American Government › Section C · Federalism › Topic C.2
How federalism has evolved
The Constitution sketches federalism in broad strokes, so the line between national and state power has been redrawn many times: by Supreme Court rulings, a civil war, an economic collapse and changing political ideas about who should govern what.
A framework, not a manual
The topic "The division of powers" set out the Constitution's federal design: enumerated national powers, reserved state powers and a supremacy clause. What the text does not do is settle every boundary. Is a national bank "necessary and proper"? Is a factory part of interstate commerce? Because such questions have no single obvious answer, the balance between Washington and the states has shifted from era to era. Political scientists label the eras dual, cooperative and new federalism. The labels overlap and simplify, but they capture real changes in how far national power reached.
McCulloch v. Maryland (1819)
Alexander Hamilton won a national bank charter in 1791 over Thomas Jefferson's objection that the Constitution gave no such power. Maryland later taxed the Baltimore branch of the Second Bank, chartered in 1816. In McCulloch v. Maryland (1819), Chief Justice John Marshall ruled for the bank on both questions. Congress could create it under the necessary and proper clause, because it was a suitable means of carrying out listed powers such as taxing and borrowing: the doctrine of implied powers. And Maryland could not tax it, because "the power to tax involves the power to destroy" and the supremacy clause protects lawful federal activity.
Worked example: reading Marshall's reasoning
Analyse McCulloch as an argument. 1. The question: may Congress do something the Constitution never mentions? 2. Marshall's premise: a government given great ends, such as taxing, borrowing and supporting armies, must be allowed suitable means to reach them. 3. The text: "necessary and proper" means useful or appropriate, not absolutely indispensable. 4. Conclusion one: the bank is constitutional. 5. Second premise: states cannot control lawful federal action. 6. Conclusion two: Maryland's tax is void. 7. Check: Jefferson read "necessary" as "indispensable"; Marshall's broader reading has guided Congress ever since.
Commerce, nullification and civil war
In Gibbons v. Ogden (1824) Marshall read the commerce clause broadly: commerce included navigation, so a federal coasting licence beat a New York steamboat monopoly. States pushed back. The Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions (1798) declared the Alien and Sedition Acts unconstitutional, and John C. Calhoun later developed the doctrine of nullification: a state could void a federal law within its borders. South Carolina tried it against the tariffs of 1828 and 1832, until the Force Bill and a compromise tariff ended the crisis in 1833. The final test came when eleven southern states seceded in 1860-1861 to protect slavery. Union victory ended any claimed right to secede, and the Fourteenth Amendment let Washington protect rights against the states.
Dual federalism: the layer cake
From the late 1870s to the 1930s, the Supreme Court largely followed dual federalism: national and state governments had separate spheres, like the layers of a cake. Congress began regulating big business with the Sherman Antitrust Act (1890), but the Court narrowed such laws. In United States v. E. C. Knight Co. (1895) it held that manufacturing was not commerce, so a sugar monopoly escaped. In Hammer v. Dagenhart (1918) it struck down a federal ban on shipping goods made by child labour. States met limits too: in Lochner v. New York (1905) the Court voided a cap on bakers' hours as a breach of liberty of contract under the Fourteenth Amendment.
Cooperative federalism: the marble cake
The Great Depression, with unemployment near 25% by 1933, pushed Washington and the states to act together. At first the Court struck down New Deal laws such as the National Industrial Recovery Act. After President Franklin Roosevelt proposed adding up to six justices in 1937, the Court changed course, upholding the National Labor Relations Act in NLRB v. Jones and Laughlin Steel (1937). In Wickard v. Filburn (1942) it held that even wheat a farmer grew for use on his own farm could be regulated, because many such farmers together affected interstate markets. The political scientist Morton Grodzins called the result a marble cake: national, state and local roles swirled together in jointly funded programmes such as unemployment insurance.
The Great Society and civil rights
In the 1960s President Lyndon Johnson's Great Society deepened national involvement. Medicare and Medicaid (1965) and federal school aid expanded Washington's role, often through states. National power was also turned against state segregation. Brown v. Board of Education (1954) required desegregation of public schools; the Civil Rights Act of 1964 banned discrimination in places such as hotels and restaurants, upheld under the commerce clause in Heart of Atlanta Motel v. United States (1964); and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 put federal oversight on election rules in places with a history of discrimination.
New federalism
Critics later argued that Washington had grown too large and too uniform. President Richard Nixon's general revenue sharing (1972) sent money to states and cities with few strings attached. President Ronald Reagan promised a "devolution" of power, merging dozens of narrow grants into broader block grants in 1981, though Congress never adopted his plan to hand some major welfare programmes entirely to the states. The Court joined in. In United States v. Lopez (1995) it struck down the Gun-Free School Zones Act, holding that carrying a gun near a school was not economic activity substantially affecting interstate commerce: the first such limit on the commerce power in nearly sixty years.
Worked example: Wickard, Lopez and Raich
Compare three commerce clause cases. 1. Wickard (1942): home-grown wheat is economic activity, and its combined effect on the national wheat market is substantial, so Congress may regulate it. 2. Lopez (1995): gun possession near a school is not economic activity, and the link to commerce runs through a long chain of inferences, so Congress may not. 3. Gonzales v. Raich (2005): home-grown marijuana for medical use, legal under California law, is like Wickard's wheat, part of a national market Congress regulates, so the federal ban applies. 4. Pattern: the Court asks whether the activity is economic and whether, added up, it substantially affects interstate commerce. 5. Lesson: Lopez trimmed the commerce power without reversing Wickard.
The pendulum since 2000
Recent decades show movement in both directions. After the 11 September 2001 attacks, Congress federalised airport screening, and laws such as No Child Left Behind (2002) and the Affordable Care Act (2010) set national rules for state-run systems. Other rulings shifted decisions to the states. In Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022) the Court held that the Constitution does not confer a right to abortion, overruling Roe v. Wade and returning the issue to elected officials. Supporters and critics disagree sharply about the ruling, but states have since adopted very different abortion laws.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, McCulloch did two things: it upheld implied powers and it barred state taxes on federal institutions. Second, dual federalism did not mean a weak national government in every field; it meant separate spheres, with the Court policing the line. Third, the switch to cooperative federalism came with the Court's change of course in 1937, not with Roosevelt's court-packing plan, which Congress never passed. Fourth, Lopez limited the commerce power without overturning Wickard.
Key takeaways
McCulloch (1819) established implied powers and national supremacy; Gibbons (1824) read the commerce clause broadly. Nullification and secession failed, and the Civil War amendments strengthened national power. Dual federalism, the layer cake, kept spheres separate from the late 1870s to the 1930s (E. C. Knight, Lochner, Hammer). Cooperative federalism, the marble cake, followed the New Deal and Wickard (1942), deepened by the Great Society and civil rights laws. New federalism under Nixon and Reagan sought devolution, and Lopez (1995) limited the commerce power. Since 2000 the balance has moved both ways, with Dobbs (2022) returning abortion law to elected officials, chiefly in the states.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Congress may charter a bank as an implied power, and states may not tax it
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What were the two holdings of McCulloch v. Maryland (1819)?
Question 2 of 5
Which pairing correctly matches a model of federalism with its image?
Question 3 of 5
Why did the Court in Wickard v. Filburn (1942) allow regulation of wheat a farmer grew for his own use?
Question 4 of 5
What did United States v. Lopez (1995) decide?
Question 5 of 5
In Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022), what did the Supreme Court hold?
