American Government › Section C · Federalism › Topic C.4

Competitive federalism today

Today the states and Washington do not simply share tasks; they compete, sue each other and race to set policy first. Advocates on every side exploit that rivalry, carrying their causes to whichever level of government seems most likely to listen.

What makes federalism competitive

Some tasks still belong clearly to one level: national defence to Washington, driving licences to the states, rubbish collection to towns. But on many issues the levels now overlap and contend. Competitive federalism describes two related features of that contest. First, states and the national government push into each other's territory, and federal courts have to sort out the boundary. Second, interest groups choose the level, and the branch, most likely to give them what they want. Political scientists also use the term for competition among the states themselves, which bid for residents and businesses with different mixes of taxes, services and rules. Crises show the overlap: during the COVID-19 pandemic, states and cities issued most public health orders, from mask rules to business closures, so policies differed sharply, while Washington supplied money, vaccines and guidance.

Immigration federalism

Immigration and naturalisation have long been national matters, resting on Congress's power to "establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization." Since the late 1990s, however, states have passed hundreds of immigration-related laws, a trend called immigration federalism. Some states, saying federal enforcement was too weak, passed laws to step it up. Others, and many cities, adopted what are often called sanctuary policies, which limit how far their police help federal immigration agents; their defenders cite the anti-commandeering principle from the topic "The division of powers." Critics argue that such policies obstruct federal enforcement and endanger public safety; defenders reply that they help immigrants trust and report crimes to local police. Supporters of each approach see it as a legitimate use of state power; opponents see it as interfering with national policy.

Arizona v. United States (2012)

In 2010 Arizona passed Senate Bill 1070, aiming to make life hard enough for unauthorised immigrants that they would leave, a strategy its backers called "attrition through enforcement." The federal government sued, arguing that federal law pre-empted it. In Arizona v. United States (2012), the Supreme Court, in an opinion by Justice Anthony Kennedy, struck down three of the four disputed provisions: making it a state crime to lack immigration papers, making it a crime for an unauthorised immigrant to seek work, and allowing warrantless arrests of people thought removable. It let stand, for the time being, the provision requiring officers to check the immigration status of people they lawfully stop when they suspect unlawful presence, leaving room for later challenges to how it was applied.

Worked example: a pre-emption analysis

Use Arizona to see how courts decide such clashes. 1. Identify the federal scheme: Congress has written detailed rules on registration, employment and removal of immigrants. 2. Ask whether the state law punishes what federal law already covers in full. The papers crime did, so it was pre-empted. 3. Ask whether the state law upsets a balance Congress chose. Congress punishes employers, not workers, for unauthorised work, so the job-seeking crime was pre-empted. 4. Ask whether state officers act alone where federal officers decide. Warrantless arrests for removal did, so that part fell. 5. Status checks simply passed information to federal officers, so they survived. 6. Lesson: supremacy works provision by provision.

Marriage: from states to the nation

Marriage law was traditionally left to the states. In 1996, after a Hawaii court ruling suggested that state might allow same-sex marriage, Congress passed the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA). It defined marriage for federal purposes as between a man and a woman and said no state had to recognise another state's same-sex marriages. Many states banned such marriages, while Massachusetts became the first to allow them, in 2004. In United States v. Windsor (2013) the Court struck down DOMA's federal definition. Lower federal courts then overturned many state bans, and in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) the Court held that the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees same-sex couples the right to marry. The Respect for Marriage Act (2022) repealed DOMA and requires federal and interstate recognition of same-sex and interracial marriages.

Venue shopping

Federalism gives advocates many doors to knock on: Congress or a state legislature, a federal or state court, the president or a governor. Venue shopping is the strategy of choosing the venue that looks most receptive and moving when one door closes. Groups across the political spectrum do it. Gun-rights and gun-control groups, environmental groups and business associations all switch between state and national arenas. State attorneys general of both parties regularly sue federal administrations they oppose, often filing in courts they expect to be sympathetic.

Worked example: MADD and the drinking age

Trace a venue-shopping campaign. 1. Goal: Mothers Against Drunk Driving, founded in 1980, wanted a drinking age of 21 everywhere. 2. First venue: state legislatures. Progress was patchy, partly because states with lower ages drew young drinkers from neighbouring states. 3. Switch: MADD lobbied Congress instead. 4. Tool: the National Minimum Drinking Age Act (1984) withheld part of highway funds from states below 21, the condition upheld in South Dakota v. Dole, as the topic "Intergovernmental relations and grants" explained. 5. Outcome: every state had a drinking age of 21 by 1988. 6. Lesson: a national venue solved a problem that state-by-state competition had kept alive.

Abortion after Roe and Dobbs

Abortion shows venue shopping in both directions. After Roe v. Wade (1973) recognised a constitutional right to abortion, opponents first sought a constitutional amendment, won limits on federal funding but no amendment, and increasingly turned to state legislatures, where they won rules on parental involvement, waiting periods and public funding. After Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022) held that the Constitution does not confer a right to abortion, the battle moved fully to the states. Some states restricted abortion sharply; others wrote protections into law or their constitutions, sometimes by ballot measure. Advocates on both sides also continue to press Congress and the federal courts, for example over abortion medication.

States racing ahead of Washington

States also compete by acting first on issues Congress has not settled. About two dozen states now allow recreational marijuana, although it remains illegal under federal law, and Gonzales v. Raich (2005) confirmed that the federal ban reaches even home-grown medical use; federal enforcement choices largely decide how far those markets can grow. In Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association (2018) the Court struck down a federal law forbidding states to authorise sports betting, as a form of commandeering, and many states then legalised it. Supporters call such divergence healthy experimentation; critics call it a confusing patchwork.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, Arizona v. United States did not strike down the whole of SB 1070: the status-check provision survived for the time being. Second, Windsor (2013) struck down DOMA's federal definition of marriage; the nationwide right to marry came two years later in Obergefell. Third, venue shopping is not a tactic of one side only; groups across the spectrum use it. Fourth, Dobbs did not ban abortion; it removed a federal constitutional right and left the issue to elected officials. Fifth, state legalisation of marijuana does not change federal law.

Key takeaways

Competitive federalism means levels of government contend over overlapping issues and advocates pick the most receptive venue. Immigration federalism brought state laws both tougher and gentler than federal policy; Arizona v. United States (2012) struck down three of four contested SB 1070 provisions as pre-empted. Marriage moved from DOMA (1996) through Windsor (2013) to Obergefell (2015) and the Respect for Marriage Act (2022). MADD's switch to Congress produced a drinking age of 21 everywhere by 1988. Abortion policy moved to the states after Dobbs (2022). States also race ahead on issues such as marijuana and sports betting.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Competitive federalism

Levels of government contend over overlapping issues, and advocates pick their venue

Also used for states competing for people and business.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In Arizona v. United States (2012), what happened to SB 1070?

Question 2 of 5

What did United States v. Windsor (2013) decide?

Question 3 of 5

An advocacy group fails to persuade state legislatures, so it lobbies Congress to attach conditions to federal grants. What is this strategy called?

Question 4 of 5

Why did MADD turn from state legislatures to Congress in the early 1980s?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about abortion policy after Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022) is accurate?

← Previous topicNext topic →