Anthropology › Section R · Humans and animals › Topic R.3

Symbolism and meaning of animals

Eagles on flags, lions on football shirts, a raven in a creation story, a cow that may not be killed: animals carry meaning far beyond their bodies. This topic looks at how people use animals to mark group identity, teach lessons and reach the sacred.

Animals as signs

Animals are among humanity's most common symbols. The bald eagle stands for the United States, the kiwi for New Zealanders, and sports teams from the Detroit Lions to the Boston Bruins pick animals for the qualities fans want to claim. Anthropologists ask what such choices mean and how they work. Three uses stand out. Animals mark the identity of groups, from clans to nations. Animals in stories model good and bad behaviour. And animals in religion act as messengers, offerings or sacred beings. In each case the animal's real habits, its strength, cunning or gentleness, supply material for meaning.

Totemism

Totemism is a system in which a social group, usually a clan, claims a special, often ancestral, relationship with a species of animal or plant, its totem. Members may treat the totem with respect, avoid harming it and use it as their emblem. The word comes from the Anishinaabe (Ojibwe) language, in which a doodem is a clan; an English trader, John Long, put it into print as totam in 1791. Anishinaabe clans were named after animals such as the crane, loon, bear, marten and fish. A child took the clan of its father, and people of the same clan could not marry, so the totem also organised descent and marriage across scattered communities.

Explaining totemism

Totemism fascinated early theorists. Émile Durkheim, in The Elementary Forms of Religious Life (1912), drew on reports about Aboriginal Australian peoples such as the Arrernte. He argued that the totem is the emblem of the clan, so when people revere it they are really revering their own society. Claude Lévi-Strauss, in Totemism (1962), took a different route. He argued that species are chosen not because they are useful but because they are good to think: the visible differences between bear, crane and fish give people a ready-made code for the differences between clans. Later scholars warned that grouping very different systems under one label can mislead.

Crests and poles

On the Northwest Coast of North America, peoples such as the Haida, Tlingit, Tsimshian and Kwakwaka'wakw display animal crests, including Raven, Eagle, Bear and Killer Whale, that belong to particular lineages and record their histories and rights. Carved cedar poles, often called totem poles, show these crests. Some stand before houses, some mark memorials or graves, and some are raised at potlatches, the feasts where titles and rights are publicly confirmed. Poles were never objects of worship, a common outsider error. Canada banned the potlatch from 1885 to 1951, and many poles were taken to museums. Not all Indigenous peoples of North America carve poles.

Worked example: is a mascot a totem?

A university's teams are the Wolves; fans wear wolf ears and howl at games. Compare this with totemism. 1. Emblem: the wolf marks group identity, as a totem does. 2. Ritual: chants and costumes are collective behaviour that builds solidarity, which Durkheim would recognise. 3. Descent: membership comes from enrolment or loyalty, not from birth into a clan, and no one claims a wolf ancestor. 4. Marriage and respect: fans face no rule against marrying fellow fans and no duty to protect wolves. 5. Conclusion: a mascot shares totemism's emblematic side but lacks its links to kinship, marriage rules and spiritual relationship, so it is an analogy, not an example.

Animals in stories

Animal tales teach in every society. Europe's include the fables credited to Aesop, a Greek storyteller of about the 6th century BCE, and folk tales collected by the brothers Grimm from 1812. Many Indigenous North American traditions feature tricksters: clever, greedy, funny figures who break rules, make mistakes and sometimes create the world in the process. Coyote plays this role among many western peoples, and Raven among Northwest Coast peoples, where in one Haida story he steals the light and releases the sun. Stories about Anansi the spider come from the Akan of Ghana; enslaved Africans carried them to the Caribbean, where they are still told.

Animals and the sacred

In religion, animals often carry messages or serve as offerings. In Genesis, a dove returns to Noah's ark with an olive leaf, a sign that the flood is ending. Many traditions practise sacrifice, such as the sheep, goats and cattle killed at the Muslim festival of Eid al-Adha in memory of Abraham's readiness to sacrifice his son. In the Andes, guinea pigs, raised for food in kitchens for thousands of years, are also used in healing: some healers rub a live guinea pig over a patient's body, then open it to diagnose the illness from its organs. Buddhism teaches that beings are reborn as humans or animals according to karma, so animals deserve compassion.

Sacred cattle and dirty pigs

Two classic studies asked why some animals are protected or forbidden. Cattle are sacred in Hinduism, and most Hindus avoid beef. The cultural materialist Marvin Harris, in a 1966 article, argued that the taboo makes ecological sense in India: living cattle provide oxen to pull ploughs, dung for fuel and fertiliser, and milk, which outweigh their value as meat. The British anthropologist Mary Douglas, in Purity and Danger (1966), analysed the forbidden animals of the Hebrew Bible. Leviticus permits animals that both chew the cud and have split hooves; the pig has split hooves but does not chew the cud. Douglas argued that it was unclean because it broke the scheme's categories.

Worked example: weighing Harris's argument

Evaluate Harris's explanation of India's sacred cattle. 1. Claim: protecting cattle maximises their total usefulness. 2. Evidence for: oxen are essential for ploughing small farms, dung is a major fuel, and dead cattle still supply hides and, for some communities, meat. 3. Evidence against: historians note that beef was eaten in early Vedic times, and that the taboo strengthened over centuries through religious and political change, not only through ecology. 4. Missing piece: Harris says little about what cows mean to worshippers, such as their link to motherhood and purity. 5. Conclusion: the material benefits are real, but they explain why the taboo is sustainable more than why it holds such religious meaning.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling any animal emblem a totem: totemism links a group to a species through descent, respect or spiritual kinship. Second, assuming totem poles were worshipped or were carved by all Indigenous North Americans; they display lineage crests and histories, and come mainly from the Northwest Coast. Third, treating tricksters as simply villains or heroes; they are both, and their mistakes teach. Fourth, accepting either a purely material or a purely symbolic explanation of food taboos without testing both. Fifth, describing other peoples' animal beliefs as quaint superstitions rather than coherent systems of meaning.

Key takeaways

Animals mark group identity, teach through stories and mediate the sacred. Totemism, a word from the Anishinaabe doodem, ties a clan to a species and often regulates descent and marriage. Durkheim saw the totem as the clan's emblem and society revering itself; Lévi-Strauss saw species as good to think. Northwest Coast poles display lineage crests, not idols. Tricksters such as Coyote, Raven and Anansi teach through mischief. Animals serve as messengers, sacrifices and healing tools. Harris explained India's sacred cattle by their usefulness, and Douglas explained the pig taboo in Leviticus as a category anomaly; each explanation captures only part of the story.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Totemism

A group's special, often ancestral, relationship with a species

Often linked to clans, descent and marriage rules.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A clan claims descent from the bear, may not marry within the clan, and treats bears with respect. What is this?

Question 2 of 5

What did Lévi-Strauss argue about why particular species become totems?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement about Northwest Coast poles is accurate?

Question 4 of 5

According to Mary Douglas, why is the pig forbidden in Leviticus?

Question 5 of 5

What is the main weakness of Harris's explanation of India's sacred cattle?

← Previous topicNext topic →