Accounting › Section S · Activity-based, variable, and absorption costing › Topic S.3

Traditional versus activity-based costing

Traditional costing and activity-based costing share out the same overhead, yet they can tell managers very different stories about which products earn money. Knowing why they differ, and what each costs to run, lets a business choose the right tool.

Same total, different shares

Whatever system a factory uses, its total overhead is the same; the systems differ only in how that total is divided among products. Halvorsen Audio, from Traditional overhead allocation and cost drivers and Activity-based product costs, has $1,500,000 of overhead shared between 40,000 Cove speakers and 5,000 Summit monitors. One plantwide rate, two departmental rates and five activity rates each assign all of it. Because the total is fixed, any cost one method moves off a product must land on another, so if one product's cost falls, another's must rise.

Three answers side by side

Overhead per unit under each method:

\begin{array}{lrr} & \text{Cove} & \text{Summit} \\ \hline \text{Plantwide} & 30.00 & 60.00 \\ \text{Departmental} & 29.00 & 68.00 \\ \text{ABC} & 20.50 & 136.00 \end{array}

Adding materials and labour, the Cove's full cost is $84, $83 or $74.50, and the Summit's $203, $211 or $279. The more closely a method follows what really consumes overhead, the further the costs drift from the simple labour-hour answer. The high-volume Cove changes by about a third, while the low-volume Summit's overhead more than doubles.

Why volume-based rates cross-subsidise

A volume-based rate charges overhead in proportion to labour or machine hours. That is accurate for unit-level costs, but batch-level and product-level costs depend on the number of setups, orders and design changes, not on volume. High-volume products, run in long batches, use few setups per unit, yet a labour-hour rate charges them for setups they did not cause. Low-volume, specialised products use many setups and changes per unit, yet are charged little. The result, often called cost distortion or cross-subsidisation, overcosts high-volume products and undercosts low-volume ones. The effect is usually much larger per unit for the low-volume product.

Worked example: measuring the distortion

Compare plantwide and ABC figures at Halvorsen, assuming every unit made is sold. 1. Cove overcosted by \(30 - 20.50 = 9.50\) dollars a unit, or \(9.50 \times 40{,}000 = 380{,}000\) in total. 2. Summit undercosted by \(136 - 60 = 76\) dollars a unit, or \(76 \times 5{,}000 = 380{,}000\). The two amounts match, as they must. 3. Product-line gross profit under one rate: Cove $1,040,000, Summit $285,000, total $1,325,000. 4. Under ABC: Cove \(35.50 \times 40{,}000 = 1{,}420{,}000\), Summit \(-19 \times 5{,}000 = -95{,}000\), total again $1,325,000. Company profit is identical; the story about where it comes from is reversed.

Worked example: pricing decisions

Halvorsen prices at full cost plus 30%. 1. Summit under one rate: \(203 \times 1.3 = 263.90\), close to its $260 price, so it looks well priced. 2. Under ABC: \(279 \times 1.3 = 362.70\), so the Summit is underpriced by about $100. 3. A rival launches a Cove-like speaker at $100. Under one rate, Halvorsen's margin at that price would be \(100 - 84 = 16\) dollars; under ABC it would be \(100 - 74.50 = 25.50\). 4. A firm trusting the labour-hour cost might abandon a profitable market for its main product while expanding a product that loses money on every sale.

Strengths of the traditional method

Traditional costing is simple and cheap: one pool, one base, one rate, and the data usually come from payroll or machine logs that exist anyway. It is easy to explain to managers and auditors. It works well when overhead is a small share of cost, when products are similar in batch size and complexity, or when overhead genuinely moves with labour or machine hours. Because it assigns all and only manufacturing overhead to products, it fits the absorption costing that GAAP requires for inventory, as Variable versus absorption costing explains.

Strengths and costs of ABC

ABC gives more realistic product and customer costs when overhead is large and products differ in complexity. It can also bring selling and service activities into product or customer costs for internal decisions, and its activity data show where effort goes, so managers can attack the drivers themselves. But it is costly: activities must be defined, costs traced to pools and driver quantities recorded, and the model goes stale as processes change. An ABC system that includes non-manufacturing costs, or leaves facility costs out, produces internal costs that cannot value inventory for external reports without adjustment.

When ABC is worth it

ABC tends to repay its cost when overhead is a large share of total cost, when products or customers differ greatly in volume, batch size or complexity, when some product lines seem unexpectedly unprofitable or competitors undercut "profitable" products, and when wrong costs lead to costly decisions. It matters less in a plant making one product or a few similar ones. Cheaper data from factory software has lowered the cost of ABC, and a simplified version, time-driven ABC, estimates how many minutes each activity takes instead of surveying staff about how they spend their time.

From costing to management

The biggest payoff from ABC often comes from activity-based management: using the activity data to reduce cost, not just to measure it. If setups drive $300,000 of cost, faster changeovers or larger batches cut it. If engineering changes are expensive, a design that shares parts across products cuts them. Non-value-added activities, such as moving, storing and reworking, become visible targets. The same thinking works in services, where it can show which customers or orders cost more to serve than they bring in.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, believing ABC raises or lowers total overhead; it redistributes it. Second, assuming ABC always raises every low-volume product's cost; it depends on which activities each product uses. Third, adopting ABC wherever possible without weighing its cost against the value of better decisions. Fourth, treating ABC unit costs as avoidable: allocated facility costs remain if a product is dropped. Fifth, using ABC internal costs, which may include selling costs, to value inventory on the balance sheet.

Key takeaways

Traditional and activity-based costing assign the same total overhead in different ways. Volume-based rates overcost high-volume, simple products and undercost low-volume, complex ones, because batch- and product-level costs do not follow volume. Distortions cancel in total, so company profit is unchanged, but product profitability and pricing can reverse. Traditional costing is cheap, simple and fits external reporting; ABC is more accurate where overhead is large and products are diverse, at a higher cost to build and maintain. Activity-based management uses ABC data to cut costs.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Total overhead

The same under every allocation method

Only the sharing changes.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Under a plantwide rate, Product A is assigned $18 of overhead per unit; under ABC it is $11. If 20,000 units of A are made, how much overhead does ABC move to other products?

Question 2 of 5

Why do volume-based overhead rates tend to undercost low-volume, complex products?

Question 3 of 5

A company moves from traditional costing to ABC. Assuming all units produced are sold, what happens to total company profit?

Question 4 of 5

In which setting is a single labour-hour rate most likely to give acceptable product costs?

Question 5 of 5

A product's ABC unit cost of $50 includes $6 of allocated facility-level cost. If the product were dropped, what would happen to that $6 a unit?

← Previous topicNext topic →