American Government › Section L · The presidency › Topic L.5
Direct presidential action
When Congress will not act, presidents can sign an order, grant a pardon or fire an official on their own. These tools work quickly, but they are also the easiest for courts, Congress and the next president to undo.
Two kinds of presidential power
Direct action uses the formal powers of the office without needing anyone's agreement: issuing orders, granting pardons, removing officials and directing the armed forces. Persuasion means bargaining with Congress, the bureaucracy, party members and foreign leaders. Direct action can set policy in days, but it often signals that the legislative route has failed, and a court, Congress or a successor can reverse it. Presidents have the most room for direct action in national security and foreign affairs, where quick decisions are often needed.
The power to remove
Presidents need the Senate to confirm many officials but not to fire them. In 1867 Congress passed the Tenure of Office Act, requiring Senate consent to remove confirmed officials; Andrew Johnson's defiance of it became a main charge in his impeachment. In Myers v. United States (1926) the Supreme Court held that the president may remove executive officers. Humphrey's Executor v. United States (1935) carved out an exception, letting Congress protect members of independent commissions such as the Federal Trade Commission. In Trump v. Slaughter (June 2026) the Court overruled that exception, six votes to three, holding that FTC commissioners exercise executive power and can be removed at will.
Pardons and commutations
Article II lets the president grant "Reprieves and Pardons for Offences against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment." The power covers federal crimes only, not state ones, and includes commutations, which shorten a sentence without erasing the conviction. Andrew Johnson pardoned large numbers of former Confederates, Gerald Ford pardoned Richard Nixon in 1974, and Jimmy Carter pardoned Vietnam-era draft evaders in 1977. Recent clemency has been large-scale and sometimes controversial: Joe Biden pardoned his son and commuted thousands of sentences, and in January 2025 Donald Trump granted clemency to about 1,500 people charged over the 6 January 2021 attack on the Capitol.
Executive orders, memoranda and proclamations
An executive order is a directive telling federal agencies how to carry out their duties; it has the force of law when it rests on the Constitution or on authority Congress has delegated. Memoranda do similar work with less publicity, and proclamations often address the public, as Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation of 1863 did. Famous orders include Truman's Executive Order 9981 (1948) on equal treatment in the armed forces. Use has varied widely: Franklin Roosevelt signed about 3,700, Joe Biden about 160 in four years, and Donald Trump more than 220 in 2025 alone, more than in his whole first term. Successors routinely revoke orders they dislike.
Worked example: Executive Order 9066
Analyse a wartime order and its later judgement. 1. After the attack on Pearl Harbor in December 1941, fears of sabotage and long-standing anti-Asian prejudice grew on the West Coast. 2. In February 1942 Franklin Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066, letting the military exclude people from designated areas. 3. About 120,000 people of Japanese ancestry, most of them US citizens, were forced into inland camps. 4. In Korematsu v. United States (1944) the Supreme Court upheld the exclusion, six votes to three. 5. Later verdict: the Civil Liberties Act of 1988 apologised and paid survivors, and in Trump v. Hawaii (2018) the Court said Korematsu was "gravely wrong the day it was decided." 6. Lesson: courts often defer in wartime, and checks may come only afterwards.
Checks on acting alone
Courts can strike down orders that exceed the president's authority, as Youngstown (1952) did. Congress can override an order by statute or refuse to fund it. In Trump v. CASA (2025) the Court limited the universal injunctions that lower courts had used to block policies nationwide. In Trump v. Barbara (June 2026) it held unlawful an order denying citizenship to some US-born children, with five justices finding that it violated the Fourteenth Amendment. In Trump v. United States (2024) it held that former presidents have immunity from prosecution for official acts, absolute for core constitutional powers.
Worked example: the 2026 tariff ruling
Trace a clash between an emergency statute and the courts. 1. Congress has power under Article I to lay duties, but it has delegated some trade authority to presidents by statute. 2. In 2025 President Trump imposed broad tariffs on many countries, citing the International Emergency Economic Powers Act of 1977 (IEEPA), which lets presidents "regulate" imports during declared emergencies. 3. Importers sued, arguing that the act never mentions tariffs. 4. In February 2026 the Supreme Court held, six votes to three, that IEEPA does not authorise tariffs; the merits ruling came in Trump v. V.O.S. Selections, decided with Learning Resources v. Trump. 5. The administration then turned to other trade laws. 6. Lesson: an order is only as strong as the authority behind it, and Congress's words decide how far that authority reaches.
Line-item vetoes and signing statements
Many governors can veto single spending lines in a bill. Congress gave presidents a version of this in the Line Item Veto Act of 1996, and Bill Clinton used it to cancel items in several laws. In Clinton v. City of New York (1998) the Supreme Court struck the act down, reasoning that cancelling parts of a passed law amounts to amending it, which only Congress may do. Signing statements survive: written statements, issued when signing a bill, on how the executive branch will interpret or enforce it, sometimes treating a provision as unconstitutional. Critics say they let presidents rewrite laws without a veto.
War and diplomacy
Congress has formally declared war only in five conflicts, the last in the Second World War, yet presidents have sent forces into Korea, Vietnam, the Persian Gulf and elsewhere. The War Powers Resolution of 1973, passed over Nixon's veto, requires the president to notify Congress within 48 hours of deploying forces into hostilities and to withdraw them within 60 days, plus 30 for withdrawal, unless Congress authorises the action. Presidents of both parties have questioned it. In diplomacy, presidents rely heavily on executive agreements, international pacts made without the two-thirds Senate vote a treaty needs. They are binding as long as they do not conflict with federal law.
The power to persuade
In Presidential Power (1960), Richard Neustadt argued that formal powers matter less than "the power to persuade": a president must convince people with their own bases of power that cooperating serves their interests. Fred Greenstein described Dwight Eisenhower's "hidden-hand" style, working quietly behind the scenes while appearing above politics. Laws passed through persuasion tend to outlast orders, because repealing them takes another act of Congress. Divided government makes bargaining essential, yet Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton both won major deals with opposition majorities.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, an executive order is not a statute; it binds agencies and holds only as long as its constitutional or legal authority holds. Second, the pardon power reaches only federal offences, not state crimes or impeachment. Third, a later president can revoke an earlier order with a new order, with no need for Congress. Fourth, an executive agreement is not a treaty and needs no two-thirds Senate vote. Fifth, Trump v. CASA did not decide whether the birthright citizenship order was lawful; it addressed how far lower-court injunctions reach, and the Court ruled on the order itself in 2026.
Key takeaways
Direct action is quick but reversible; persuasion is slower but more durable. The removal power grew from Myers (1926), was limited by Humphrey's Executor (1935) and widened by Trump v. Slaughter (2026). Pardons cover federal offences except impeachment. Executive orders direct agencies and need a legal basis; courts check them, as Youngstown and the 2026 tariff and citizenship rulings show. The line-item veto fell in 1998, while signing statements and executive agreements remain. Neustadt saw presidential power as the power to persuade.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Using formal powers of the office without others' agreement
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A newly inaugurated president dislikes an executive order signed by the previous president. What is the simplest way to undo it?
Question 2 of 5
What did the Supreme Court decide in Trump v. Slaughter (2026)?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about the presidential pardon power is correct?
Question 4 of 5
Why did the Supreme Court strike down the Line Item Veto Act in Clinton v. City of New York (1998)?
Question 5 of 5
What does the War Powers Resolution of 1973 require?
