American Government › Section M · The courts › Topic M.2

The dual court system

The United States runs two court systems side by side: one for the nation and one in every state. Knowing which system hears which dispute, and how a case can cross from one to the other, explains a great deal about how justice actually works.

Two systems, three tiers each

The colonies had their own courts long before the Constitution created a national judiciary, and each state kept them. The result is a dual court system: a federal system created under Article III and Congress's laws, and fifty separate state systems created by state constitutions and laws. Both sides usually have three tiers: trial courts, where evidence is heard and facts decided; intermediate appellate courts, which review trials for legal errors; and a court of last resort. The US Supreme Court sits above both sides, but it can review a state case only when it raises a question of federal law.

Criminal and civil cases

Courts hear two broad kinds of dispute. In a criminal case a government charges a person with breaking a law that defines harmful conduct and sets a punishment, which is why case names such as Miranda v. Arizona carry the government's name. Crimes are graded as felonies, the more serious, or misdemeanours. Guilt must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. In a civil case private parties, or a government acting like one, dispute rights and duties such as contracts, injuries or property, and the plaintiff usually needs only a preponderance of the evidence: more likely than not. In both kinds, most cases end in plea bargains or settlements, not trials.

State courts carry most of the load

About nine in ten American court cases are heard in state courts, which receive tens of millions of new cases a year against fewer than a million in the federal courts. Most crimes, including robbery, assault and murder, break state laws. State courts also handle most traffic, family, divorce, juvenile, probate, personal injury, contract and property cases. Federal courts hear cases arising under the Constitution, federal laws and treaties; cases in which the United States is a party; disputes between states; and fields Congress has assigned them, such as bankruptcy, patents, copyright and maritime law.

Diversity and concurrent jurisdiction

Federal courts can also hear diversity cases: lawsuits between citizens of different states, or with foreign citizens, when more than $75,000 is at stake. The idea is that an out-of-state party might not get a fair hearing in the other side's home courts. Many such cases could equally go to a state court; when both systems may hear a case, they have concurrent jurisdiction, and the plaintiff usually chooses. Some subjects, such as bankruptcy and federal crimes, belong to federal courts alone. Others, such as divorce and probate, stay in state courts even when the parties live in different states.

Worked example: choosing a court

A driver from Florida is badly injured when a delivery van owned by a Georgia company crashes into her in Georgia. She sues for $180,000. 1. The claim is negligence, a matter of state law, so a state court can hear it. 2. The parties are citizens of different states and the amount exceeds $75,000, so diversity jurisdiction lets her file in federal district court instead. 3. Because both courts could hear it, jurisdiction is concurrent. 4. She might choose federal court if she worries that a Georgia jury would favour a local business. 5. Even in federal court, the judge applies Georgia's negligence law, because the claim arises under state law. 6. Check: had she sued for $50,000, only a state court could hear it.

How state cases reach the Supreme Court

A case that begins in a state court normally stays there. Only a question of federal law, such as a claim that police violated the Fourth Amendment, can carry it to the US Supreme Court, and usually only after the state's own appeals are exhausted. The Supreme Court then decides that federal question, not the whole case. If it rules on federal grounds, its answer binds the state courts. But when a state court rests its decision on the state's own constitution or laws, which may protect rights more generously, the state's highest court has the final word on what that state law means.

Worked example: Ernesto Miranda's two trials

Trace one case through both systems. 1. In 1963 Ernesto Miranda was arrested in Arizona for kidnapping and rape, crimes under state law, and confessed after police questioning. 2. An Arizona court convicted him, largely on that confession, and the Arizona Supreme Court upheld the verdict. 3. He appealed to the US Supreme Court on a federal question: whether the confession violated his Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination. 4. In 1966 the Court ruled five votes to four that police must warn suspects of their rights before questioning, and overturned the conviction. 5. The Court did not decide whether he was guilty. 6. Arizona retried him without the confession, and in 1967 he was convicted again on other evidence. 7. Lesson: states decide guilt; federal courts guard federal rights.

Fifty different state systems

No two state court systems are alike. They differ in structure, names and jurisdiction. In New York the "Supreme Court" is a trial court and the Court of Appeals is the highest court, while Texas and Oklahoma each have two courts of last resort, one for civil and one for criminal cases. States also choose judges differently: some hold partisan or nonpartisan elections, some let the governor appoint, some use merit selection followed by retention elections in which voters decide whether a judge stays, and a few let the legislature choose. Most states use elections at some stage, which raises debates about campaign money and judicial independence.

Strengths and weaknesses of a dual system

The dual system gives people more than one place to seek protection. A person who loses in state court may still win on a federal question, as Miranda did, and a state court may protect a right more broadly than federal law does. Variety among the states lets different approaches be tried. The cost is unevenness. The same conduct can be legal in one state and a crime in the next: as of 2025, recreational marijuana was legal under the laws of about 24 states but remained illegal under federal law everywhere. Both systems can even prosecute the same act, as the topic "The rights of suspects" explains.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, most cases are not federal: about nine in ten are heard in state courts. Second, the federal system is not simply "above" the state systems; a state case reaches the US Supreme Court only on a federal question. Third, diversity jurisdiction needs both different states and more than $75,000 at stake. Fourth, a state's highest court is not always called the supreme court, as New York shows. Fifth, overturning a conviction on constitutional grounds is not a finding of innocence; the state may retry the defendant.

Key takeaways

The United States has a federal court system and fifty state systems, each usually with trial courts, intermediate appellate courts and a court of last resort. Criminal cases need proof beyond a reasonable doubt; civil cases usually a preponderance of the evidence. State courts hear about nine in ten cases. Federal courts hear federal questions, cases involving the United States, disputes between states and diversity cases above $75,000, sometimes concurrently with state courts. State cases reach the US Supreme Court only on federal questions, as Miranda's case shows. State courts vary in structure and judicial selection, which widens access but makes the law uneven.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Dual court system

Separate federal and state court systems operating side by side

The Supreme Court sits above both.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which kind of case is most likely to be heard in a state court rather than a federal court?

Question 2 of 5

A resident of Ohio sues a Michigan company for $40,000 over a broken contract. Can the case be heard in federal court on diversity grounds?

Question 3 of 5

What standard of proof applies in most civil cases?

Question 4 of 5

After the Supreme Court overturned Ernesto Miranda's conviction in 1966, what happened?

Question 5 of 5

When can a case that began in a state court be reviewed by the US Supreme Court?

← Previous topicNext topic →