American Government › Section C · Federalism › Topic C.5

Advantages and disadvantages of federalism

Federalism lets fifty states try fifty answers. That can spark invention, widen participation and respect local values, but it can also leave Americans with very unequal services and make national problems harder to solve. Judging it means weighing both.

A design with trade-offs

The framers chose federalism partly to protect liberty. James Madison argued in Federalist No. 51 that splitting power between two levels, and then among branches within each, gave the people a "double security": each government would check the other. More than two centuries on, the same design produces both strengths and weaknesses. Supporters stress innovation, participation and respect for diversity. Critics stress inequality between states, harmful competition and gridlock on national issues. Most scholars see a mix, and which side weighs more often depends on the issue and on who is asking.

States as laboratories

In 1932 Justice Louis Brandeis wrote, in a dissent in New State Ice Co. v. Liebmann, that "a single courageous State may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country." The idea is that a policy can be tested in one state, and copied if it works. History offers examples. Wyoming let women vote as a territory in 1869, and many states had done so before the Nineteenth Amendment (1920). State child-labour and pension laws preceded the New Deal. Massachusetts's 2006 health insurance law served as a model for parts of the Affordable Care Act (2010).

Participation and access

Federalism multiplies the places where citizens can take part. Americans elect hundreds of thousands of officials, from school boards and county commissions to governors, and most of those offices are local. Political careers usually begin there. Because there are two levels able to act, losing at one does not end a cause: a group defeated in Congress can try state legislatures, as the topic "Competitive federalism today" showed with venue shopping. Polls by Gallup have long found that Americans trust their state and local governments more than the federal government, which supporters of federalism cite as a sign that government closer to home feels more accountable.

Accommodating diversity

A country of more than 330 million people disagrees about a great deal. Federalism lets different communities choose different policies instead of forcing one national answer on everyone. States differ on taxes, gun laws, alcohol sales, school choice, marijuana, minimum wages and, since Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022), abortion. Supporters argue this lowers the stakes of national politics and lets people move to states that match their values. Critics answer that rights should not depend on where a person happens to live, and that moving is not a realistic choice for many people.

Worked example: tracing policy diffusion

Follow one experiment from a state to the nation. 1. Problem: many Massachusetts residents lacked health insurance. 2. State experiment: in 2006 the state required most residents to have insurance, subsidised coverage for lower-income people and created a marketplace to compare plans. 3. Evidence: the share of uninsured residents in the state fell sharply in the following years. 4. Diffusion: national lawmakers drew on the design for the Affordable Care Act, which used an individual mandate, subsidies and marketplaces. 5. Conflict: critics in many states objected, and the law faced lawsuits led by state attorneys general. 6. Lesson: a laboratory can produce a national model, and the model can then spark new federalism disputes.

Unequal states

The first major drawback is inequality. States differ greatly in wealth, so they can afford different services. In Census Bureau figures for fiscal 2023, the highest-spending state spent about three times as much per public-school pupil as the lowest, and median household incomes, health coverage and life expectancy vary widely by state. Benefits in joint programmes such as Medicaid and unemployment insurance differ too, because states set many of the rules. Ten states had still not adopted the Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act in 2026, according to KFF, a health policy research organisation. Critics argue that federalism makes it harder to even out such gaps.

The race to the bottom

States compete for businesses and jobs. A race to the bottom happens when they cut taxes, regulations or benefits to attract employers, each fearing that others will undercut it. Critics point to weaker worker protections and underfunded unemployment insurance as costs. Defenders reply that competition can also produce a race to the top, forcing governments to be efficient, and that low-tax states are making a legitimate choice that their voters endorse. National minimum standards, such as the federal minimum wage or air-quality rules, are one answer: they set a floor below which no state may compete.

Obstacles to national action

Federalism, combined with checks and balances, can block or slow national responses. Early New Deal laws were struck down as invading state powers. National civil rights were long resisted under the banner of states' rights, as southern states defended segregation and barriers to Black voting until federal courts and laws overrode them in the 1950s and 1960s. Debate continues over voting rules. In Shelby County v. Holder (2013) the Supreme Court struck down the formula that decided which places needed federal approval before changing election laws; supporters called the formula outdated, while critics said the ruling weakened voter protection.

Worked example: weighing an argument

Evaluate the claim "Federalism protects freedom." 1. Supporting evidence: power divided between levels gives citizens two governments to appeal to, as Madison argued. 2. Supporting evidence: states have expanded rights before Washington, as with women's suffrage. 3. Counter-evidence: states also used their powers to deny rights, as segregation laws showed. 4. Counter-evidence: national action was needed to end those abuses. 5. Recent example: in Moore v. Harper (2023) the Court held that state courts may review legislatures' rules for federal elections, rejecting the independent state legislature theory, the claim that legislatures act free of state constitutional limits. 6. Conclusion: federalism protects freedom when one level can check another, not automatically.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, the laboratory quotation comes from Justice Brandeis in 1932, in a dissent, not from the framers. Second, a race to the bottom is a risk, not a certainty; states sometimes compete upwards. Third, federalism has served both expanding and restricting rights, so neither side can claim it always helps its cause. Fourth, Shelby County did not strike down the whole Voting Rights Act; it ended the coverage formula that triggered preclearance. Fifth, diversity of policy is a benefit to some and a burden to others; good answers weigh both.

Key takeaways

Madison saw divided power as a "double security" for liberty. Federalism's advantages include policy innovation, as in Brandeis's laboratories of democracy (1932), more chances to participate and the ability to fit policy to diverse communities. Its disadvantages include unequal services across states, race-to-the-bottom competition and obstacles to national action, from the early New Deal to segregation. Cases such as Shelby County v. Holder (2013) and Moore v. Harper (2023) show the balance still being argued. Whether federalism helps or harms depends on the issue and on which level checks which.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Double security

Madison's idea that two levels of government check each other to protect liberty

Federalist No. 51.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did Justice Brandeis mean by calling a state a "laboratory"?

Question 2 of 5

Which is the best example of a race to the bottom?

Question 3 of 5

What did Shelby County v. Holder (2013) decide?

Question 4 of 5

Which fact is the strongest evidence against the claim that federalism always protects freedom?

Question 5 of 5

In Moore v. Harper (2023), what did the Supreme Court hold?

← Previous topicNext topic →