Accounting › Section Y · Balanced scorecard and performance measures › Topic Y.1

Why measure performance, and what makes a good measure

Once decisions are spread across many managers, the company needs a way to see whether those decisions serve its goals. Good performance measures do that; poor ones quietly reward the wrong behaviour.

Why measure at all

As Centralized and decentralized management explained, a growing company pushes decisions down to the managers closest to customers and operations. That gains speed and local knowledge, but head office can no longer watch every choice. Performance measurement fills the gap. It tells senior managers whether each unit is moving towards the company's goals, gives unit managers feedback on their own decisions, and provides the basis for rewards such as bonuses and promotions. Because people pay attention to whatever they are measured and rewarded on, choosing the measures is itself one of the most important decisions a company makes.

Goal congruence

Goal congruence means that managers, pursuing their own goals, also pursue the organisation's. A manager wants a bonus, a promotion or recognition; the company wants profit, growth, satisfied customers and a sound reputation. A well-designed measure links the two, so that what earns the manager a reward also helps the company. A badly designed one splits them. A depot manager paid only on cost savings may refuse a profitable rush job because it adds overtime. The measure, not the manager's character, has created the conflict, and it is the measure that needs fixing.

From strategy to measures

Measures should be built from the top down. The company first states its strategy, the broad route by which it intends to compete. It turns the strategy into specific goals, such as raising on-time deliveries or cutting fuel cost per mile. For each goal it chooses a measure and sets a target, a number to aim for by a date. Results are then reviewed against the targets, actions are taken, and goals or targets are adjusted as conditions change. A measure that cannot be traced back to a goal is a candidate for removal, because it uses attention without serving the strategy.

The controllability principle

Managers should be judged mainly on what they can control or strongly influence. Types of responsibility centers showed the main kinds: a cost centre manager controls costs, a revenue centre manager revenues, a profit centre manager both, and an investment centre manager also the assets used. Each should be measured accordingly. Costs allocated from head office, national fuel prices or exchange rates are usually beyond a unit manager's control. Including them in the evaluation adds noise, punishes or rewards luck, and weakens motivation. They can still be reported, but separately, so everyone sees the full cost without blaming the wrong person.

Worked example: Dunmere's controllable costs

Dunmere Freight's Riverside depot budgeted $400,000 of costs for the deliveries it actually made: wages $210,000, fuel $120,000 (40,000 gallons at $3.00), maintenance $40,000 and a head-office charge of $30,000. Actual costs were wages $206,000, fuel $128,700 (39,000 gallons at $3.30), maintenance $39,000 and head office $38,000: $411,700, so $11,700 U. 1. Head-office charge: $8,000 U, not controllable. 2. Fuel price: \((3.30 - 3.00) \times 39{,}000 = 11{,}700\) U, set by the market. 3. Fuel usage: \((39{,}000 - 40{,}000) \times 3.00 = -3{,}000\), so $3,000 F. 4. Controllable: wages $4,000 F, fuel usage $3,000 F, maintenance $1,000 F, so $8,000 F. 5. Check: uncontrollable \(8{,}000 + 11{,}700 = 19{,}700\) U less $8,000 F controllable is $11,700 U. Judged fairly, the manager did well.

What makes a good measure

A good performance measure has several features. 1. It is linked to a strategic goal. 2. It covers something the manager controls or influences. 3. It is measurable, objectively and at reasonable cost. 4. It is timely, reported soon enough to act on. 5. It is consistent, defined the same way each period, with any change announced in advance. 6. It is compared with a baseline, such as a budget, standard, past result or peer, because a number on its own means little. 7. It balances the short term and the long term. 8. It is hard to game. Involving managers in choosing measures also helps them understand and accept them.

Limits of accounting measures

Accounting numbers are attractive measures because they already exist and are audited at the company level. But on their own they have weaknesses. They look backwards, reporting what has already happened. They can be moved by timing: delaying discretionary spending on maintenance, training, advertising or research raises this year's profit while harming future years. They are affected by events outside the manager's control. And they say little about quality, customer loyalty or employee skills, which drive future profit. Most companies therefore combine financial measures with nonfinancial ones, the approach developed in The balanced scorecard.

Worked example: a bonus that backfires

Dunmere pays its Hillside depot manager a $5,000 bonus if annual depot profit reaches $500,000. In November profit is heading for $480,000. 1. The manager postpones $30,000 of preventive maintenance, lifting profit to $510,000 and earning the bonus. 2. The next year, two trucks break down; repairs, hired vehicles and lost contracts cost $75,000. 3. Two-year effect on depot profit: \(30{,}000 - 75{,}000 = -45{,}000\). 4. Including the bonus, the company is \(45{,}000 + 5{,}000 = 50{,}000\) worse off, while the manager is $5,000 better off. 5. Remedy: add measures such as the share of scheduled maintenance completed and the breakdown rate, and judge profit over more than one year.

When a measure becomes a target

People respond to measures, sometimes in ways the designer never intended. An idea often linked to the economist Charles Goodhart holds that once a measure is used as a target, it tends to lose its value as a measure. A call centre judged only on average call length may see staff end calls before problems are solved. A sales team judged only on revenue may offer discounts that destroy margin. The usual defence is to pair measures that pull against each other: call length with the share of problems solved on the first call, or revenue with gross margin.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, holding managers responsible for allocated or market-driven costs they cannot control. Second, choosing measures because the data are easy to collect rather than because they serve a goal. Third, relying on a single measure, which invites gaming. Fourth, rewarding short-term profit alone, which encourages cuts to maintenance, training and research. Fifth, changing a measure's definition mid-period without telling the manager. Sixth, judging a result without a baseline to compare it with.

Key takeaways

Decentralised companies need performance measures to keep many managers' decisions aligned with company goals; this alignment is goal congruence. Measures should flow from strategy to goals, measures and targets, then be reviewed. Judge managers mainly on what they control and report uncontrollable items separately. Good measures are strategic, controllable, measurable, timely, consistent, compared with a baseline, balanced over time and hard to game. Accounting measures alone look backwards and can be manipulated, so companies add nonfinancial measures and pair measures that check each other.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Performance measure

A metric used to evaluate how well a unit or manager meets a goal

Needs a baseline to mean anything.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A store manager's costs were $6,000 over budget. Of this, $9,000 U came from a head-office rent allocation and the rest from items the manager controls. What is the manager's controllable result?

Question 2 of 5

A manager earns a bonus by delaying $20,000 of training to next year, and the delay later costs the company $35,000 in errors. What is the combined two-year effect on profit, ignoring the bonus?

Question 3 of 5

Which feature of a good performance measure is broken when a company changes how it defines operating profit halfway through the bonus year without telling managers?

Question 4 of 5

A help desk is judged only on how quickly it closes tickets. Which added measure would best guard against gaming?

Question 5 of 5

Why should allocated head-office costs usually be reported separately from a depot manager's controllable costs?

← Previous topicNext topic →