American Government › Section Q · Foreign policy › Topic Q.2

Foreign policy instruments

American foreign policy is made through concrete outputs: laws, budgets, treaties, appointments, summits and orders to the armed forces. Some take years and bind future governments; others take hours and can be reversed by the next president.

Broad and sharply focused outputs

Foreign-policy decisions come in two kinds. Broadly focused outputs, such as laws, agency budgets, treaties and senior appointments, involve many actors, usually including Congress, take months or years, cost a great deal and are hard to reverse, so their effects last. Sharply focused outputs, such as sending troops in a crisis, holding a summit or ordering a strike, are usually decided by the president, happen quickly, have a short time horizon and are easier for a later president to undo. The distinction helps explain why presidents dominate crises while Congress has more say over long-term direction.

Public laws

Public laws are statutes that apply generally, as opposed to private laws that concern named individuals. Several shape what government may do abroad. The National Security Act of 1947 created the National Security Council and the Central Intelligence Agency and began unifying the armed services under what became the Department of Defense. After the September 2001 attacks, Congress passed an Authorization for Use of Military Force against those responsible, which presidents have since cited for many counter-terrorism operations, and the Patriot Act, which widened surveillance powers. The Homeland Security Act of 2002 merged parts of more than twenty agencies into a new Department of Homeland Security.

The War Powers Resolution

Congress has the power to declare war but last did so in 1942, during the Second World War, although American forces later fought in Korea, Vietnam and elsewhere. After Vietnam, Congress passed the War Powers Resolution in 1973 over President Nixon's veto. It requires the president to consult Congress where possible, report within 48 hours of sending forces into hostilities, and withdraw them within 60 days of that report, plus 30 more for a safe withdrawal, unless Congress authorises the action. Presidents of both parties have called it unconstitutional. Many scholars argue that in practice it confirmed presidents' freedom to act for the first 60 days, since many operations end sooner.

Worked example: the war powers clock

A president orders air strikes on 1 March without congressional authorisation and reports to Congress the same day. 1. Report: the deadline was 48 hours, by 3 March, and the clock starts from the report. 2. Sixty days: counting 30 days left in March and 30 in April, the 60-day limit ends on 30 April. 3. Withdrawal period: the law allows up to 30 more days to bring forces out safely, to 30 May. 4. Congress's options: authorise the action, extend the deadline, or let the clock run. 5. Reality check: presidents have often argued that limited operations are not hostilities under the law, and Congress has rarely forced an end, so funding debates usually matter more.

Reauthorisation and the budget

Many foreign-policy programmes must be renewed periodically by authorising laws, which forces regular conversations between agencies and Congress about what works. The largest is the National Defense Authorization Act, which Congress has passed every year since 1961. Authorisation is separate from funding: money comes through annual appropriations, and defence and foreign affairs are discretionary spending, decided each year rather than set by standing law. Defence takes roughly half of all discretionary spending, while diplomacy and foreign aid take a small share. Because nothing can be spent without an appropriation, the budget is Congress's strongest lever over foreign policy.

Treaties

Under Article II the president makes treaties, but only if two-thirds of the senators present give the Senate's consent. The president negotiates; the Senate considers the treaty, usually after hearings by its Foreign Relations Committee, and may attach conditions; then the president ratifies it. The House has no formal role, though it may need to pass laws to carry a treaty out or fund it. The two-thirds rule gives a determined minority great power: the Senate rejected the Treaty of Versailles, and with it membership of the League of Nations, in 1919 and 1920. Treaties are hard to make, and their broad support tends to make them last, though presidents have sometimes quit treaties alone, as with the ABM Treaty in 2002.

Executive agreements

Over 90 percent of the international agreements the United States has made since the 1930s are executive agreements, not treaties. A congressional-executive agreement, once the president has negotiated it, needs only majority votes in the House and the Senate, as with the North American Free Trade Agreement, in force from 1994, and its successor, the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement of 2020. A sole executive agreement rests on the president's own constitutional authority and needs no vote. Two cases, United States v. Belmont (1937) and its 1942 sequel, United States v. Pink, held that such agreements can override state law much as treaties do. Their weakness is that a later president can more easily abandon them.

Worked example: choosing the form

A president negotiates an arms-control deal and must decide its form; 98 senators are present for any vote. 1. Treaty route: two-thirds of 98 is about 65.3, so 66 senators must agree. 2. Congressional-executive route: a majority of each chamber, so 50 of those 98 senators plus 218 representatives if all 435 vote. 3. Sole executive agreement: no vote, but it rests on one president's authority alone. 4. Durability test: the 2015 nuclear deal with Iran was not submitted as a treaty, and in 2018 the next president withdrew from it. 5. Conclusion: easier routes trade durability for speed.

Appointments

A new president fills hundreds of senior foreign-policy posts, including the secretary of state, under secretaries, assistant secretaries and every ambassador, and each needs confirmation by a simple majority of the Senate. When party control of the White House changes, turnover is especially large, because the new president wants officials who share the new agenda. Presidents look for nominees with knowledge of the region or subject, loyalty to the administration and a fair chance of confirmation. The Senate Foreign Relations Committee holds hearings first, and a single senator's hold can delay many nominations. Who is appointed shapes whether policy leans towards engagement with allies or towards pulling back.

Sharply focused outputs

In a crisis the president acts quickly. In October 1962, after American spy planes photographed Soviet missile sites in Cuba, President Kennedy rejected immediate air strikes and imposed a naval quarantine; the Soviets removed the missiles, and the United States quietly agreed to withdraw its own missiles from Turkey. Summits bring leaders together for direct bargaining: at Camp David in September 1978, President Carter, Egypt's Anwar Sadat and Israel's Menachem Begin spent about two weeks negotiating the Camp David Accords. Presidents also order uses of force, such as the 2011 air campaign over Libya, and request emergency spending, which Congress usually grants quickly in a crisis.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, saying the Senate ratifies treaties; it gives consent by two-thirds of senators present, and the president ratifies. Second, assuming most international agreements are treaties; over 90 percent are executive agreements. Third, thinking the War Powers Resolution requires approval before any deployment; it allows 60 days, plus 30 for withdrawal, before authorisation is needed. Fourth, confusing authorisation with appropriation; a programme can be authorised and still get no money. Fifth, believing executive agreements cannot bind; the Court treated them as binding in Belmont and Pink.

Key takeaways

Broadly focused outputs, laws, budgets, treaties and appointments, involve Congress, take time and last; sharply focused outputs, crisis decisions, summits, uses of force and emergency funding, are fast, presidential and reversible. Key laws include the National Security Act (1947), the War Powers Resolution (1973) and the 2001 AUMF. Treaties need two-thirds of senators present, while congressional-executive agreements need majorities of both chambers and sole executive agreements need no vote. The Senate confirms ambassadors and senior officials by majority. The power of the purse remains Congress's strongest lever.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Broadly focused output

Slow, costly, lasting decision involving many actors

Laws, budgets, treaties, appointments.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A president sends forces into hostilities on 1 June without authorisation and reports to Congress that day. Under the War Powers Resolution, when must they leave if Congress never acts and the full withdrawal period is used?

Question 2 of 5

With 96 senators present, how many must vote yes for the Senate to consent to a treaty?

Question 3 of 5

How was the North American Free Trade Agreement approved in the United States?

Question 4 of 5

Which of these is a sharply focused foreign-policy output?

Question 5 of 5

Why are sole executive agreements less durable than treaties?

← Previous topicNext topic →