American Government › Section C · Federalism › Topic C.1

The division of powers

The United States splits power twice: across three branches, and between a national government and fifty state governments. That second split, federalism, decides who taxes you, who licenses you to drive and whose law wins when the two disagree.

Two ways to divide power

Democracies can divide power across branches, so that a legislature, an executive and a judiciary check one another. They can also divide it between levels of government. The United States does both. Federalism is the second kind: a national government and regional governments each hold authority from the constitution, and each can act directly on the people. In American usage, "the federal government" means the national government, and "the states" means the fifty below it. Federal countries such as the United States, Germany and Mexico share common features: elected governments at both levels, a written constitution the regions must help amend, national courts that settle disputes between levels, and regional representation in the national legislature, here two senators per state.

Federal, unitary and confederal systems

Federalism sits between two alternatives. In a unitary system, the central government holds final authority and regional bodies have only the powers it gives them; France and Japan are examples. The United Kingdom is unitary too, although since the late 1990s it has handed some powers to elected bodies in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, a process called devolution. In a confederation, the member states keep sovereignty and the centre can act only with their consent. The United States tried that model first, as the topic "The Articles of Confederation" showed, and found the centre too weak to pay debts or settle disputes between states.

Powers of the national government

The Constitution lists, or enumerates, the powers of Congress, mainly in Article I, Section 8: taxing, borrowing, regulating commerce with foreign nations and among the states, coining money, setting rules for naturalisation, raising armed forces and declaring war, among others. The final clause lets Congress make all laws "necessary and proper" for carrying out those powers. This necessary and proper clause, or elastic clause, is the basis of implied powers: means not listed but needed to reach listed ends. With broad readings of the commerce clause, it has let national power grow far beyond the bare list.

Reserved and concurrent powers

The original Constitution did not list state powers, because most framers assumed states kept whatever was not given away. Anti-Federalists wanted that in writing, and the Tenth Amendment supplied it: powers not delegated to the United States, nor prohibited to the states, "are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." Reserved powers include running elections, chartering local governments, licensing professions and most criminal law, schooling and policing. Concurrent powers belong to both levels at once: taxing, borrowing, building roads, creating courts, and making and enforcing laws.

What neither level may do

Article I, Section 9 bars Congress from suspending the writ of habeas corpus, which lets a prisoner ask a judge whether a detention is lawful, except in rebellion or invasion. It also bans bills of attainder, laws declaring someone guilty without a trial, and ex post facto laws, which punish an act that was legal when done. Section 10 applies those two bans to the states and stops them making treaties or coining money. The Fourteenth Amendment (1868) forbids states to deny due process or equal protection, and later amendments bar both levels from denying the vote on account of race or sex, or to citizens 18 or over on account of age.

The supremacy clause and its limits

Article VI makes the Constitution, federal laws made under it and treaties "the supreme Law of the Land." When a valid federal law conflicts with a state law, the federal law wins, a principle called pre-emption. Two limits matter. First, the federal law must be within Congress's powers; an unconstitutional law pre-empts nothing. Second, Congress may not commandeer the states, ordering their legislatures or officers to run federal programmes. In Printz v. United States (1997) the Supreme Court struck down a temporary requirement that local sheriffs run background checks on handgun buyers.

Worked example: whose law wins?

Suppose Congress requires every new car sold to carry a certain safety device, and a state bans that device. 1. Is the federal law within an enumerated power? Car sales cross state lines, so it rests on the commerce clause. 2. Do the laws conflict? Yes: obeying the state ban means breaking the federal rule. 3. Apply the supremacy clause: the valid federal law pre-empts the ban. 4. Change the facts: Congress orders state police to inspect every car. That raises an anti-commandeering problem under Printz. 5. Conclusion: Congress may bind carmakers directly, but must use its own inspectors or pay states to take part.

Relations among the states

Article IV governs how states treat one another. The full faith and credit clause requires each state to recognise the others' public acts, records and court judgments, so an adoption granted in one state holds in another. The privileges and immunities clause, or comity clause, bars states from discriminating against out-of-staters in basic matters such as access to courts, owning property and travel; it still allows sensible differences, such as higher out-of-state tuition or voting only where you live. Extradition requires a state to hand over a person charged with a crime to the state where it occurred. With Congress's consent, states may also form interstate compacts.

Money and local government

The Sixteenth Amendment (1913) let Congress tax incomes without sharing the tax out among states by population, and federal revenue grew sharply. Much of it flows back as grants: federal money made up about a third of state revenue in fiscal 2024, according to the Pew Charitable Trusts. Below the states sit counties, cities, towns, school districts and special districts, about 90,800 local governments at the 2022 Census of Governments. They have no independent standing in the Constitution. Under Dillon's Rule, a local government has only the powers its state grants, although many states give cities home rule, broader power over their own affairs.

Worked example: one errand, three levels

Trace the governments involved when a student drives to a city college. 1. The driving licence comes from the state, a reserved power. 2. Federal safety standards for the car rest on the commerce clause. 3. The highway may be state-built but partly paid for with federal grants. 4. Fuel is taxed by both Washington and the state, a concurrent power. 5. The college may belong to a local district created by the state. 6. Check: every step traces to a constitutional grant, a reservation or a state charter.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, "federal" in American usage means the national government, not the whole system. Second, the supremacy clause does not make every federal action supreme: only laws within Congress's powers pre-empt state law, and even valid laws cannot commandeer state officers. Third, the Tenth Amendment lists no specific state powers; it reserves whatever was not delegated or prohibited. Fourth, local governments are not a constitutional level like the states; states create them.

Key takeaways

Federalism divides authority between a national government and state governments, each acting directly on the people; unitary systems centralise power and confederations leave it with the members. Enumerated powers in Article I, Section 8, stretched by the necessary and proper and commerce clauses, define national authority. The Tenth Amendment reserves the rest to the states, and many powers are concurrent. The supremacy clause makes valid federal law win, though Printz (1997) bars commandeering. Article IV covers full faith and credit, privileges and immunities and extradition. Local governments are creatures of the states.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Federalism

Authority divided between a national government and regional governments, each acting directly on the people

Both levels draw power from the constitution.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which description fits a confederation rather than a federal or unitary system?

Question 2 of 5

What does the Tenth Amendment do?

Question 3 of 5

Congress orders county sheriffs to carry out background checks for a federal gun law. Under Printz v. United States (1997), what is the problem?

Question 4 of 5

Which is a concurrent power, held by both the national and state governments?

Question 5 of 5

A state charges higher tuition at its public university to students from other states. Why is this usually allowed?

← Previous topicNext topic →