Accounting › Section U · Standard costs and variances › Topic U.2

Materials variances

When materials cost more or less than standard, managers need to know whether the company paid a different price or used a different amount. Splitting the total materials variance answers exactly that question.

Two reasons materials cost can differ

Developing standard costs built a standard cost card for Pellworth Pottery's planter: 4 kg of clay at $1.50 per kg. If the clay used for a month's output costs more than standard, there are only two possible reasons. Pellworth may have paid more than $1.50 per kg, or it may have used more than 4 kg per planter, or both. The total materials variance is actual materials cost minus the standard cost of the materials allowed for actual output. It is split into a price variance and a quantity variance, because different people control each, and a single total would blur them together.

The materials price variance

The price variance measures what the company paid compared with the standard price, on the quantity actually bought:

\text{Price var.} = (AP - SP) \times AQ

Here AP is the actual price per unit of material, SP the standard price and AQ the actual quantity purchased. Using this section's convention, actual minus standard, a positive result is unfavourable (U) and a negative one favourable (F). Most companies compute it when materials are purchased, not when they are used, so the purchasing department, which usually controls price, hears about a problem at once instead of weeks later when the stock reaches the factory floor.

The materials quantity variance

The quantity variance, also called the usage variance, measures how much material was used compared with the amount allowed for the output actually produced:

\text{Qty var.} = (AQ - SQ) \times SP

Here AQ is the actual quantity used and SQ the standard quantity allowed: units produced times the standard quantity per unit. The difference is valued at the standard price on purpose. If the actual price were used, a price rise would make the quantity variance look worse even though production used the material just as well. Production managers usually answer for this variance.

Three columns that tie together

A tidy way to compute both variances is to list three amounts. Column 1 is \(AQ \times AP\), the actual cost. Column 2 is \(AQ \times SP\), the actual quantity at the standard price. Column 3 is \(SQ \times SP\), the standard cost of actual output. Column 1 minus column 2 is the price variance; column 2 minus column 3 is the quantity variance; column 1 minus column 3 is the total. Because column 2 cancels, the two parts always add up to the total when the same quantity is purchased and used, which is a quick check on the arithmetic.

Worked example: Pellworth's March clay

In March Pellworth made 9,600 planters. It bought and used 39,200 kg of clay for $56,840. 1. Actual price: \(56{,}840 \div 39{,}200 = 1.45\), or $1.45 per kg. 2. Standard quantity allowed: \(9{,}600 \times 4 = 38{,}400\) kg. 3. Price variance: \((1.45 - 1.50) \times 39{,}200 = -1{,}960\), so $1,960 F. 4. Quantity variance: \((39{,}200 - 38{,}400) \times 1.50 = 1{,}200\), so $1,200 U. 5. Total: the standard cost is \(38{,}400 \times 1.50 = 57{,}600\), and \(56{,}840 - 57{,}600 = -760\), so $760 F. 6. Check: \(-1{,}960 + 1{,}200 = -760\). Clay was cheaper but 800 kg more was used than allowed.

When purchases and usage differ

Companies rarely use exactly what they buy in a month, because some material goes into or comes out of storeroom stock. The price variance is still computed on the quantity purchased, and the quantity variance on the quantity used. The two figures then describe different quantities, so they do not add up to the variance on materials used. Some companies prefer to compute the price variance on the quantity used instead; then the parts do add up, but the warning about price arrives later. Either way, state which quantity you used, and never mix the two in one formula.

Worked example: Pellworth's April clay

In April Pellworth bought 42,000 kg of clay at $1.53 per kg, a total of $64,260, and used 41,000 kg to make 10,100 planters. 1. Standard quantity allowed: \(10{,}100 \times 4 = 40{,}400\) kg. 2. Price variance on purchases: \((1.53 - 1.50) \times 42{,}000 = 1{,}260\), so $1,260 U. 3. Quantity variance on usage: \((41{,}000 - 40{,}400) \times 1.50 = 900\), so $900 U. 4. For a reconciliation on usage, the price variance on the 41,000 kg used is \(0.03 \times 41{,}000 = 1{,}230\) U, and the total on usage is \(62{,}730 - 60{,}600 = 2{,}130\) U (41,000 kg at $1.53 less 40,400 kg at $1.50), which equals \(1{,}230 + 900\). The other 1,000 kg stays in stock.

Why price variances arise

An unfavourable price variance can come from a general rise in market prices, a rush order that needed express freight, buying in smaller lots and losing a quantity discount, or buying a higher grade of material than the standard assumes. A favourable one can come from a new supplier, a bulk purchase, a falling market, or buying a lower grade. That last cause is the warning: a favourable price variance is not automatically good news. And if market prices have simply moved, the standard itself may be out of date and need revising rather than anyone needing blame.

Why quantity variances arise

Unfavourable quantity variances often come from poor-quality material that breaks or must be scrapped, inexperienced or poorly supervised workers, badly maintained machines, theft, or spoilage in storage. Favourable ones can follow better training, new equipment or a design change. The two materials variances are often linked. Pellworth's cheaper clay in March gave a $1,960 favourable price variance, but if it cracked more easily it could explain the $1,200 unfavourable quantity variance. Purchasing and production should then discuss the clay together, because the net saving of $760 might vanish once extra labour time is counted.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, using planned output instead of actual output to find the standard quantity allowed. Second, valuing the quantity variance at the actual price, which mixes a price effect into a usage measure. Third, applying the price variance to the quantity used when the company's policy computes it on purchases, or the reverse. Fourth, getting the sign backwards: with actual minus standard, a positive figure is unfavourable. Fifth, treating every favourable price variance as a success without checking what happened to usage and quality.

Key takeaways

The materials price variance is (AP − SP) × AQ purchased, usually computed at purchase so purchasing gets early warning. The quantity variance is (AQ used − SQ) × SP, valued at standard price so it reflects usage alone. When purchases equal usage, the two add up to the total materials variance, actual cost minus SQ × SP. Positive results are unfavourable and negative results favourable. The variances are often linked, so a cheap material that causes waste may cost more overall.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Total materials variance

Actual materials cost − SQ × SP

Pellworth March: 56,840 − 57,600 = 760 F.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A company bought 5,000 metres of fabric at $4.20 per metre and used 4,000 metres this month. The standard price is $4.00 per metre, and price variances are computed at purchase. What is the materials price variance?

Question 2 of 5

The standard is 3 kg per unit at $6 per kg. A company made 1,000 units using 3,200 kg bought at $5.80. What is the materials quantity variance?

Question 3 of 5

Using the same facts (3,200 kg bought and used at $5.80; standard 3,000 kg at $6), what is the total materials variance?

Question 4 of 5

Why is the materials quantity variance valued at the standard price rather than the actual price?

Question 5 of 5

A buyer switched to a cheaper, lower-grade wood. The price variance was $2,400 F and the quantity variance $3,100 U. What is the best conclusion?

← Previous topicNext topic →