal most to Indigenous people, pardos and mestizos. 3. Points for creoles and clergy: independence, sovereignty and the protection of the Catholic Church offered reassurance to more conservative readers. 4. A tension: it promised equality among Americans while forbidding any other religion, showing that its liberty was not modelled simply on the United States or France. 5. Conclusion: Morelos tried to join social revolution to Catholic, American identity, but moderate creoles still held back.

A Mexican civil war

The war was fought mostly among Mexicans. Royalist armies, commanded by officers such as Félix Calleja, were largely American-born, with creole officers and mestizo soldiers, so the struggle was in many ways a civil war over the shape of society. After Morelos's death the insurgency shrank to guerrilla bands in the mountains, led by men such as Guadalupe Victoria and Vicente Guerrero, a leader of mixed ancestry, including African. Interpretations of the rebels' aims differ. The historian Eric Van Young argued in 2001 that many village insurgents fought for local land, community and religion rather than for an abstract Mexican nation. By 1820 New Spain seemed largely pacified.

Iturbide and the Plan of Iguala

Events in Spain revived the cause. In 1820 a military revolt forced Ferdinand VII to restore the liberal Cádiz Constitution, and the Spanish Cortes moved against the special legal privileges of the church and army. Mexican conservatives who had backed Spain against Hidalgo now saw independence as protection. Agustín de Iturbide, a creole royalist officer who had fought the insurgents, made a pact with his old enemy Guerrero. On 24 February 1821 he proclaimed the Plan of Iguala, built on Three Guarantees: independence, the Catholic religion as the only faith, and union of Americans and Europeans. Mexico would become a constitutional monarchy.

Worked example: why Iturbide won where Hidalgo lost

Compare the two movements. 1. Leadership and goals: Hidalgo led a social uprising from below; Iturbide offered independence without social upheaval. 2. Coalition: Hidalgo frightened creoles into the royalist camp, while Iturbide united conservative creoles, the church, many peninsulares and Guerrero's insurgents. 3. Military power: royalist officers and units changed sides to join Iturbide's Army of the Three Guarantees, so the army that had defeated Hidalgo now fought for independence. 4. Spain's position: torn by its own revolution, it could send few troops. 5. Conclusion: independence came when elites decided it would protect, not threaten, their property, faith and status.

From empire to republic

In August 1821 Iturbide and Spain's last representative, Juan O'Donojú, signed the Treaty of Córdoba, and on 27 September Iturbide entered Mexico City in triumph. When no European prince accepted the crown, Congress proclaimed him Emperor Agustín I in 1822. He dissolved Congress, revolts spread, and he abdicated in 1823; returning from exile in 1824, he was executed. The Constitution of 1824 made Mexico a federal republic, with Guadalupe Victoria as first president. Central America declared independence in 1821, joined the Mexican empire briefly, and in 1823 formed the United Provinces of Central America. Spain recognised Mexico only in 1836.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming Hidalgo proclaimed a fully formed programme in his Grito: his exact words are unknown, and his decrees on slavery and tribute came later in 1810. Second, imagining Spanish troops did most of the fighting; royalist armies were largely Mexican. Third, treating independence in 1821 as the victory of Hidalgo's social goals; Iturbide's plan protected the church and elites. Fourth, confusing the Plan of Iguala with a republic; it proposed a monarchy. Fifth, forgetting that Iturbide's empire lasted only until 1823. Sixth, assuming every insurgent fought for a Mexican nation; many defended local interests.

Key takeaways

After a peninsular coup in 1808 blocked creole self-rule, hunger and debt fed a conspiracy, and Hidalgo's Grito de Dolores of 16 September 1810 launched a mass uprising under the Virgin of Guadalupe. Its violence drove creoles to the royalists, and Hidalgo was executed in 1811. Morelos's Sentiments of the Nation joined independence and social equality to Catholic exclusivity before his execution in 1815. In 1821, alarmed by Spain's liberal turn, conservative creoles followed Iturbide's Plan of Iguala to independence. His empire fell in 1823, and the Constitution of 1824 created a federal republic.

Flashcards

Flashcard

New Spain

The viceroyalty that included Mexico, Spain's richest colony

The world's leading silver producer.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did most creoles turn against Hidalgo's rebellion?

Question 2 of 5

Which point in Morelos's Sentiments of the Nation would most reassure conservative creoles and clergy?

Question 3 of 5

What led Mexican conservatives to support independence in 1821?

Question 4 of 5

What form of government did the Plan of Iguala propose for an independent Mexico?

Question 5 of 5

Why is the war of 1810 to 1821 often described as a Mexican civil war?

← Previous topicNext topic →