Anthropology › Section R · Humans and animals › Topic R.2
Animals and subsistence
For hunters and herders, animals are not just food on the hoof: they are partners, adversaries and sometimes persons. How people make a living from animals shapes how they think about them, and the contrast between a hunter's prey and a herder's flock is one of the clearest in anthropology.
Making a living with animals
Subsistence is the way a group gets its food and other necessities, and the section Economic anthropology compared its main modes. In foraging and herding societies, animals supply meat, fat, hides, bone, sinew, wool, milk and transport, and their behaviour sets the rhythm of the year. Survival depends on knowing them intimately. Anthropologists use the term animal empathy for the sense of being attuned to another creature's feelings and intentions. Elaborate beliefs and rituals about the bond between people and animals are common among hunters and herders, but their content differs, because killing a wild animal and raising a tame one are very different relationships.
An ancient partnership
Close attention to animals is very old. The anthropologist Pat Shipman, in The Animal Connection (2011), proposed that the need to watch, predict and outwit animals pushed early humans towards sharper observation, toolmaking and, eventually, symbols; later she argued that alliances with wolf-dogs helped modern humans out-compete Neanderthals. Both ideas are hypotheses that other researchers dispute. The evidence of attention itself is clear, though. In the Lascaux cave in southwestern France, people painted horses, aurochs, deer, bison and other animals about 17,000 years ago, often in lifelike motion. The cave was closed to visitors in 1963 to protect the paintings and is part of a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
Hunters and their prey
Hunters cannot control the animals they depend on; they must find them, understand them and persuade them to come within reach. Many Indigenous hunting peoples regard animals as fellow persons with their own minds, spirits and social lives, with whom people must keep a relationship of respect. The anthropologist Nurit Bird-David, working with the Nayaka of southern India from the late 1970s, described a view of the forest as a giving parent rather than a store of resources. Hunters in such societies commonly perform rituals before and after a hunt, both to show respect and to keep the animals willing to return. Success depends on behaving well towards the prey.
Becoming the elk
Rane Willerslev lived with Yukaghir hunters in Siberia in the 1990s and described their methods in Soul Hunters (2007). Before a hunt, men took sauna baths to reduce their human scent and avoided speaking directly about killing, so that the animals' spirits would not overhear. A hunter wore skis covered in elk skin, so that his steps sounded like an elk's in the snow, and imitated an elk's movements to draw one close. Hunters spoke of seducing the animal's spirit. Yet imitation carried a risk: a hunter who identified too fully with his prey might lose his own human identity. For the Yukaghir the hunt was a dangerous relationship between near-equals.
Worked example: Grateful Prey
In Grateful Prey (1993), Robert Brightman described the Rock Cree, who call themselves Asinskâwôiniwak, of northern Manitoba, Canada. Analyse their hunting ethics. 1. Belief: animals have bodies and spirits, regenerate after death, and can be killed only if they choose to give themselves to the hunter. 2. Practice: hunters offer prayers, songs, food and tobacco before a hunt, waste no part of a kill, and hang the bones in trees, out of reach of dogs and other scavengers. 3. Logic: respect keeps the relationship going, because offended animals will not return and the hunter will go hungry. 4. Context: many Rock Cree now combine hunting and trapping with wage work, so fur prices matter too. 5. Conclusion: an ethic of reciprocity, not only technique, organises the hunt.
Tamed is not domesticated
Hunting peoples often keep animals too, but usually tamed rather than domesticated ones. A tamed animal is a wild individual that has learned to tolerate people's closeness for long periods, such as a young parrot or monkey whose mother was killed in a hunt. A domesticated animal belongs to a population whose breeding people have controlled over many generations. In much of lowland South America, children raise the young of hunted animals as household pets, and caring for them teaches the children how animals move and behave. Taming changes one animal's life; domestication changes a species.
Herders and their flocks
Pastoralists, discussed in Pastoralism, also feel empathy for their animals, but the relationship is one of daily care and control rather than pursuit. Herders decide where animals graze, protect them from predators, help at births and choose which ones will breed or be slaughtered. Because the animals are tamer, herders can milk them, shear them and use them for transport, which hunters of the same species cannot. Herd animals are property and wealth, passed between generations and given at marriages. In The Nuer (1940), E. E. Evans-Pritchard described Nuer men in what is now South Sudan who took names from their favourite oxen and composed songs about them.
Reindeer: hunted and herded
Reindeer show both relationships within one species. Wild reindeer, called caribou in North America, are hunted by peoples such as the Inuit and Dene. Domestic reindeer are herded by peoples including the Sámi of Norway, Sweden, Finland and Russia and the Nenets of Siberia. Herded reindeer remain semi-wild, grazing freely for much of the year, and herders follow their seasonal migrations between winter and summer pastures. In return for meat, hides, milk and transport, herders give protection from wolves, salt and extra food. Anthropologists describe the relationship as symbiotic: each species benefits from the other.
Worked example: hunting, taming or herding?
Classify each case from field notes. 1. A family raises a young woolly monkey caught after its mother was hunted; no monkeys are bred: taming, because only an individual wild animal has been habituated to people. 2. Hunters leave tobacco for the spirit of a moose before tracking it and hang its bones afterwards: hunting with ritual respect, because the animal remains wild and uncontrolled. 3. A household chooses which goats will mate, milks the females and moves the flock between seasonal pastures: herding of domesticated animals, because people control breeding and daily life. 4. Check: the key questions are who controls breeding and whether the animals are wild individuals or a managed population.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming hunters see animals as mere resources: many treat them as persons owed respect. Second, treating respect rituals as superstition without function; they also express ecological knowledge and rules against waste. Third, confusing a tamed animal with a domesticated species. Fourth, assuming herders and hunters relate to animals in the same way: herders control breeding and daily life, hunters do not. Fifth, describing today's hunters as living outside the modern economy, when many combine hunting with wage work and trade. Sixth, presenting Shipman's ideas as established fact rather than debated hypotheses.
Key takeaways
Hunters and herders depend on detailed knowledge of animals, and both show animal empathy, but in different forms. Many Indigenous hunters, such as the Yukaghir studied by Willerslev and the Rock Cree studied by Brightman, treat prey as persons in a relationship of respect and reciprocity, with rituals, rules against waste and care for bones. Taming habituates an individual wild animal; domestication controls a population's breeding. Herders manage their animals daily, use milk, wool and transport, and treat herds as wealth, as Evans-Pritchard showed for Nuer cattle. Reindeer are hunted as caribou and herded by the Sámi and Nenets.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The way a group obtains its food and other necessities
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why do Rock Cree hunters hang the bones of a kill in trees and avoid wasting any part of it?
Question 2 of 5
A family raises a young monkey whose mother was killed in a hunt, and no monkeys are bred. What is this?
Question 3 of 5
Why did Yukaghir hunters wear skis covered in elk skin?
Question 4 of 5
What can herders usually do with their animals that hunters of the same species cannot?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about Pat Shipman's ideas is accurate?
