American Government › Section C · Federalism › Topic C.3

Intergovernmental relations and grants

Washington rarely runs schools, hospitals or highways itself. Instead it pays and pressures states to do so, through grants that act as carrots and mandates that act as sticks. Following the money is the quickest way to see how federalism works today.

Carrots and sticks

Washington needs states and cities to carry out many of its goals, and it has two broad tools. A grant is a carrot: federal money, not repaid, that encourages a state or local government to do something it might not do on its own, usually with conditions attached. A mandate is a stick: a federal requirement that states or localities must meet, backed by penalties, often with little or no money to cover the cost. These flows of money and obligations are called fiscal federalism.

From land to cash

Federal aid began with land. During the 1800s Washington gave millions of acres to states to help build roads, canals and railways. The Morrill Act of 1862 granted federal land that states sold to fund colleges teaching agriculture and engineering; a second Morrill Act in 1890 led to land-grant colleges for Black students in the segregated South. In the twentieth century cash replaced land, growing fast in the New Deal and the 1960s. Federal grants to state and local governments reached an estimated $1.1 trillion in fiscal 2024, roughly 16% of all federal spending, according to the Congressional Research Service.

Categorical grants

Most federal aid comes as categorical grants: money for a narrow purpose, with detailed rules on how it is spent, reported and audited, and often a requirement that the state add matching funds of its own. They come in two forms. Formula grants are shared out automatically by a rule written into law, using measures such as population, income or road miles. Project grants are awarded competitively: agencies invite applications and pick the best proposals, as with many research or transit grants. Medicaid, the joint federal-state health programme for people on low incomes, is by far the largest; it made up about 57% of all federal grant spending in fiscal 2023.

Block grants and revenue sharing

A block grant funds a broad area, such as community development or social services, with fewer rules, so states choose how to spend it. President Richard Nixon's general revenue sharing, which ran from 1972 to 1986, went further: money with almost no strings. Supporters of new federalism favour block grants because states know local needs. Critics reply that block grants make it harder to hold states accountable and easier for Congress to let funding shrink. Categorical grants still dominate: one count in 2018 found only 21 block grants among about 1,274 funded federal grant programmes. Members of Congress can claim credit for specific programmes, and agencies keep more control over results.

TANF: an entitlement becomes a block grant

The biggest change came in 1996. Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC), a New Deal-era welfare programme, was an open-ended entitlement: Washington paid a share of whatever states spent on eligible families. Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) replaced it with a fixed block grant of about $16.5 billion a year, giving states wide freedom to design their programmes, alongside federal work requirements and time limits. The fixed sum has not been raised for inflation since, so its real value has fallen. Over time Congress has also added rules to many block grants, a process called creeping categorisation, which narrows their flexibility.

Worked example: choosing a grant design

Congress wants more students to get after-school tutoring. 1. Option A, a formula categorical grant: money goes to every state by the number of low-income pupils, and must be spent on tutoring that meets federal standards. 2. Option B, a project grant: districts compete, and the agency funds the strongest plans. 3. Option C, a block grant for youth services: states may spend it on tutoring, sports or mentoring as they judge best. 4. Trade-off: A and B give Washington more control and clearer accountability; C gives states more flexibility but less certainty that tutoring grows. 5. Conclusion: the choice of grant type decides who really sets the policy.

Strings attached: South Dakota v. Dole

Congress can attach conditions to grants that it could not impose directly. The National Minimum Drinking Age Act of 1984 withheld part of federal highway money, 5% at first, from any state that let people under 21 buy alcohol. South Dakota, which allowed 19-year-olds to buy some beer, sued. In South Dakota v. Dole (1987) the Supreme Court upheld the law. Conditions are allowed if they serve the general welfare, are stated clearly, relate to the purpose of the spending, do not require states to break the Constitution, and are not so heavy that pressure turns into compulsion. Highway money and road safety were related, and the amount was modest, so the condition stood.

Where pressure becomes coercion

The coercion limit finally bit in National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius (2012). The Affordable Care Act told states to expand Medicaid to more low-income adults or risk losing all their existing Medicaid money, not just new funds. Chief Justice John Roberts called that threat "a gun to the head." The Court upheld most of the law but ruled that Congress could not take away existing Medicaid funding from states that declined. Expansion therefore became a genuine choice, and states have decided differently. The case shows that the spending power is broad but not unlimited.

Worked example: testing a condition

Apply the Dole test to two invented conditions. 1. Condition A: states lose 5% of federal highway funds unless they require seat belts. 2. Is it clear and related to the spending? Yes: road safety and road money match. 3. Is it coercive? No: the share is small and states can refuse. 4. Likely valid. 5. Condition B: states lose all federal education funds unless they change their voting rules. 6. Related? No: schooling and elections are different purposes. 7. Coercive? Very likely, given the sums. 8. Likely invalid, following the reasoning of Dole and NFIB.

Unfunded mandates

Mandates require action without full payment. Crosscutting mandates attach conditions to all federal grants; for example, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 lets Washington cut off funds to programmes that discriminate by race. Partial pre-emption sets national standards and leaves enforcement to states, as when the Clean Air Act requires each state to write a plan to meet federal air-quality limits. After state and local complaints, the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 made Congress estimate mandate costs and made costly mandates easier to challenge in Congress, though relief has been limited. The Real ID Act of 2005 is a costly example: states had to redesign licences, and airport enforcement began only in May 2025.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, a block grant is not free of conditions; it simply has fewer and broader ones than a categorical grant. Second, formula grants are not competitive; project grants are. Third, South Dakota v. Dole did not let Congress set the drinking age directly; Congress used money to persuade states, which still passed the laws. Fourth, NFIB v. Sebelius did not strike down the Affordable Care Act; it made Medicaid expansion optional.

Key takeaways

Grants are carrots and mandates are sticks. Federal aid moved from land, such as the Morrill Acts, to cash, reaching an estimated $1.1 trillion in fiscal 2024. Categorical grants, formula or project, carry detailed rules; Medicaid is the largest. Block grants and revenue sharing give more freedom; TANF (1996) turned welfare into a fixed block grant. Dole (1987) allows clear, related, non-coercive conditions; NFIB (2012) found the Medicaid threat coercive. Unfunded mandates, crosscutting or partial pre-emption, impose costs that the 1995 reform act only partly restrained.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Fiscal federalism

The flow of money and obligations between levels of government

Grants are carrots, mandates are sticks.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A federal programme gives each state money in proportion to its number of school-age children, to be spent only on reading programmes that meet federal rules. What kind of grant is this?

Question 2 of 5

What did Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (1996) change?

Question 3 of 5

Why did the Supreme Court uphold the drinking-age condition in South Dakota v. Dole (1987)?

Question 4 of 5

In NFIB v. Sebelius (2012), what did the Court rule about Medicaid expansion?

Question 5 of 5

The Clean Air Act sets national air-quality limits and requires each state to write and enforce a plan to meet them. What kind of federal tool is this?

← Previous topicNext topic →