Accounting › Section V · Responsibility accounting and decentralization › Topic V.1
Centralized and decentralized management
As a business grows, one person can no longer make every decision. Whether authority stays at the top or is spread through the organisation shapes how fast it reacts, how consistent it stays, and how its managers must be measured.
Who decides?
Tidecombe Coffee began as a single café run by its founder, who ordered the beans, set the prices, hired the baristas and balanced the till each night. Eight years later it has six cafés in two cities. The founder cannot be in six places at once, and every decision that waits for her slows the whole business down. Should she keep control of everything, or hand some decisions to the people running each café? That choice, between centralised and decentralised management, is the subject of this topic, and it decides how the accounting system must report on each part of the business.
Management control systems
A management control system is the structure an organisation uses to set its strategic goals, put them into practice and monitor progress towards them. Setting goals covers markets, products, prices and people. Putting them into practice needs plans, budgets and clear communication. Monitoring relies on the financial and managerial accounting systems, which report what actually happened. That feedback lets managers repeat what works, correct what does not and, sometimes, question whether the goals themselves still make sense. A good system looks forward through planning and backward through evaluation.
Levels of management
Organisations are often described as having three levels. Upper management, the board of directors and senior executives, sets strategy and answers to the owners. Middle management runs departments, divisions or regions, turning strategy into plans and directing the managers below. Lower-level management, such as supervisors and shift leaders, oversees day-to-day work. The key design question is how much decision-making authority each level holds. Centralisation and decentralisation are two ends of a spectrum, and most organisations sit somewhere between them.
Centralised organisations
In a centralised organisation, the important decisions, such as how resources are allocated and which direction the business takes, are made by one person or a small group at the top. Lower managers carry decisions out and report back. Many small businesses are centralised, because the owner makes most of the decisions, but large organisations can be too. The advantages are clear and consistent decisions, quick roll-out of policies, strong control over strategy and no duplicated effort. The drawbacks are a bottleneck at the top, slower responses to local conditions, less use of front-line knowledge and fewer chances for lower managers to develop.
Decentralised organisations
In a decentralised organisation, decision-making authority is spread across several levels, usually by dividing the business into segments whose managers run them with real autonomy. Senior management sets goals and guidelines; segment managers decide how to reach them. The advantages are faster decisions by people closer to customers, easier expansion into new products or places, top management freed to concentrate on strategy, managers who build skills and experience, better morale, and pay that can rise with responsibility.
The costs of decentralisation
Spreading authority has costs. Coordination is harder, because separate managers may pull in different directions. Administrative costs can rise when each segment duplicates activities, such as its own purchasing or bookkeeping. A manager may optimise their own segment at the expense of the whole company, for example by refusing to share staff with a busier unit; aligning segment goals with company goals is called goal congruence. And the company depends heavily on the skill of each segment manager. Responsibility accounting, covered in "Types of responsibility centers", is the main tool for keeping decentralised managers accountable.
Daily and strategic decisions
Daily decisions are frequent and immediate: how many staff to roster today, whether to reorder milk, how to handle a complaint. Strategic decisions are infrequent and long term: which cities to enter, which products to offer, whether to compete mainly on low cost. A new owner often makes both kinds, which builds deep knowledge of the business but cannot last. As the business grows, an owner who stays absorbed in daily decisions neglects strategy, while one who turns only to strategy risks poor daily decisions. Delegating daily decisions to trained managers resolves the dilemma, and is the usual first step towards decentralisation.
Segments and organisational charts
A segment is an identifiable part of a business, such as a department, a product line or a geographic region. An organisational chart shows the segments as boxes and the reporting lines as connections, with the highest authority at the top. In a centralised chart, many boxes report straight to the top; in a decentralised one, segments report through intermediate managers who hold real authority. Delegating authority does not delegate final accountability: the chief executive remains responsible to the board for the results of the whole organisation.
Worked example: two charts for Tidecombe
1. Centralised: the founder supervises managers for purchasing, marketing and finance, plus all six café managers, so she has 9 direct reports. 2. Decentralised: the six cafés are grouped under a North regional manager and a South regional manager, three cafés each, so she has 5 direct reports: three functions and two regions. 3. Follow one decision, a café adding a weekend barista. In the centralised chart it waits for the founder. In the decentralised chart the regional manager approves it within the regional budget, the same day. 4. Effect: decisions are faster and the founder's time is freed for strategy, but Tidecombe now needs reports that show how each region performs.
Worked example: what to centralise
Tidecombe decides decision by decision. 1. Buying coffee beans: centralise. One buyer wins volume discounts and keeps the taste the same in every café. 2. Hiring and rostering baristas: decentralise. Café managers know the local labour market and their busy hours. 3. Menu prices: mix. Head office sets a price band to protect the brand, and cafés run local promotions within it. 4. Opening a new café: centralise. It is a large, long-term investment that affects the whole company. The result is a hybrid structure, which is typical: few organisations are fully centralised or fully decentralised.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming centralisation means a small company and decentralisation a large one; size influences the choice but does not decide it. Second, treating the choice as all or nothing, when most organisations centralise some decisions and delegate others. Third, believing that delegating a decision also delegates final accountability. Fourth, listing the benefits of decentralisation without its costs: duplication, coordination problems and goal incongruence. Fifth, delegating authority without changing how managers are measured.
Key takeaways
A management control system sets goals, puts them into practice and monitors results, with the accounting system supplying the feedback. Centralised organisations keep major decisions at the top, gaining consistency and control at the cost of speed and local knowledge. Decentralised organisations delegate decisions to segment managers, gaining speed, expansion and management development at the cost of coordination, duplication and possible goal incongruence. Daily decisions are usually delegated first; strategic ones stay nearer the top. Most organisations are hybrids, and the chief executive remains accountable for the whole.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Structure for setting, implementing and monitoring strategic goals
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which description best fits a decentralised organisation?
Question 2 of 5
A retail chain lets each store manager choose staffing levels. Which benefit of decentralisation does this most directly provide?
Question 3 of 5
Each division of a decentralised company runs its own purchasing and bookkeeping teams. Which cost of decentralisation does this show?
Question 4 of 5
A president oversees three functional managers. Eight stores are grouped under two regional managers who report to her. How many direct reports does she have?
Question 5 of 5
Which decision is a café chain most likely to keep centralised, and why?
