American Government › Section B · The Constitution › Topic B.5

Changing the Constitution

The framers had seen a government fail because it could not be changed, so they built in a way to amend the Constitution while making it deliberately hard. Formal amendments, court rulings and political practice have all reshaped the document since 1789.

Built to change, but not easily

Under the Articles of Confederation, a single state could block any amendment, as the failed import duty showed. The framers wanted a constitution that could adapt without that veto, yet would not shift with every passing majority. The result has proved very hard to change. According to the Senate's count, about 11,985 measures proposing amendments were introduced in Congress between 1789 and 3 January 2025. Congress approved only 33 and sent them to the states, and just 27 were ratified. Ten of those came together as the Bill of Rights, so only seventeen amendments have been added since 1791.

Article V: two steps, two routes each

Article V sets out a two-step process. To propose an amendment, either two-thirds of both houses of Congress approve it, or Congress calls a national convention when two-thirds of state legislatures apply for one. To ratify it, three-quarters of the states must approve, either through their legislatures or through special state conventions; Congress chooses the method. Every amendment so far has been proposed by Congress, and no national convention has ever been called. Only one amendment, the Twenty-First, was ratified by state conventions. One provision is effectively permanent: "no State, without its Consent, shall be deprived of its equal Suffrage in the Senate."

Worked example: the arithmetic of Article V

Count what a proposed amendment needs today, with every member voting. 1. House: two-thirds of 435 is 290 votes. 2. Senate: two-thirds of 100 is 67 votes. 3. Convention route instead: two-thirds of 50 state legislatures is 34 applications. 4. Ratification: three-quarters of 50 states is 37.5, so 38 states are needed. 5. Blocking power: if 13 states refuse, only 37 can ratify, and the amendment fails. 6. Check: the thirteen least populous states together hold well under a tenth of the national population, so a determined minority of states can stop an amendment that most Americans support.

The Bill of Rights

Madison drew most of his proposals from state declarations, especially the Virginia Declaration of Rights of 1776, drafted mainly by George Mason, and from English precedents such as the 1689 Bill of Rights, discussed in an earlier topic. Some went beyond English precedent, such as the First Amendment's ban on a national established church. The Ninth Amendment answered fears that listing rights would imply no others: "The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people." The Tenth reserves undelegated powers "to the States respectively, or to the people."

The Reconstruction amendments

Three amendments ratified after the Civil War transformed the Constitution, as the US History course describes. The Thirteenth (1865) abolished slavery except as punishment for a crime. The Fourteenth (1868) made all persons born or naturalised in the United States, and subject to its jurisdiction, citizens and barred states from denying anyone due process of law or the equal protection of the laws. The Fifteenth (1870) barred denying the vote because of race. For decades states evaded them, but the Fourteenth later became the basis for applying most of the Bill of Rights to the states, a process a later section explains.

Widening democracy and adjusting the machinery

Many later amendments expanded who takes part. The Seventeenth (1913) gave voters, not legislatures, the choice of senators; the Nineteenth (1920) barred sex discrimination in voting; the Twenty-Third (1961) gave Washington, DC, electoral votes; the Twenty-Fourth (1964) banned poll taxes in federal elections; and the Twenty-Sixth (1971) set the voting age at 18. Others adjusted the machinery: the Twentieth (1933) moved inauguration to 20 January, the Twenty-Second (1951) limited presidents to two elected terms, and the Twenty-Fifth (1967) covered presidential disability. The Eighteenth (1919) imposed Prohibition, and the Twenty-First (1933) repealed it.

Slow and unfinished amendments

The Twenty-Seventh Amendment, which delays any change in congressional pay until after the next House election, was one of the twelve amendments sent to the states in 1789. It was ratified only in 1992, after a campaign begun in 1982 by a university student, Gregory Watson. The Equal Rights Amendment, banning denial of equal rights on account of sex, passed Congress in 1972 with a deadline later extended to 1982, when 35 states had ratified. Three more ratified between 2017 and 2020. Supporters say it is now law; opponents cite the deadline and several states' rescissions. As of 2026, the National Archives had not certified it.

Informal change

Much constitutional change happens without amendments. Courts interpret broad phrases such as due process and equal protection, and their readings shift: in 1954, Brown v. Board of Education rejected the separate but equal doctrine that the Court had accepted in 1896. Congress and presidents create institutions the text never mentions, such as the cabinet and dozens of federal agencies. Custom matters too. Political parties and presidential primaries are not in the Constitution, and presidents followed Washington's two-term example until Franklin Roosevelt won a third term in 1940; only then did the Twenty-Second Amendment make it law.

Debates over interpretation

Judges and scholars disagree about how to read the Constitution. Originalists, such as the late Justice Antonin Scalia, argue that its words should carry the public meaning they had when adopted, and that changes should come through amendment. Supporters of a living Constitution argue that its broad principles must be applied to circumstances the framers could not foresee, and that formal amendment is too difficult to be the only path. Justice Stephen Breyer, often linked with this second view, emphasised a law's purposes and consequences. Textualism, a related approach often paired with originalism, focuses closely on the words themselves. These approaches often lead to different answers in major cases.

Worked example: direct election of senators

Trace how informal and formal change combined. 1. The original rule: state legislatures chose senators, and deadlocks sometimes left seats empty for months. 2. Pressure: reformers, especially in the Progressive Era, charged that wealthy interests could buy legislative votes. 3. Informal change: from the early 1900s, Oregon and other states held popular votes and pressed legislators to follow the result. 4. Leverage: many state legislatures applied for a national convention, raising the possibility Congress feared most. 5. Formal change: Congress proposed the Seventeenth Amendment in 1912, ratified in 1913. 6. Conclusion: practice moved first, and the text caught up.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking the president plays a formal role in amendments: Article V gives none, and no signature is needed. Second, saying the convention route has been used; it never has. Third, confusing the thresholds: two-thirds of Congress proposes, three-quarters of the states ratify. Fourth, believing the Bill of Rights came with the original Constitution; it was ratified in 1791. Fifth, assuming that change requires amendment: court rulings, laws and customs have reshaped how the Constitution works.

Key takeaways

Article V requires proposal by two-thirds of both houses, or a convention requested by two-thirds of the states, and ratification by three-quarters of the states. About 11,985 amendments were proposed in Congress by January 2025, but only 27 have been ratified, including the Bill of Rights of 1791. The Reconstruction amendments ended slavery, defined citizenship and equal protection, and barred racial discrimination in voting. Later amendments widened the vote and adjusted the machinery of government. The Constitution also changes informally, through interpretation, legislation and custom, amid debates between originalists and living constitutionalists.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Article V

The amendment process: proposal, then ratification

Two routes for each step.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which path has every one of the 27 ratified amendments followed?

Question 2 of 5

With 50 states, what is the smallest number of states that can block a proposed amendment from being ratified?

Question 3 of 5

What is the purpose of the Ninth Amendment?

Question 4 of 5

Which change to American government came about without any constitutional amendment?

Question 5 of 5

What position do originalists take on interpreting the Constitution?

← Previous topicNext topic →