American Government › Section M · The courts › Topic M.1

Courts as guardians of the Constitution

The federal courts command no army and control no budget, yet they can strike down laws passed by Congress and orders signed by the president. This topic explains where that power came from, how courts use it to shape policy and protect individuals, and what holds it in check.

A branch without sword or purse

The Articles of Confederation created no national courts. Article III of the Constitution, the shortest of the three articles that set up the branches, vests "the judicial Power of the United States" in "one supreme Court" and in whatever lower courts Congress creates. Federal judges hold office "during good Behaviour", which in practice means for life unless impeached and removed, and their pay cannot be cut while they serve. Article III also limits federal courts to real "Cases" and "Controversies", so they decide actual disputes rather than giving advisory opinions on hypothetical questions.

The least dangerous branch

In Federalist No. 78 Alexander Hamilton argued that the judiciary would be "the least dangerous" branch. It has no influence over "the sword or the purse", he wrote, and so has "neither FORCE nor WILL, but merely judgment." Courts depend on the executive to enforce their rulings and on the public to accept them. Hamilton also argued that courts must be able to treat laws contrary to the Constitution as void, or written limits on government would mean little. That argument anticipated the power the Supreme Court would soon claim for itself.

Humble beginnings

The Judiciary Act of 1789 set up federal district courts and circuit courts beneath the Supreme Court; the modern courts of appeals were added in 1891. The early Court struggled. In Chisholm v. Georgia (1793) it allowed a citizen of one state to sue another state in federal court, and the states responded with the Eleventh Amendment (1795), which overturned the ruling. The first chief justice, John Jay, left in 1795 to serve as New York's governor and refused a later offer to come back. The Court met in borrowed rooms, mostly in the Capitol, until its own building opened in 1935.

Worked example: Marbury v. Madison (1803)

Follow the reasoning that created judicial review. 1. In his last days in office, President John Adams appointed William Marbury a justice of the peace, but the commission was not delivered. 2. The new secretary of state, James Madison, refused to deliver it, and Marbury asked the Supreme Court for a writ of mandamus, an order to an official, under the Judiciary Act of 1789. 3. Chief Justice John Marshall held that Marbury had a right to his commission. 4. But the act's grant of that power to the Supreme Court enlarged the Court's original jurisdiction beyond what Article III allows. 5. A law in conflict with the Constitution is void, so the Court could not issue the writ. 6. Result: Marbury lost, but the Court gained the power of judicial review.

Judicial review in practice

Judicial review is the power of courts to declare laws and government actions unconstitutional and therefore void. It is not written in the Constitution; Marshall grounded it in the logic of a written constitution, saying it is "emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is." The Supreme Court has used it against Congress far less often than against the states. Lower federal courts and state courts exercise it too. It has produced some of the worst rulings in the Court's history, such as Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), which denied that Black Americans could be citizens, and some of the most celebrated, such as Brown v. Board of Education (1954).

Judge-made law and public policy

The United States inherited the common law system from England. In it, judges' decisions in individual cases become binding precedents that guide later cases, so much of the law is built up case by case. In code law systems, used across much of Europe and Latin America, detailed written codes leave judges a smaller role. Because American judges interpret statutes and the Constitution as cases arise, they help make policy, focusing on the specific people and facts before them. Losing sides in the legislature often turn to the courts for a second chance.

Worked example: the courts and the Affordable Care Act

Trace how court rulings shaped one major law after it passed in 2010. 1. Opponents argued that requiring most people to buy health insurance exceeded Congress's powers. 2. In NFIB v. Sebelius (2012) the Court upheld the requirement, five votes to four, as a valid use of the taxing power, but let states opt out of the Medicaid expansion. 3. In Burwell v. Hobby Lobby (2014) it exempted certain closely held for-profit companies with religious objections from covering contraceptives, under a federal religious freedom law. 4. In King v. Burwell (2015) it upheld tax credits for insurance bought on federally run exchanges. 5. In California v. Texas (2021) it dismissed another challenge because the challengers lacked standing. 6. Lesson: each ruling refined how the law works, giving both sides some wins.

Courts as a last resort for individuals

American courts are adversarial: two sides present their case, and an impartial judge or jury decides. That lets a single person or an unpopular group press claims that legislatures ignore. Many rights Americans now take for granted came from individual cases: a lawyer for poor defendants in Gideon v. Wainwright (1963), warnings before police questioning in Miranda v. Arizona (1966), and a warrant to search a phone in Riley v. California (2014). Courts also enforce statutes: in 2015 the Supreme Court held that an employer could violate the Civil Rights Act by refusing to hire an applicant to avoid accommodating her religious headscarf.

Balancing rights and government interests

Courts rarely grant rights without limit; they weigh individual claims against the government's need to keep order and serve the public. The death penalty shows the balance. In Gregg v. Georgia (1976) the Court held that capital punishment does not in itself violate the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment. It later set limits: no executions of people with intellectual disabilities (2002), of offenders who were under 18 at the time of the crime (2005), or for the rape of a child where the victim did not die (2008).

Limits on judicial power

Courts hear only parties with standing, meaning a concrete injury the court can remedy, and only cases that are ripe, not premature, and not moot, already resolved. They avoid political questions, such as how Congress runs its own proceedings, that the Constitution leaves to elected branches. Congress sets the size of the Supreme Court, nine since 1869, and much of its appellate jurisdiction. It can rewrite a statute the Court has interpreted, and amendments can overturn constitutional rulings, as the Eleventh did to Chisholm and the Fourteenth did to Dred Scott. Courts also follow stare decisis, "let the decision stand", deferring to precedent except in rare cases.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, the Constitution does not mention judicial review; Marbury established it in 1803. Second, Marbury did not win; the Court ruled that it lacked power to give him his commission. Third, judicial review is not only for the Supreme Court; lower federal and state courts use it too. Fourth, "the least dangerous branch" does not mean the weakest in practice; Hamilton meant that it cannot enforce its own rulings. Fifth, courts cannot pick issues on their own; they need a real case brought by a party with standing.

Key takeaways

Article III creates one Supreme Court; judges serve during good behaviour and decide only real cases. Hamilton called the judiciary the least dangerous branch. The early Court was weak until Marbury v. Madison (1803) established judicial review. In a common law system, courts shape policy case by case, as the Affordable Care Act rulings show, and offer individuals a last resort. They balance rights against government interests and are limited by standing, ripeness, mootness, political questions, Congress and amendments.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Article III

Creates "one supreme Court" and lets Congress create lower courts

The shortest of the three branch articles.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did Hamilton call the judiciary "the least dangerous" branch in Federalist No. 78?

Question 2 of 5

In Marbury v. Madison (1803), why did the Supreme Court refuse to order Madison to deliver Marbury's commission?

Question 3 of 5

How did the states respond to the Supreme Court's ruling in Chisholm v. Georgia (1793)?

Question 4 of 5

In NFIB v. Sebelius (2012), on what basis did the Court uphold the requirement to buy health insurance?

Question 5 of 5

A group asks a federal court to rule on whether a proposed law, not yet passed, would be constitutional. What will the court most likely do?

← Previous topicNext topic →