Accounting › Section U · Standard costs and variances › Topic U.5

How companies use variance analysis

Computing variances is arithmetic; using them well is management. This topic shows how companies report variances, decide which ones to investigate, trace their causes and avoid the behaviour that standards can encourage.

From numbers to decisions

The last four topics split Pellworth Pottery's March cost overrun into eight variances. On their own those figures change nothing. Their value comes from what happens next: someone decides which ones matter, finds out why they happened, and either fixes a problem, keeps a good practice going, or updates a standard that no longer fits. Done well, variance analysis turns a monthly cost report into a set of questions for the right people. Done badly, it becomes a blame exercise that teaches managers to protect their numbers instead of the business.

The variance report

Most companies summarise variances in a monthly report, listed by cost and by the manager responsible. Pellworth's March report, using this section's sign convention, looks like this:

\begin{array}{lr} \text{Materials price} & 1{,}960 \text{ F} \\ \text{Materials quantity} & 1{,}200 \text{ U} \\ \text{Labour rate} & 2{,}520 \text{ U} \\ \text{Labour efficiency} & 5{,}760 \text{ U} \\ \text{VOH spending} & 1{,}260 \text{ F} \\ \text{VOH efficiency} & 1{,}920 \text{ U} \\ \text{FOH budget} & 1{,}200 \text{ U} \\ \text{FOH volume} & 2{,}000 \text{ U} \\ \hline \text{Total} & 11{,}380 \text{ U} \end{array}

The total matches the $11,380 U found in Developing standard costs: actual cost of $270,580 against a standard cost of $259,200.

Management by exception

Managers cannot chase every variance, so most companies set thresholds and investigate only variances that cross them, an approach called management by exception. A common rule combines a percentage and a dollar amount, for example any variance of at least 5% of the related standard cost, or at least $2,500. Thresholds are a starting point, not the whole test. A small variance that repeats in the same direction month after month deserves attention, because it suggests a lasting problem or an out-of-date standard. Many companies also require explanations of large favourable variances, to learn whether a saving can be repeated.

Worked example: applying Pellworth's thresholds

Pellworth investigates any variance of at least 5% of its standard cost, or at least $2,500. Standard costs of March output were clay $57,600, labour $115,200, variable overhead $38,400 and fixed overhead applied $48,000. 1. Materials price: \(1{,}960 \div 57{,}600 \approx 3.4\%\): not flagged. 2. Materials quantity: about 2.1%: not flagged. 3. Labour rate: 2.2%, but $2,520 is over $2,500: flagged. 4. Labour efficiency: \(5{,}760 \div 115{,}200 = 5.0\%\): flagged. 5. Variable overhead spending: 3.3%: not flagged. 6. Variable overhead efficiency: \(1{,}920 \div 38{,}400 = 5.0\%\): flagged. 7. Fixed overhead budget, 2.5%, and volume, 4.2%: not flagged. Three variances go to managers for explanation.

Linked causes

Variances are often connected, so an investigation follows the chain rather than stopping at the first figure. Cheaper material can raise usage and labour time. Inexperienced workers may save on rate but waste material and hours. Extra labour hours raise variable overhead whenever it is applied by labour hours. Overtime worked to recover lost time creates a rate variance downstream of an efficiency problem. Responsibility follows the cause, not the label: purchasing usually answers for price, production for usage and efficiency, and whoever schedules work for overtime, but a purchasing choice can create a production variance.

Worked example: tracing March's story

Pellworth's production manager finds that 200 of the 240 extra labour hours went into remaking planters that cracked during firing, and that the cracks came from the cheaper clay that produced the favourable price variance. 1. Saving from the cheaper clay: $1,960 F. 2. Extra clay used: $1,200 U, all traced to cracks. 3. Labour for remakes: \(200 \times 24 = 4{,}800\) U. 4. Variable overhead for remakes: \(200 \times 8 = 1{,}600\) U. 5. Net effect of the clay decision: the costs total \(1{,}200 + 4{,}800 + 1{,}600 = 7{,}600\), and \(7{,}600 - 1{,}960 = 5{,}640\), so $5,640 U. 6. Decision: return to the standard grade of clay. A buyer judged only on the price variance would have looked successful while costing the company money.

When standards drive the wrong behaviour

Standards can distort decisions. A favourable variance may come from budget slack, a standard set deliberately loose so that results look good. Managers may also manage to the variances: buying cheap material for a good price variance, cutting maintenance to save spending, or producing beyond demand to turn the volume variance favourable, which piles up inventory and, under absorption costing, moves fixed cost into stock, as Variable versus absorption costing showed. Companies limit this by setting standards with the people affected, reviewing them regularly, and judging managers on several measures, not cost variances alone.

Closing variances at period end

In a standard cost system inventory and cost of goods sold are carried at standard, and variances are kept in their own accounts during the year. At period end, small net variances are usually closed to Cost of Goods Sold: unfavourable variances increase it and favourable ones decrease it. When the variances are material, many companies prorate them among Work in Process, Finished Goods and Cost of Goods Sold, so that inventory on the balance sheet stays close to actual cost. US GAAP accepts standard costs for inventory when they reasonably approximate actual cost and are revised as conditions change.

Strengths and limits of standard costing

Standard costing gives a clear benchmark, speeds up budgeting, makes exceptions visible and points to the area responsible. It also has limits. Monthly variances can arrive too late for fast-moving operations. Building and updating standards takes time and money. In highly automated plants direct labour is a small cost, so labour variances say little. Most importantly, cost variances say nothing directly about quality, delivery or customer satisfaction. That is why many companies pair them with nonfinancial measures, the idea behind The balanced scorecard.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, investigating only the largest variance and missing the chain that links it to others. Second, assuming favourable means good; cheap material, deferred maintenance or budget slack can all produce one. Third, ignoring small variances that recur every month. Fourth, blaming the manager whose department reports a variance rather than the one whose decision caused it. Fifth, producing extra units to improve the volume variance. Sixth, forgetting that variance accounts must be closed at period end, usually to Cost of Goods Sold.

Key takeaways

Variance reports list each variance, its direction and the responsible manager, and the parts sum to the total cost variance. Management by exception uses thresholds, plus attention to repeated and large favourable variances. Investigations follow linked causes, so responsibility rests with the decision that caused a variance. Standards can encourage budget slack and managing to the variances, so companies use several measures. Small variances are closed to Cost of Goods Sold; material ones may be prorated among inventories and cost of goods sold.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Variance report

A list of each variance, its direction and the manager responsible

Pellworth March total: 11,380 U.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A company investigates any variance of at least 4% of the related standard cost. The standard labour cost of output was $80,000. Which labour efficiency variance would be investigated?

Question 2 of 5

A buyer's switch to cheaper material gave a $3,000 F price variance, but it caused $1,000 U in extra material, $2,400 U in extra labour and $800 U in extra variable overhead. What was the net effect of the switch?

Question 3 of 5

At year end a company has a small net unfavourable variance of $4,000. What is the usual treatment?

Question 4 of 5

A plant manager produces 20% more units than customers ordered to turn the fixed overhead volume variance favourable. What is the main problem?

Question 5 of 5

Why might a company ask managers to explain a large favourable variance?

← Previous topicNext topic →