Accounting › Section W · Short-term decision making › Topic W.3

Make or buy

Almost every product contains parts its maker could produce itself or buy from someone else. A supplier's quote often looks cheaper than the in-house cost per unit, but that comparison is only fair once you know which in-house costs would really disappear.

Outsourcing is a choice between alternatives

Outsourcing means having another company supply goods or services that a firm needs instead of providing them itself. A manufacturer decides whether to make a component or buy it ready-made; a service firm decides whether to keep payroll, cleaning or IT support in-house or contract them out. Each is a make-or-buy decision, and it is analysed with the tools from "Relevant information and sunk costs": compare the future costs that differ between the two alternatives, then weigh the qualitative factors. Over a year or so the capacity involved is largely fixed, which makes this a short-term decision.

What it really costs to make

The relevant cost of making is the cost that would disappear if the firm stopped making the item. That always includes the variable production costs: direct materials, direct labour and variable overhead. It also includes any avoidable fixed costs, such as the salary of a supervisor who runs only that work, or an equipment lease that would be cancelled. It excludes fixed overhead that would continue anyway, such as an allocated share of factory rent, and sunk costs, such as depreciation on a machine already owned. The full cost per unit shown in the cost records usually includes those unavoidable items, so it overstates what buying would save.

What it really costs to buy

The relevant cost of buying is the purchase price plus any extra costs that buying creates: delivery charges the supplier does not include, receiving and inspection, or a contract-management role. These are added to the buy side. Costs that continue under both options appear on neither side, or equally on both, which comes to the same thing. The firm then compares the two totals for the same quantity and the same period. If buying costs less than the relevant cost of making, buying raises operating income by the difference, before qualitative factors are weighed.

Worked example: chain guards at Halsway Bicycle Co.

Halsway Bicycle Co., a fictional maker, uses 20,000 chain guards a year. Its records show a cost per guard of $4.10 materials, $2.60 labour, $1.30 variable overhead and $3.00 fixed overhead ($60,000 a year): $11.00 in all. A supplier offers delivered guards at $9.20. Of the $60,000, $14,000 is the salary of a supervisor who runs only guard moulding and would leave; the rest is rent share and depreciation, which continue. 1. Variable cost of making: 20,000 × $8.00 = $160,000. 2. Relevant totals:

\begin{array}{lrr}&\text{Make}&\text{Buy}\\\hline\text{Variable cost}&160{,}000&\\\text{Supervisor}&14{,}000&\\\text{Price paid}&&184{,}000\\\hline\text{Total}&174{,}000&184{,}000\end{array}

3. Making saves $10,000 a year, although $9.20 looks cheaper than $11.00. 4. Check: $46,000 of unavoidable fixed cost is paid either way, so it does not change the comparison.

Freed capacity has value

If the firm buys, the space, machines and people it used may be free for something else: renting the space out, making another product, or taking extra orders. The benefit from that best alternative use is an opportunity cost of making, because making ties the capacity up. It can be shown either as an extra cost on the make side or as a saving on the buy side; the difference between the options is the same. When the freed capacity has no other use, this opportunity cost is zero and the comparison rests on avoidable costs alone.

Worked example: putting the freed space to work

Return to Halsway. A neighbouring firm offers to rent the moulding area for $18,000 a year if Halsway stops making guards. 1. Making now has an opportunity cost of $18,000, the rent given up. 2. Make: $174,000 + $18,000 = $192,000. Buy: $184,000. 3. Buying is now better by $8,000 a year. 4. The most Halsway should pay per guard is the relevant cost of making, including the opportunity cost, per unit:

\frac{174{,}000 + 18{,}000}{20{,}000} = 9.60

Without the rental offer, the maximum would be $174,000 ÷ 20,000 = $8.70 per guard. 5. The answer flipped because a cost that never appears in the records was added.

Service businesses face the same choice

A small accounting practice spends $52,000 a year on an in-house payroll clerk, including benefits, plus $3,000 on payroll software. A payroll bureau quotes $46,000 a year for the same work. The office the clerk uses is leased for five years, and its share of rent would continue. Relevant cost of keeping the work in-house: $52,000 + $3,000 = $55,000, since both would end if the work were outsourced. Relevant cost of buying: $46,000. Outsourcing saves $9,000 a year. The rent share is unavoidable and stays out, unless the empty desk could be used for something that earns money.

Qualitative factors

The cheaper option on paper can still be the wrong one. Will the supplier meet the quality standard, deliver on time and keep producing the volumes needed? Is a low first quote a temporary price that will rise once the firm depends on it? Does making the part protect know-how, a patented design or customer data? Outsourcing can harm the morale of staff whose jobs go, and work that leaves the firm is often hard to bring back. On the other side, buying can bring outside expertise, free money and management time for the firm's core strengths, and pass some production risk to the supplier.

Common mistakes to avoid

1. Comparing the supplier's price with the full cost per unit, which includes fixed overhead that buying will not remove. 2. Treating every fixed cost as unavoidable, and so missing a supervisor's salary or a lease that would end. 3. Including depreciation on equipment already owned, which is a sunk cost. 4. Forgetting the opportunity cost of freed capacity. 5. Leaving out costs that buying adds, such as freight, inspection and ordering. 6. Comparing different quantities or periods. 7. Deciding on cost alone, without weighing quality, reliability and supplier dependence.

Key takeaways

A make-or-buy decision compares the relevant cost of making with the relevant cost of buying. The relevant cost of making is the variable production cost plus avoidable fixed costs; unavoidable fixed overhead and sunk costs are excluded. The relevant cost of buying is the purchase price plus any extra costs buying creates. The benefit of the best other use of freed capacity is an opportunity cost of making. The most worth paying a supplier is the relevant cost of making, including that opportunity cost, per unit. Quality, reliability, price stability and know-how can outweigh a small saving.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Outsourcing

Having another company supply goods or services the firm needs

A make-or-buy decision.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A part costs $3 materials, $2 labour, $1 variable overhead and $4 fixed overhead per unit, and none of the fixed overhead would be avoided by buying. A supplier offers it at $8. What should the firm do?

Question 2 of 5

A firm makes 10,000 units at a variable cost of $7 each. Of its $50,000 fixed overhead, $15,000 would end if it bought the part. A supplier quotes $8.20. Which is correct?

Question 3 of 5

Making 10,000 units costs $5 each in variable cost plus $20,000 of avoidable fixed cost. If the part is bought, the freed space can be rented out for $10,000 a year. What is the most the firm should pay per unit?

Question 4 of 5

How should the rent that freed space could earn be treated in a make-or-buy analysis?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these is a qualitative risk of buying a part rather than making it?

← Previous topicNext topic →