Accounting › Section W · Short-term decision making › Topic W.2

Accepting or rejecting a special order

A customer offers to buy a large batch at a price below your usual one. Whether that is a bargain or a mistake depends on one question above all: is there spare capacity to make the extra units?

What a special order is

A special order is a one-time request, usually at a price below the normal selling price, that falls outside the firm's regular market and is not expected to change its normal sales. A bicycle maker might be asked for 300 bikes for a city hire scheme; a hotel might be asked to house a conference at a group rate. The decision uses the tools of "Relevant information and sunk costs": compare only the future revenues and costs that differ between accepting and rejecting. The answer depends on the firm's capacity, on which costs the order really adds, and on several qualitative and legal points.

Start with capacity

Capacity is the output a firm can achieve with its present machines, space and staff. Normal capacity, the level it can sustain without adding resources, is often below the theoretical maximum, and the gap between normal capacity and current output is spare capacity. Within the relevant range from "Variable, fixed, and mixed costs", total fixed costs stay the same, so units made with spare capacity add only variable costs and any costs specific to the order. Once an order would push output beyond capacity, the firm must either give up some regular sales or pay for more capacity, such as an extra shift. Labour can usually be added more quickly than machines.

The rule when there is spare capacity

With enough spare capacity, accept the order if its incremental revenue exceeds its incremental costs. Incremental costs are the variable costs the order will actually cause, plus any costs that exist only because of the order, such as special packaging, a one-off setup or extra shipping. Leave out variable costs the order will not incur: a sales commission that is not paid on a direct order, for example. Fixed costs that will be incurred anyway are irrelevant. The lowest acceptable price is therefore the incremental cost per unit; any price above it adds to operating income, before qualitative factors.

The full-cost trap

Many firms quote a full cost per unit that includes a share of fixed overhead. Comparing a special-order price with that figure is the commonest error in these decisions. Spreading fixed overhead over units makes it look as if every extra unit costs the full amount, but with spare capacity the factory rent, depreciation and supervisors' salaries do not rise when one more batch is made. A price below full cost can still raise profit, as long as it exceeds the incremental cost. In the language of "Contribution margin", an order with a positive contribution margin, after any order-specific costs, makes the firm better off when capacity is idle.

Worked example: spare capacity at Saltash Kayaks

Saltash Kayaks, a fictional maker, can build 6,000 kayaks a year and sells 4,500 at $640. Each costs $380 in variable manufacturing cost plus a $40 sales commission; fixed manufacturing costs of $630,000 work out at $140 per kayak, so full cost is $560. A rental chain offers $470 each for 1,000 kayaks bearing its logo, ordered directly with no commission. The logo adds $15 per kayak and a one-off $6,000 printing screen. 1. Spare capacity is 1,500, so the order fits. 2. Fixed costs do not change, so they are irrelevant. 3. Incremental analysis:

\begin{array}{lr}\text{Revenue}&470{,}000\\\text{Variable cost}&(395{,}000)\\\text{Logo screen}&(6{,}000)\\\hline\text{Gain}&69{,}000\end{array}

4. Accept: operating income rises by $69,000 although $470 is below the $560 full cost. The lowest acceptable price is $401,000 ÷ 1,000 = $401.

When the plant is already busy

Without enough spare capacity, the order has a further cost. If the firm fills it by making fewer regular units, the contribution margin those regular sales would have earned is lost; that lost margin is the opportunity cost of the order and belongs in the analysis. If instead the firm adds capacity, the extra costs of doing so, such as overtime premiums, a temporary supervisor or rented equipment, become relevant, even those that are fixed in nature. Either way, the lowest acceptable price rises, because the relevant costs are now the incremental costs plus the opportunity cost (or the cost of the extra capacity):

\text{Minimum price} = \frac{\text{relevant costs}}{\text{units ordered}}

Worked example: when the plant is nearly full

Next year Saltash expects to sell 5,500 kayaks to regular customers, leaving spare capacity of only 500. The rental chain repeats its offer of 1,000 kayaks at $470 and will not take a smaller batch. 1. Accepting means giving up 1,000 − 500 = 500 regular sales. 2. Each regular kayak earns a contribution margin of $640 − $380 − $40 = $220, so the opportunity cost is 500 × $220 = $110,000. 3. The order's own gain is still $69,000, so the net effect is $69,000 − $110,000 = −$41,000. 4. Reject at $470. 5. The lowest acceptable price is ($395,000 + $6,000 + $110,000) ÷ 1,000 = $511. An extra shift costing less than $110,000 would be cheaper than losing regular sales, so management should price that option too.

Qualitative factors

Numbers rarely settle a special order on their own. Regular customers who learn of a lower price may demand the same terms, and if the special units are a cheaper version, buyers may switch to it. A firm sometimes accepts a loss-making first order to win a valuable new customer, which is a deliberate qualitative judgement. Long overtime at a full plant can hurt morale and quality, and late deliveries to regular customers can damage relationships for years. Finally, a special-order price covers only incremental costs; if discounting becomes routine, total revenue may no longer cover fixed costs in the long run.

Legal limits on price differences

In the United States, the Robinson-Patman Act of 1936 restricts sellers from charging different prices to competing buyers of goods of the same grade and quality when the difference may harm competition. Defences exist, such as showing that the lower price reflects genuine cost savings or was offered to meet a competitor's price. The law applies to sales of goods rather than services, and its application is a matter for legal advice. For a special order, the practical point is simple: if the buyer competes with your regular customers, a price gap needs a sound justification before it is offered.

Common mistakes to avoid

1. Rejecting an order because its price is below full cost per unit, when spare capacity means fixed costs will not change. 2. Including variable costs the order will not incur, such as commissions on a direct sale. 3. Forgetting costs that exist only because of the order, such as setups and special packaging. 4. Ignoring the contribution margin of displaced regular sales when the plant is full. 5. Treating a one-time discount as if it could become the normal price. 6. Overlooking the reaction of regular customers and the legal rules on price differences.

Key takeaways

A special order is a one-time request, usually at a reduced price, outside normal sales. With spare capacity, accept it if incremental revenue exceeds incremental costs: the variable costs the order actually causes plus order-specific costs. Fixed costs that will be incurred anyway are irrelevant, so a price below full cost can still raise profit. Without spare capacity, add the opportunity cost of displaced regular sales, or the cost of extra capacity. Always weigh regular customers, precedent and price-discrimination law before accepting.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Special order

A one-time request, usually at a reduced price, outside normal sales

Not expected to change regular sales.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A firm with ample spare capacity sells a part for $56. Its variable cost is $36 and allocated fixed cost is $10 per unit. A customer offers $50 each for 2,000 extra units. What is the effect on operating income?

Question 2 of 5

A special order is placed directly, so the usual 5% sales commission will not be paid. How should the commission be treated in the analysis?

Question 3 of 5

A busy plant is offered 1,000 units at $30. Variable cost is $20 per unit. To make room, it must give up 400 regular units that each earn a $15 contribution margin. What is the net effect of accepting?

Question 4 of 5

Why might a firm with spare capacity reject a special order whose price exceeds its incremental cost?

Question 5 of 5

With spare capacity, an order for 500 units has variable cost of $60 per unit and a one-off setup of $4,000. Fixed overhead is $25 per unit at normal volume. What is the lowest acceptable price per unit?

← Previous topicNext topic →