American Government › Section B · The Constitution › Topic B.3

Writing the Constitution

In the summer of 1787, delegates in Philadelphia had to build a government strong enough to work but limited enough to be trusted. Their answer combined compromises over representation and slavery with a design that separates, checks and divides power.

From Annapolis to Philadelphia

In September 1786, at Virginia's invitation, delegates from just five states met at Annapolis, Maryland, to discuss problems of interstate trade. Too few came to act, so Alexander Hamilton and James Madison persuaded them to call a broader convention, which Congress endorsed in February 1787 to revise the Articles. From May to September 1787, fifty-five delegates from twelve states met in Philadelphia; Rhode Island sent none. George Washington presided, the debates were secret, and Madison kept the fullest notes. The delegates soon chose to write a new constitution instead. The US History course follows the convention day by day; this topic examines the design it produced.

Four points of contention

Delegates disagreed along four main lines. Large and small states disputed how each should be represented in Congress. Northern and southern delegates were divided over slavery: some opposed it, while those from South Carolina and Georgia insisted it be protected. Nationalists wanted a powerful central government that could tax, defend the country and override the states, while others wanted most power to stay with the states. Finally, some stressed individual liberty and others stressed order, especially after Shays's Rebellion.

Settling representation

The Virginia Plan, drafted largely by Madison, proposed a two-house, or bicameral, Congress with seats in both houses based on population, which favoured large states. The New Jersey Plan, introduced by William Paterson, kept a one-house Congress with one vote per state but gave it new powers, including taxing imports. The Great Compromise, proposed by Connecticut's Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth, joined the two ideas. Seats in the House of Representatives would follow population, with members elected by voters for two years. Each state would have two senators, chosen by its legislature for six years. Article I, Section 7 added that "All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives".

Bargains over slavery

The Constitution protected slavery without using the word. The three-fifths clause counted three-fifths of enslaved people when apportioning House seats and direct taxes, giving slaveholding states extra seats and electoral votes. Congress could not ban the import of enslaved people before 1808. A fugitive slave clause required people who escaped bondage to be returned. Historians often describe a bargain in August 1787: delegates from South Carolina and Georgia secured the slave trade clause, while northern delegates won the power for Congress to pass trade laws by simple majority rather than two-thirds. Planters also gained a ban on taxing exports. The US History course analyses these clauses in depth.

Separation of powers

After a preamble, the Constitution has seven articles, and the first three follow Montesquieu by placing each kind of power in a separate branch. Article I creates Congress, which makes the laws. Article II creates the presidency, which carries them out. Article III creates the Supreme Court and lets Congress add lower federal courts, which decide cases under federal law. Neither a national executive nor national courts had existed under the Articles. Each branch is chosen differently and serves a different term: representatives two years, the president four, senators six, and judges during good behaviour, in practice for life.

Checks and balances

Separation alone would not stop one branch from overpowering the others, so each was given tools to restrain the rest. The president can veto a bill, and Congress can override the veto by a two-thirds vote in each house. The Senate must approve treaties by two-thirds of senators present and confirm judges and senior officials by a majority. The House can impeach officials by a simple majority, and the Senate can remove them by a two-thirds vote; the Chief Justice presides over a president's trial. The courts' power to strike down unconstitutional laws, judicial review, was established in Marbury v. Madison in 1803.

Worked example: checks on one bill

Follow a bill the president opposes, with every member present. 1. Passage: a majority of the House, at least 218 of 435, and of the Senate, at least 51 of 100 (or 50 plus the vice president's tie-breaking vote), approve it. 2. The veto: the president returns it unsigned with objections. 3. The override: two-thirds of those voting in each chamber is needed, so 290 representatives and 67 senators. 4. Judicial review: if it becomes law, someone harmed by it can sue, and the courts may strike it down. 5. Enforcement: the executive branch carries it out, and Congress can scrutinise how. 6. Check: each branch had a separate chance to stop the bill.

Federalism: dividing national and state power

The framers also divided power vertically, creating a federal system. Enumerated powers are those listed for Congress, chiefly in Article I, Section 8: to tax, borrow, regulate commerce with foreign nations, among the states and with Native nations, coin money, declare war, raise armies and a navy, run a post office and set naturalisation rules. Powers not given to the national government were left to the states, a principle the Tenth Amendment later made explicit: these reserved powers include most criminal law, schooling and marriage. Concurrent powers, such as taxing and borrowing, belong to both levels. A later section examines federalism in depth.

The supremacy and elastic clauses

Two clauses tilt the balance towards the nation. The supremacy clause in Article VI declares that the Constitution, federal laws made under it, and treaties "shall be the supreme Law of the Land", binding state judges. The final clause of Article I, Section 8 lets Congress "make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers". This necessary and proper clause, often called the elastic clause, allows Congress to choose the means for exercising its listed powers. How far it stretches has been argued over ever since.

Worked example: reading the elastic clause

In 1791 Congress chartered a national bank, though no listed power mentions banks. 1. The text: Congress may pass laws necessary and proper for executing its enumerated powers. 2. A narrow reading, Jefferson's: necessary means essential, and a bank is merely convenient, so it is unconstitutional. 3. A broad reading, Hamilton's: necessary means useful or conducive, and a bank helps Congress tax, borrow and regulate commerce. 4. The outcome: Washington accepted Hamilton's view; in McCulloch v. Maryland in 1819, the Supreme Court upheld a later national bank on similar reasoning. 5. Conclusion: one word's meaning set the reach of national power.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, saying the three-fifths clause defined a person as three-fifths human; it was an apportionment rule that boosted slaveholding states' power. Second, confusing separation of powers, dividing functions among branches, with checks and balances, letting each branch restrain the others. Third, thinking judicial review is written in the text; it was established by the Court in 1803. Fourth, believing voters chose senators in 1789; state legislatures did until the Seventeenth Amendment of 1913.

Key takeaways

The 1787 convention replaced the Articles rather than revising them. The Great Compromise created a House based on population and a Senate with two members per state, and revenue bills begin in the House. Clauses on apportionment, the slave trade and fugitives protected slavery. The Constitution separates legislative, executive and judicial power and gives each branch checks on the others. Federalism divides enumerated national powers from reserved state powers, with some concurrent. The supremacy clause makes federal law supreme, and the necessary and proper clause lets Congress choose the means to exercise its powers.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Annapolis Convention, 1786

Five-state meeting on trade that called for the Philadelphia convention

Hamilton and Madison pushed it forward.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did the Great Compromise settle the dispute between large and small states?

Question 2 of 5

The president vetoes a bill. With all members present and voting, what does Congress need to override the veto?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement correctly distinguishes separation of powers from checks and balances?

Question 4 of 5

Under the necessary and proper clause, Hamilton argued that Congress could charter a national bank because

Question 5 of 5

Which of these powers is concurrent, held by both the national government and the states?

← Previous topicNext topic →