American Government › Section B · The Constitution › Topic B.4

Ratifying the Constitution

Signing the Constitution in September 1787 did not make it law. It still had to win approval in the states, and the national argument that followed, between Federalists and Anti-Federalists, produced some of the most important writing in American political thought.

Article VII: the ratification rule

On 17 September 1787, thirty-nine delegates signed the finished Constitution; three who were present, George Mason, Edmund Randolph and Elbridge Gerry, refused. Article VII set out how it would take effect: "The Ratification of the Conventions of nine States, shall be sufficient for the Establishment of this Constitution between the States so ratifying the Same." Two features stood out. Only nine states were needed, not all thirteen, and approval would come from specially elected conventions rather than state legislatures. On 28 September the Confederation Congress sent the document to the states without endorsing or opposing it.

Why conventions, not legislatures?

The framers had practical and principled reasons. State legislators stood to lose power under the new system, so they might reject it. Conventions elected for this single purpose were more likely to judge the plan on its merits. The principle was popular sovereignty, the idea that the people are the ultimate source of authority. A constitution that opens with We the People, Madison and others argued, should be approved by bodies chosen by the people themselves. Critics pointed out that the Articles required every state legislature to approve any change, so the nine-state rule was legally irregular.

The Federalists

Supporters of the Constitution took the name Federalists. Prominent among them were Washington, Madison, Hamilton, John Jay and Benjamin Franklin. They argued that only a stronger national government could pay the war debt, defend the country, protect American trade and keep order after Shays's Rebellion. Many merchants, creditors and large landowners backed them. In 1913 the historian Charles Beard argued that the framers acted mainly to protect their own property, but later historians, such as Forrest McDonald, found that economic interests did not line up so neatly, and few now accept Beard's thesis in its original form.

The Anti-Federalists

Opponents, called Anti-Federalists, were a varied coalition, from Virginia planters such as Patrick Henry and George Mason to small farmers and New York's Melancton Smith. Many wrote under pen names such as Brutus, the Federal Farmer and Centinel. They warned that the new government would absorb the states, that the necessary and proper and supremacy clauses had no clear limits, and that a powerful president and Senate could become a new aristocracy. Following Montesquieu, many argued that a free republic could not survive over so large a territory. Their most popular complaint was that the Constitution lacked a bill of rights.

The Federalist essays

To win over New York, Hamilton, Madison and Jay wrote eighty-five essays in 1787 and 1788 under the shared pen name Publius, later collected as The Federalist. Hamilton wrote most of them, Madison about twenty-nine and Jay five. In No. 10, Madison argued that factions could not be removed without destroying liberty, but a large republic would contain so many competing interests that no single faction could easily form an oppressive majority. In No. 51 he defended checks and balances: "Ambition must be made to counteract ambition." In No. 70, Hamilton argued that a single, energetic executive was easier to hold accountable than a committee.

Worked example: Federalist No. 10 against Brutus

Compare two answers to the same question: can a republic work across a large country? 1. Brutus, in his first essay of October 1787, said no: in a vast republic, representatives would be too few and too distant to know their constituents, and citizens would lose trust in them. 2. Madison said yes: size multiplies interests, so oppressive majorities form less easily. 3. Their shared fear: both worried about government captured by a narrow group. 4. The difference: Brutus feared distant elites; Madison feared local majorities. 5. Check: each relied on Montesquieu's question about scale but reached opposite answers.

The ratification contest

Delaware ratified first, unanimously, on 7 December 1787, followed quickly by Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Georgia and Connecticut. Massachusetts approved narrowly in February 1788 after Federalists agreed to recommend amendments, and Maryland and South Carolina followed in the spring. New Hampshire became the decisive ninth state on 21 June 1788. Virginia, on 25 June, and New York, on 26 July, ratified by close votes, both with recommended amendments; the US History course gives the vote counts. North Carolina joined only in November 1789, and Rhode Island, which had sent no delegates to Philadelphia, ratified by just two votes in May 1790.

Worked example: why the amendment promise worked

Trace cause and effect in Massachusetts, the first closely divided state. 1. The obstacle: many convention delegates objected that the Constitution did not protect rights. 2. The choice: rejecting it outright, or ratifying only on conditions, risked sinking the whole plan. 3. The strategy: Federalists backed a proposal, presented by Governor John Hancock, to ratify while recommending amendments. 4. The result: the convention approved in February 1788. 5. The spread: Virginia and New York adopted the same approach. 6. The consequence: the promise of amendments became a political debt, which the first Congress paid with the Bill of Rights.

From promise to Bill of Rights

Madison had at first thought a bill of rights unnecessary, doubting that written lists, which he called parchment barriers, could stop a determined majority. Jefferson, writing from Paris, urged him otherwise; in a letter of 15 March 1789 he stressed that a declaration of rights would give judges a legal check on government. Elected to the first House of Representatives, Madison introduced amendments in June 1789. Congress sent twelve to the states in September, and ten were ratified by December 1791. The next topic covers that process, and the US History course places it in the politics of the 1790s.

Who decided?

Historians caution that ratification was not a simple national vote. In several states, seats in the conventions favoured older eastern districts over the newer western ones, where opposition was often stronger, and some small towns could not afford to send delegates. Women, enslaved people and most men without property could not vote for delegates at all. Because of this, historians disagree about whether a majority of Americans supported the Constitution in 1787 and 1788. What is clear is that Federalists were better organised, had the support of most newspapers, and won several conventions only by narrow margins.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming all thirteen states had to ratify: Article VII required nine. Second, thinking state legislatures ratified the Constitution; specially elected conventions did. Third, picturing the Anti-Federalists as opposed to union; most wanted a looser union, more state power and protected rights. Fourth, believing The Federalist essays were neutral analysis; they were persuasive writing for ratification, especially in New York. Fifth, assuming the Bill of Rights came with the original Constitution: it was promised during ratification and added between 1789 and 1791.

Key takeaways

Article VII required ratification by conventions in nine states, a choice justified by popular sovereignty. Federalists argued that a stronger union was needed for credit, defence and order; Anti-Federalists feared consolidated power, aristocracy and the lack of a bill of rights. The Federalist essays, especially Nos. 10 and 51, defended a large republic and checks and balances. New Hampshire was the ninth state in June 1788, but Virginia and New York, ratifying with recommended amendments, made the union secure. The promise of amendments led to the Bill of Rights in 1791.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Article VII

Conventions in nine states must ratify

Not all thirteen, and not legislatures.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did the framers send the Constitution to special ratifying conventions instead of state legislatures?

Question 2 of 5

In Federalist No. 10, how did Madison argue that a large republic would control the effects of faction?

Question 3 of 5

Which objection did Anti-Federalists raise most often and most successfully?

Question 4 of 5

What made the Constitution's adoption secure in practice, beyond reaching the nine-state threshold?

Question 5 of 5

In 1913, what did the historian Charles Beard argue about the framers?

← Previous topicNext topic →