American Government › Section Q · Foreign policy › Topic Q.1
Defining foreign policy
Foreign policy decides how the United States deals with the rest of the world, from trade deals and embassies to alliances and war. Understanding its goals, its main areas and its peculiar challenges is the first step to judging any foreign-policy choice.
What foreign policy is
Foreign policy is the set of goals a government pursues beyond its borders, the values behind those goals, and the means it uses to reach them. Like other policy, it is built up from many decisions, not made once: American policy towards China, for example, has been shaped by many presidents, secretaries of state, members of Congress and career officials. It is also purposive, meaning deliberate: when the United States signs a trade pact or an arms-control agreement, it does so for stated reasons. Domestic policy, by contrast, deals with matters inside the country, such as schools, policing or health insurance.
Where foreign and domestic meet
The line between foreign and domestic policy is often blurred. Immigration affects both relations with other countries and jobs, schools and politics at home. Tariffs on imports protect some domestic industries while raising costs for consumers and inviting retaliation abroad. Energy prices depend on events in distant oil-producing regions. Scholars sometimes call such issues intermestic, a blend of international and domestic. Because these issues touch voters' daily lives, members of Congress and interest groups take a keen interest in them, whereas purely diplomatic matters, such as relations with a small, distant country, attract much less public attention.
Four broad goals
A common way to summarise American foreign policy identifies four broad goals. First, security: protecting the country, its citizens at home and abroad, and its allies from attack by states, terrorist groups or other threats. Second, prosperity: keeping access to resources, markets and investment, and helping American businesses sell abroad. Third, stability: preserving a balance of power, where no single state or bloc can dominate the rest, and so reducing the risk of major war. Fourth, values: promoting democracy and human rights. Which goal comes first, and how each is best pursued, is constantly debated between parties and administrations.
When goals collide
The four goals do not always point the same way. Security and prosperity can push the United States to work closely with governments that do not share its values: it has long had close security and economic ties with Saudi Arabia, a monarchy, for example. Promoting human rights can mean criticising or sanctioning a major trading partner, at some cost to American exporters. Pursuing stability may mean accepting an unfriendly government rather than risking a war to change it. Critics on different sides charge either that policy is too idealistic, ignoring hard interests, or too cynical, betraying the values the country claims to uphold.
Worked example: weighing the goals
Imagine a proposed free trade agreement with a fast-growing country that has a poor record on workers' rights. 1. Prosperity: lower tariffs would open markets for American farmers and manufacturers, but some domestic industries could face stiffer competition. 2. Security and stability: closer economic ties could draw the country away from a rival power. 3. Values: human rights groups and unions object to rewarding labour abuses. 4. A possible compromise: include enforceable labour standards in the agreement. 5. Conclusion: the decision turns on how leaders rank the four goals, which is why trade deals often divide parties and interest groups.
Trade, diplomacy and sanctions
Foreign policy covers several distinct areas. Trade policy governs the flow of goods and services. Protectionism shields domestic producers with high tariffs, taxes on imports, or other barriers, while free trade lowers them. The balance of trade compares exports with imports; the United States has run a trade deficit, importing more than it exports, in every year since the mid-1970s. Diplomacy is the formal relationship between governments, conducted by ambassadors working from embassies; it is usually the first tool used in a dispute, and recalling an ambassador signals serious displeasure. Economic sanctions cut off trade or financial dealings with a country, group or person to pressure a change in behaviour.
Defence, intelligence, aid and environment
Military and defence policy prepares the armed forces to deter and, if necessary, fight wars, and maintains American bases and alliances around the world. Intelligence policy covers gathering information about foreign governments and groups, openly or secretly, and analysing it for leaders. Foreign aid gives money, goods or expertise to other countries for development, emergencies or security; it has usually been around 1 percent of federal spending, although surveys find many Americans guess it is far larger. Global environmental policy deals with problems no country can solve alone, such as climate change and ocean pollution. The United States has joined and left the 2015 Paris Agreement on climate change more than once.
International organisations
The United States helped create many of the institutions that structure world politics. The United Nations, founded in 1945 after fifty countries drafted its charter in San Francisco, now has 193 members. All sit in the General Assembly, while the Security Council has fifteen members, including five permanent members, the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Russia and China, each of which can veto a resolution. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), formed in 1949 by twelve countries, is a military alliance that now has 32 members. Its Article 5 treats an armed attack on one member as an attack on all, and it has been invoked only once, after the attacks of 11 September 2001.
Five special challenges
Foreign policy faces difficulties that domestic policy usually does not. First, no world government exists to enforce agreements, so international politics rests on bargaining and voluntary cooperation. Second, countries hold very different views of what government should do for its people. Third, they have different forms of government, from democracies to absolute monarchies and dictatorships, which can make agreement harder. Fourth, many problems, such as terrorism, pandemics, human trafficking and climate change, are transnational: they cross borders and do not belong to any single state. Fifth, countries differ hugely in wealth and stability, so a fragile state may be unable to keep its promises, however willing its leaders.
Worked example: a transnational threat
Suppose a criminal group operating from several countries uses ransomware to shut down American hospitals. 1. Identify the actor: a non-state group, not a government, so traditional diplomacy has no single target. 2. Check sovereignty: the attackers sit inside other states' borders, where American police have no authority. 3. Choose tools: intelligence to identify the group, diplomacy to seek cooperation from host governments, and sanctions on members and their finances. 4. Recognise limits: a weak or unwilling host government may not act. 5. Conclusion: transnational threats push policy towards intelligence, cooperation among many states and targeted measures rather than one-to-one bargaining.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating foreign and domestic policy as entirely separate; trade, immigration and energy are both. Second, assuming the four goals always agree; security or prosperity often competes with promoting values. Third, thinking the United Nations is a world government; it has no army of its own and relies on members' cooperation. Fourth, believing any of the fifteen Security Council members can veto a resolution; only the five permanent members can. Fifth, overestimating foreign aid; it is a small share of federal spending.
Key takeaways
Foreign policy is a purposive pattern of actions towards other countries, often entangled with domestic, or intermestic, issues. Its four broad goals are security, prosperity, a stable balance of power, and democracy and human rights, which sometimes collide. Its areas include trade, diplomacy, sanctions, defence, intelligence, foreign aid and environmental policy. The UN (1945, 193 members) and NATO (1949, now 32 members) structure cooperation, with vetoes for five permanent Security Council members and Article 5 invoked once, after 9/11. No world government enforces agreements, and transnational threats cross borders.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A government's goals abroad, the values behind them and the means used
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Debates over immigration involve relations with other countries and also jobs and schools at home. What do scholars call such issues?
Question 2 of 5
The United States maintains close ties with a monarchy that does not share its democratic values because the partnership supports regional security and energy supplies. Which tension does this show?
Question 3 of 5
A resolution in the UN Security Council wins 13 of 15 votes, but France votes against it. What happens?
Question 4 of 5
When has NATO's Article 5, the collective defence clause, been invoked?
Question 5 of 5
Why is foreign policy harder to enforce than domestic law?
