Accounting › Section V · Responsibility accounting and decentralization › Topic V.2

Types of responsibility centers

Once decisions are delegated, each manager needs to know what they will be judged on. Responsibility accounting matches each part of the business to the revenues, costs or investment its manager controls, and reports on it in those terms.

Measuring delegated managers

A decentralised company, as described in "Centralized and decentralized management", hands real decisions to segment managers. That raises a practical question: how will each of them be judged? A warehouse manager cannot set selling prices, and a sales manager does not choose the warehouse's equipment. Judging both on company profit would reward or blame them for things they cannot influence. Responsibility accounting solves this by measuring each manager on the items they are responsible for and have the authority to affect.

Responsibility accounting

Responsibility accounting assigns each segment of the business to a manager who is responsible for its financial performance and has authority over its decisions. Each such segment is a responsibility centre. Its report compares actual results with the budget for the items its manager controls, and reports roll up the organisation: a department's figures feed its store, the store's feed its region. There are five common types, by what the manager is accountable for: cost centres, discretionary cost centres, revenue centres, profit centres and investment centres.

Cost centres

In a cost centre, the manager is responsible only for costs, and there is a clear link between the costs incurred and the goods or services produced. Production departments, warehouses and maintenance teams are typical. The manager is judged on keeping costs at or below budget, ideally a flexible budget for the work actually done, as "Flexible budgets" explains. Low cost is not the only goal: a maintenance team that saves money by leaving spills uncleaned harms customers and safety, so cost targets must be set alongside service standards.

Worked example: a cost centre report

Stourmoor Home Stores' flagship store reports on its maintenance department for October 2027.

\begin{array}{lrr} & \text{Budget} & \text{Actual} \\ \hline \text{Wages} & 14{,}000 & 14{,}900 \\ \text{Supplies} & 1{,}200 & 1{,}650 \\ \text{Repairs} & 2{,}000 & 1{,}700 \\ \text{Supervisor} & 4{,}500 & 4{,}500 \\ \hline \text{Total} & 21{,}700 & 22{,}750 \end{array}

1. Total variance: \(22{,}750 - 21{,}700 = 1{,}050\) U, about 4.8%. 2. Lines: wages 900 U (6.4%), supplies 450 U (37.5%), repairs 300 F (15%), supervisor salary on budget. 3. Cause: store management added two late-night sales events, which needed extra cleaning hours and supplies. 4. Conclusion: the overrun followed a decision outside the department, so the manager should not be blamed.

Discretionary cost centres

In a discretionary cost centre, the manager is responsible for costs, but there is no well-defined link between spending and output. Human resources, legal, accounting and research departments are examples: no formula says how much a safety-training programme or a legal review should cost per unit of benefit. Their spending is set largely by management judgement, and they are judged mainly on staying within budget while delivering the service expected. Spending less is not automatically better; cutting training or research may improve this year's report and harm future years.

Revenue centres

In a revenue centre, the manager is held accountable mainly for revenue. A sales team, an online store's sales desk or a reservations office are examples. The manager works on product knowledge, customer service and converting enquiries into sales, and is judged on revenue against budget, often split by product or region. Many revenue centres are also responsible for their own controllable selling costs, such as travel. One risk is that a manager judged only on revenue may chase sales through deep discounts or slow-paying customers, so prices and credit terms are usually set elsewhere.

Profit centres

In a profit centre, the manager answers for revenue as well as costs, and so for segment profit. A single store, a product line or a department within a store are typical. It is the most demanding of the centres so far, because the manager must raise revenue and control costs together. Comparing segments of different sizes in dollars alone misleads, so reports often add percentages, including the profit margin:

\text{Profit margin} = \frac{\text{Segment profit}}{\text{Revenue}}

It shows how many cents of each revenue dollar the segment turns into profit.

Worked example: comparing profit centres

Stourmoor's furniture department budgeted revenue of $400,000 and profit of $52,000, and actually earned profit of $54,600 on revenue of $420,000. Kitchenware budgeted $22,000 of profit on $140,000 and earned $25,500 on $150,000. 1. Dollar change: furniture \(54{,}600 - 52{,}000 = 2{,}600\) F, kitchenware \(25{,}500 - 22{,}000 = 3{,}500\) F. 2. Percentage change: furniture \(2{,}600 \div 52{,}000 = 5.0\%\), kitchenware \(3{,}500 \div 22{,}000 \approx 15.9\%\). 3. Actual profit margin: furniture \(54{,}600 \div 420{,}000 = 13.0\%\), kitchenware \(25{,}500 \div 150{,}000 = 17.0\%\). 4. Furniture adds more dollars of profit, but kitchenware beat its budget by more and turns more of each sale into profit.

Investment centres

In an investment centre, the manager is responsible for revenues, costs and the assets invested in the segment, such as a division with its own stores and equipment. Profit alone cannot judge it, since a division with twice the assets should earn more. Two common measures relate profit to investment:

\text{ROI} = \frac{\text{Operating income}}{\text{Average operating assets}}

and residual income, operating income minus a minimum required rate times average operating assets. Companies define the investment base differently, so use one definition consistently. "Return on investment, residual income, and EVA" develops both measures.

Worked example: two divisions

Stourmoor's East division earned operating income of $300,000 on average operating assets of $1,500,000; West earned $90,000 on $500,000. The company requires a minimum return of 12%. 1. ROI: East \(300{,}000 \div 1{,}500{,}000 = 20\%\), West \(90{,}000 \div 500{,}000 = 18\%\). 2. Required return: East \(12\% \times 1{,}500{,}000 = 180{,}000\), West \(12\% \times 500{,}000 = 60{,}000\). 3. Residual income: East \(300{,}000 - 180{,}000 = 120{,}000\), West \(90{,}000 - 60{,}000 = 30{,}000\). 4. Both beat the minimum. ROI compares efficiency regardless of size; residual income shows the dollars earned above the required return, so it favours the larger division.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, judging a cost centre against a static budget when its workload changed. Second, assuming lower spending in a discretionary cost centre is always good. Third, judging a revenue centre on revenue without watching discounts and credit quality. Fourth, comparing profit centres of different sizes in dollars only. Fifth, judging an investment centre on profit without the assets used to earn it, or switching definitions of the investment base between periods.

Key takeaways

Responsibility accounting measures each manager on the items they are responsible for and can affect. Cost centres answer for costs with a clear link to output; discretionary cost centres for costs without one; revenue centres mainly for revenue; profit centres for revenue and costs; investment centres for profit and the assets invested. Reports compare actual with budget, ideally flexible, and use percentages such as profit margin to compare segments of different sizes. Investment centres are judged with ROI and residual income, using a consistent investment base.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Responsibility accounting

Measuring each manager on the items they are responsible for and can affect

Reports roll up the organisation.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A company's human resources department runs training and sets hiring policy. No formula links its spending to output. What kind of responsibility centre is it?

Question 2 of 5

A store manager sets local prices, staff levels and promotions, but head office decides on all new buildings and equipment. What kind of centre is the store?

Question 3 of 5

A division earned operating income of $84,000. Its operating assets were $640,000 at the start of the year and $760,000 at the end. What is its ROI on average operating assets?

Question 4 of 5

The same division, with average operating assets of $700,000 and operating income of $84,000, faces a 10% minimum required return. What is its residual income?

Question 5 of 5

Department A earned $54,600 profit on revenue of $420,000; Department B earned $25,500 on $150,000. Which statement is correct?

← Previous topicNext topic →