Accounting › Section U · Standard costs and variances › Topic U.4

Overhead variances

Overhead is charged to products at standard rates, so at month end the overhead applied rarely equals the overhead actually incurred. Four variances explain the gap: two for variable overhead and two for fixed.

Applying overhead at standard

Pellworth Pottery's standard cost card, from Developing standard costs, charges each planter 0.5 direct labour hours of overhead: $8 per hour variable and $10 per hour fixed. In a standard cost system, overhead is applied using the standard hours allowed for actual output, not the actual hours worked as in the normal costing of Predetermined overhead rates:

\text{Applied OH} = SH \times \text{rate}

The total overhead variance is actual overhead minus applied overhead, the same under- or overapplied overhead met in Costing a job and fixing misapplied overhead. Positive is unfavourable (U), meaning underapplied; negative is favourable (F), meaning overapplied. Variable and fixed overhead behave differently, so each is analysed separately.

Variable overhead spending variance

Variable overhead, such as power, supplies and indirect materials, should rise with the activity base. The spending variance compares actual variable overhead with what the flexible budget allows for the hours actually worked:

\text{Spending} = \text{Actual VOH} - AH \times SR

Here SR is the standard variable overhead rate per hour. Some books call this the rate variance. It mixes price and usage: higher power prices and wasteful power use both show up here, so the supervisor usually has to examine the individual cost lines to explain it. A rise in one item can also hide a fall in another.

Variable overhead efficiency variance

The efficiency variance compares actual hours with standard hours allowed, valued at the variable overhead rate:

\text{Efficiency} = (AH - SH) \times SR

Despite its name, it says nothing about how efficiently overhead items were used. It measures the overhead cost of using the activity base inefficiently: if variable overhead truly moves with labour hours, every extra labour hour also draws $8 of power and supplies. That is why, when overhead is applied by labour hours, the variable overhead efficiency variance always has the same sign as the labour efficiency variance in Labor variances. Fix the labour hours and this variance follows.

Worked example: Pellworth's March variable overhead

In March Pellworth made 9,600 planters, its potters worked 5,040 hours, and actual variable overhead was $39,060. 1. Standard hours allowed: \(9{,}600 \times 0.5 = 4{,}800\). 2. Spending: the flexible budget for actual hours is \(5{,}040 \times 8 = 40{,}320\), and \(39{,}060 - 40{,}320 = -1{,}260\), so $1,260 F; the actual rate was \(39{,}060 \div 5{,}040 = 7.75\) per hour. 3. Efficiency: \((5{,}040 - 4{,}800) \times 8 = 1{,}920\), so $1,920 U. 4. Total: applied is \(4{,}800 \times 8 = 38{,}400\), and \(39{,}060 - 38{,}400 = 660\), so $660 U. 5. Check: \(-1{,}260 + 1{,}920 = 660\). Spending per hour was good; the 240 extra labour hours were not.

Fixed overhead budget variance

Fixed overhead, such as rent, salaried supervision and depreciation, should not change with activity in the short run. So the flexible budget allows the same fixed amount at any output, and actual fixed overhead is compared with that budget:

\text{Budget var.} = \text{Actual} - \text{Budget}

with both figures for fixed overhead. This is also called the fixed overhead spending variance. It is the controllable part of fixed overhead: a rise in insurance premiums, an unplanned supervisor's salary or an extra maintenance contract shows up here. There is no fixed overhead efficiency variance, because fixed costs do not depend on the hours worked.

Fixed overhead volume variance

Fixed overhead is applied at a rate per hour, as if it were variable, but it is not. The fixed rate was set by dividing the budget by the denominator hours, so applied fixed overhead equals the budget only when standard hours allowed equal the denominator hours. The volume variance measures the difference:

\text{Volume var.} = \text{Budget} - SH \times FR

Budget is the budgeted fixed overhead and FR the fixed rate. Under this section's convention it is unfavourable when output falls short of the denominator level, leaving capacity idle, and favourable when output exceeds it. It is not a spending measure: cutting costs cannot change it, only producing more or less.

Worked example: Pellworth's March fixed overhead

The fixed overhead budget is $50,000 for a denominator of 5,000 hours, so $10 per hour; actual fixed overhead was $51,200. 1. Budget variance: \(51{,}200 - 50{,}000 = 1{,}200\), so $1,200 U. 2. Applied: \(4{,}800 \times 10 = 48{,}000\). 3. Volume variance: \(50{,}000 - 48{,}000 = 2{,}000\), so $2,000 U, because output allowed only 4,800 of the planned 5,000 hours. 4. Total: \(51{,}200 - 48{,}000 = 3{,}200\), so $3,200 U. 5. Check: \(1{,}200 + 2{,}000 = 3{,}200\). 6. Total overhead: \(660 + 3{,}200 = 3{,}860\) U, which equals actual overhead of $90,260 minus applied overhead of $86,400: overhead was underapplied by $3,860.

Worked example: a busy month

In June Pellworth made 10,500 planters in 5,100 hours, with actual variable overhead of $41,820 and fixed overhead of $49,400. 1. Standard hours allowed: \(10{,}500 \times 0.5 = 5{,}250\). 2. Variable spending: \(41{,}820 - 5{,}100 \times 8 = 1{,}020\) U. 3. Variable efficiency: \((5{,}100 - 5{,}250) \times 8 = -1{,}200\), so $1,200 F; total variable \(41{,}820 - 42{,}000 = -180\), so $180 F. 4. Fixed budget: \(49{,}400 - 50{,}000 = -600\), so $600 F. 5. Volume: \(50{,}000 - 5{,}250 \times 10 = -2{,}500\), so $2,500 F, as output beat the denominator. 6. Total fixed: \(49{,}400 - 52{,}500 = -3{,}100\), so $3,100 F.

The two-variance view

Some companies report only two overhead variances. The controllable variance is actual total overhead minus the flexible budget for standard hours allowed; it combines variable spending, variable efficiency and the fixed budget variance. The volume variance is the same as before. For Pellworth in March, the flexible budget at 4,800 hours is \(4{,}800 \times 8 + 50{,}000 = 88{,}400\), so the controllable variance is \(90{,}260 - 88{,}400 = 1{,}860\) U, which equals \(-1{,}260 + 1{,}920 + 1{,}200\). Adding the $2,000 U volume variance again gives $3,860 U.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, applying overhead on actual hours instead of standard hours allowed. Second, computing a fixed overhead efficiency variance; none exists. Third, comparing actual fixed overhead with applied fixed overhead and calling the whole gap a spending problem: part of it is volume. Fourth, treating an unfavourable volume variance as overspending; it means idle capacity. Fifth, reading the variable overhead efficiency variance as a measure of how carefully power or supplies were used; it follows the activity base. Sixth, dividing fixed overhead by actual hours to set the rate.

Key takeaways

In a standard cost system, overhead is applied as SH × rate, and actual minus applied overhead is the total overhead variance. Variable overhead splits into spending, actual VOH − AH × SR, and efficiency, (AH − SH) × SR. Fixed overhead splits into the budget variance, actual minus budgeted fixed overhead, and the volume variance, budget − SH × FR. Positive is unfavourable, negative favourable, and the four parts sum to the under- or overapplied overhead. The volume variance reflects capacity use, not spending.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Applied overhead (standard costing)

SH × standard overhead rate

Standard hours allowed, not actual hours.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Actual variable overhead was $26,400 for 3,200 hours worked, and 3,000 standard hours were allowed for actual output. The standard variable overhead rate is $8 per hour. What is the variable overhead spending variance?

Question 2 of 5

Using the same facts (actual variable overhead $26,400 for 3,200 hours, 3,000 standard hours allowed, rate $8 per hour), what is the variable overhead efficiency variance?

Question 3 of 5

Budgeted fixed overhead is $60,000 at a denominator of 6,000 hours. Standard hours allowed for actual output were 5,400. What is the fixed overhead volume variance?

Question 4 of 5

A plant reports a large unfavourable fixed overhead volume variance but a zero budget variance. What does this most likely mean?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about the variable overhead efficiency variance is correct when overhead is applied by direct labour hours?

← Previous topicNext topic →