Accounting › Section W · Short-term decision making › Topic W.1
Relevant information and sunk costs
Every business decision is a choice between alternatives, and most of the numbers on a manager's desk have no bearing on it. Learning to pick out the few figures that actually change from one option to the next is the core skill of short-term decision making.
Decisions are choices between alternatives
Should a workshop take an extra order, buy a part instead of making it, or close a weak product line? Each answer leads to a different future, and managerial accounting puts a money value on those futures. This section covers short-term decisions: choices whose effects play out over about a year or less and can be reversed fairly cheaply. Long-term choices, such as building a factory, tie up money for years, so the time value of money matters; they belong to "Capital investment decisions". Income taxes are ignored throughout this section.
A five-step decision process
A sound decision usually follows the same path. 1. State the goal, such as raising operating income. 2. List the realistic alternatives, including doing nothing. 3. Gather and analyse the figures for each alternative, along with the factors money cannot measure. 4. Choose the alternative that best meets the goal. 5. Afterwards, compare the actual results with the forecast. Accountants contribute most to step 3, and doing it well means knowing which numbers belong in the analysis.
What makes a cost or revenue relevant
A cost or revenue is relevant to a decision only if it passes two tests: it lies in the future, and it differs between the alternatives. Fail either test and it cannot change which option is better. The amount by which a cost differs between two alternatives is the differential cost, sometimes called the incremental cost; the difference in revenue is the differential revenue. Comparing alternatives using only these differences is differential (or incremental) analysis. It gives the same answer as a full budget for each alternative, because identical items cancel out, but it is quicker to check.
Avoidable and unavoidable costs
An avoidable cost is one that disappears, wholly or partly, if a particular alternative is chosen; an unavoidable cost continues whichever way the decision goes. Variable costs are normally avoidable, because they stop when the activity that drives them stops. Fixed costs, introduced in "Variable, fixed, and mixed costs", are often unavoidable in the short run. A lease that cannot be cancelled must be paid whether or not the space is used. Some fixed costs are avoidable, though, such as the salary of a supervisor who runs only one product line. Over a long enough horizon almost every cost becomes avoidable.
Sunk costs
A sunk cost has already been incurred and cannot be recovered by any future choice, so it is never relevant. The classic case is the book value of existing equipment: its cost minus accumulated depreciation is a record of a past purchase, and that money is gone whether the machine is kept, sold or scrapped. What can matter is the machine's resale value today, which is a future cash flow. Sunk costs are hard to ignore when they expose an earlier mistake. Pouring more money into a failing project because so much has already been spent is known as the sunk cost fallacy.
Future costs that do not differ
A cost can lie in the future and still be irrelevant, if it will be the same under every alternative. Suppose a bakery is choosing between sourdough and rye for tomorrow's oven time, and both need the same two bakers for the same hours. Those wages are real future costs, but they cannot help choose between the breads. The same goes for a share of building rent or head-office costs charged whichever option is picked. Leaving such items in does not change the right answer, but it lengthens the analysis and invites slips.
Opportunity costs
An opportunity cost is the benefit given up by choosing one alternative instead of the next best one. It never appears in the accounting records, because no transaction takes place, yet it is fully relevant. If a firm uses an empty storeroom itself, the opportunity cost is the rent a tenant would have paid. If a machine is busy with one product, it is the contribution the displaced product would have earned. When there is genuinely spare capacity with no other use, the opportunity cost of using it may be zero.
Quantitative and qualitative factors
Quantitative factors can be measured in numbers: sales, costs, hours, defect rates. Qualitative factors cannot be measured reliably in money but can still decide the matter: staff morale, customer goodwill, product quality, reputation, dependence on one supplier, or the ethics of a choice. A sound recommendation states the money difference and then the qualitative points that might outweigh it, which often settle close calls.
Worked example: a spare room at Tregarth Ceramics
Tregarth Ceramics, a fictional pottery workshop, has an empty upstairs room. It could run weekend pottery classes there, or rent the room to a yoga teacher for $900 a month. Classes would bring in $3,200 a month and need an instructor ($1,400), clay and glaze ($350) and extra kiln electricity ($150). The room carries a $1,100 share of building rent, and the kiln was bought last year for $12,000. 1. Building rent is paid either way, and the kiln cost is sunk, so both are irrelevant. 2. Classes, per month:
3. Renting yields $900, so classes win by $1,300 − $900 = $400 a month. Equivalently, the forgone rent is the opportunity cost of the classes. 4. Qualitatively, a tenant gives steadier income, while classes might win new pottery customers.
Worked example: a batch of misprinted mugs
Tregarth made 500 mugs for a café chain at a cost of $4,500, but the logo was misprinted and the café refused them. Option A: sell them to a discount outlet for $1,000. Option B: reglaze and refire them for $1,250 in total, then sell them in Tregarth's shop at $5 each. 1. The $4,500 is sunk under both options, so it is left out. 2. Option A brings in $1,000. 3. Option B brings in 500 × $5 = $2,500 less $1,250, a net $1,250. 4. Option B is better by $250, assuming all 500 mugs sell. 5. Check: neither option recovers the $4,500, and that is not the test; what matters is which leaves Tregarth better off from today.
Common mistakes to avoid
1. Including the book value of old equipment, or any other past spending, in a comparison of future alternatives. 2. Counting a cost under one option but forgetting it under the other, when it is the same for both and should cancel. 3. Treating every fixed cost as irrelevant: a fixed cost that can be avoided by one alternative belongs in the analysis. 4. Forgetting opportunity costs because they never pass through the accounts. 5. Treating a fixed cost spread per unit as if it would vary with volume. 6. Stopping at the money answer without weighing quality, customers and staff.
Key takeaways
A cost or revenue is relevant only if it lies in the future and differs between the alternatives. Differential analysis compares just those differences and reaches the same answer as full budgets. Variable costs are usually avoidable; fixed costs are relevant only when a choice can avoid them. Sunk costs, including the book value of existing assets, are never relevant, but today's resale value can be. Opportunity costs are relevant even though they are never recorded. Every recommendation should pair the money difference with the qualitative factors that could outweigh it.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A future cost that differs between the alternatives
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A machine bought two years ago for $30,000 now has a book value of $18,000. When deciding whether to replace it, how should the $18,000 be treated?
Question 2 of 5
Running evening classes in a spare room would bring in $2,000 a month and add $1,200 of instructor and materials costs. The room carries a $600 share of building rent either way, and a tenant would pay $500 a month for it. By how much do the classes beat renting?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about fixed costs in a short-term decision is correct?
Question 4 of 5
A firm uses its only delivery van for its own orders instead of hiring it out at $400 a week. What is the $400 a week?
Question 5 of 5
Which of these is a qualitative factor in deciding whether to stop making a part in-house?
