Accounting › Section U · Standard costs and variances › Topic U.3

Labor variances

Direct labour can cost more than standard because people were paid a different rate or worked a different number of hours. Separating the two tells managers whether to look at pay and scheduling or at productivity.

Rate or hours?

Pellworth Pottery's standard cost card, from Developing standard costs, allows 0.5 direct labour hours per planter at $24.00 per hour, so $12.00 of labour per planter. The total labour variance is actual labour cost minus the standard labour cost of actual output. Like the materials variance in Materials variances, it splits in two. The labour rate variance asks whether each hour cost more or less than standard. The labour efficiency variance asks whether more or fewer hours were worked than the output allowed. The same sign convention applies: actual minus standard, positive unfavourable (U), negative favourable (F).

The labour rate variance

The rate variance compares the actual hourly rate with the standard rate, on the hours actually worked:

\text{Rate var.} = (AR - SR) \times AH

AR is the actual rate per hour, found by dividing the actual direct labour cost by the actual hours; SR is the standard rate; AH is the actual hours worked. Rate variances often come from overtime premiums, a pay rise not yet built into the standard, or using a different mix of workers, for example senior staff on a task the standard assumed junior staff would do. Where wage rates are fixed by contract, rate variances tend to be small and easy to explain.

The labour efficiency variance

The efficiency variance, sometimes called the time or usage variance, compares the hours worked with the standard hours allowed for actual output, valued at the standard rate:

\text{Eff. var.} = (AH - SH) \times SR

SH is units produced times the standard hours per unit. Valuing the hours at the standard rate keeps pay effects out of what is meant to be a productivity measure. Unfavourable efficiency variances can come from untrained workers, poor supervision, machine breakdowns, waiting for materials, poor-quality materials that are hard to work, or many small production runs with extra setups.

Three columns again

The three-column layout works for labour exactly as for materials. Column 1 is \(AH \times AR\), the actual payroll. Column 2 is \(AH \times SR\), the actual hours at the standard rate. Column 3 is \(SH \times SR\), the standard labour cost of actual output. Column 1 minus column 2 gives the rate variance, column 2 minus column 3 the efficiency variance, and column 1 minus column 3 the total. Labour cannot be bought and stored for later, so the hours paid for are the hours used, and the two variances always add up to the total labour variance.

Worked example: Pellworth's March labour

In March Pellworth made 9,600 planters. Its potters worked 5,040 hours and the direct labour payroll, including taxes and benefits, was $123,480. 1. Actual rate: \(123{,}480 \div 5{,}040 = 24.50\), or $24.50 per hour. 2. Standard hours allowed: \(9{,}600 \times 0.5 = 4{,}800\). 3. Rate variance: \((24.50 - 24.00) \times 5{,}040 = 2{,}520\), so $2,520 U. 4. Efficiency variance: \((5{,}040 - 4{,}800) \times 24 = 5{,}760\), so $5,760 U. 5. Total: standard cost is \(4{,}800 \times 24 = 115{,}200\), and \(123{,}480 - 115{,}200 = 8{,}280\), so $8,280 U. 6. Check: \(2{,}520 + 5{,}760 = 8{,}280\). The 240 extra hours cost far more than the higher rate.

Who answers for each variance

Responsibility needs care. The production manager usually answers for the efficiency variance, but not always: if purchasing bought clay that cracked, extra hours spent remaking planters trace back to purchasing, and Pellworth's March figures fit that story, since the clay was cheaper and usage was high. The rate variance often belongs to whoever scheduled the work. A supervisor who calls in overtime to recover lost time creates an unfavourable rate variance, and a human resources department that agrees a mid-year pay rise creates one too. The point of the split is to start the right conversation, not to assign blame mechanically.

Worked example: a skill-mix trade-off

In May Pellworth tried using only senior potters, paid $27.00 an hour including benefits, hoping they would work faster. It made 9,000 planters in 4,200 hours. 1. Standard hours allowed: \(9{,}000 \times 0.5 = 4{,}500\). 2. Rate variance: \((27 - 24) \times 4{,}200 = 12{,}600\), so $12,600 U. 3. Efficiency variance: \((4{,}200 - 4{,}500) \times 24 = -7{,}200\), so $7,200 F. 4. Total: actual pay \(4{,}200 \times 27 = 113{,}400\) less standard \(4{,}500 \times 24 = 108{,}000\) is 5,400, so $5,400 U. 5. Judgement: the faster team saved hours, but not enough. At 4,200 hours the experiment would break even only at a rate of \(108{,}000 \div 4{,}200 \approx 25.71\), about $25.71 an hour.

Labour in modern settings

The variances assume labour cost moves with the hours worked. In many firms that is no longer quite true. Where workers are salaried or guaranteed a full week, a favourable efficiency variance may not save any cash; it frees time that managers can use for training, maintenance or more output. Highly automated plants have little direct labour, so they often set standards in machine hours instead. Service businesses rely heavily on labour standards: a clinic can compare actual nurse hours per patient with a standard, and the same two formulas apply.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, using standard hours in the rate variance; it uses actual hours. Second, using the actual rate in the efficiency variance; it uses the standard rate. Third, basing standard hours on planned rather than actual output. Fourth, forgetting to find the actual rate first when you are given only total payroll and hours. Fifth, judging a favourable efficiency variance on its own, as in the skill-mix example, where a bigger unfavourable rate variance outweighed it. Sixth, blaming production for every efficiency problem when materials or scheduling caused it.

Key takeaways

The labour rate variance is (AR − SR) × AH, driven by pay rates, overtime and the mix of workers. The labour efficiency variance is (AH − SH) × SR, driven by productivity, training, machines, materials and scheduling. Because labour hours are used as they are bought, the two always add up to the total labour variance, actual payroll minus SH × SR. Positive results are unfavourable and negative favourable. Rate and efficiency variances often move in opposite directions, so judge them together and trace each to its real cause.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Total labour variance

Actual payroll − SH × SR

Pellworth March: 123,480 − 115,200 = 8,280 U.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Workers were paid $91,800 for 3,600 hours, and the output allowed 4,000 standard hours. The standard rate is $25 per hour. What is the labour rate variance?

Question 2 of 5

The standard is 2 hours per unit at $18 per hour. A company made 1,500 units in 2,850 hours. What is the labour efficiency variance?

Question 3 of 5

A rate variance is $4,000 U and an efficiency variance is $6,500 F. What is the total labour variance?

Question 4 of 5

Which event would most likely cause an unfavourable labour rate variance but a favourable labour efficiency variance?

Question 5 of 5

Why do the labour rate and efficiency variances always add up to the total labour variance?

← Previous topicNext topic →