Anthropology › Section N · Anthropology of food › Topic N.1
Food as a material artifact
Meals vanish, but they leave traces: cut bones, burnt seeds, stained pots, worn teeth and the chemistry of the skeleton itself. Reading those traces lets anthropologists reconstruct how people ate, worked and ranked one another, and it connects ancient kitchens to living food heritage.
Why food leaves a record
Every society spends a large share of its time getting, processing, sharing and disposing of food, so food is one of the richest sources of evidence anthropologists have. Archaeologists treat it as a material artifact: something shaped by human hands and choices, and left behind in the ground. A single layer of rubbish can show which animals and plants people used, how food was cooked and stored, and who did the work. The term foodways covers this whole chain, from getting food to preparing, serving, eating and discarding it, together with the meanings attached at each step.
The deepest traces
The oldest food evidence comes from bones. Stone-tool cut marks on animal bones from Bouri in Ethiopia, about 2.5 million years old, show early hominins removing meat and marrow. Marks on bones from Dikika, about 3.4 million years old, have been claimed as older still, but researchers dispute whether stone tools made them. Cooking is harder to detect, because fire leaves ash that can blow away. At Klasies River in South Africa, Cynthia Larbey and colleagues reported in 2019 charred fragments of starchy plants in hearths about 120,000 years old, among the earliest direct evidence of people cooking plant foods.
Kinds of food evidence
Archaeologists draw on many kinds of evidence. Animal bones, studied by zooarchaeologists, show species, age at death and butchery. Plant remains, recovered by washing soil so that charred seeds float, show crops and wild foods; microscopic starch grains and phytoliths, tiny silica bodies made by plants, survive even where seeds rot. Shell middens are large heaps of discarded shells and other waste. Coprolites, preserved human faeces, record what one person actually swallowed. Hearths, ovens, storage pits, baskets and pots show how food was processed and kept. Each source has blind spots, so researchers combine several before drawing conclusions.
Reading diet in the skeleton
Bones also record diet chemically, through stable isotope analysis. Stable isotopes are forms of an element that do not decay, so they are not radioactive. Carbon isotopes separate two groups of plants: most trees, wheat, rice and beans follow one photosynthetic pathway, called C3, while maize, sorghum, millet and sugar cane follow another, called C4, which leaves relatively more carbon-13. Nitrogen isotopes rise by a step with each level of the food chain, so meat eaters and fish eaters show higher values than people living mainly on plants. Because bone collagen renews over years, a sample summarises an individual's diet over a long stretch of life.
Worked example: when did maize arrive?
In a simplified model, bone collagen from someone eating only C3 foods measures about −21 per mil for carbon, and from someone eating only C4 foods about −7 per mil. A skeleton from a later village measures −14 per mil. Estimate the share of C4 food. 1. Find the full range: −7 − (−21) = 14 units. 2. Find how far the sample sits above the C3 end: −14 − (−21) = 7 units. 3. Divide: 7 ÷ 14 = 0.5, so roughly half the dietary carbon came from C4 plants, most plausibly maize. 4. Check: an earlier skeleton at −20 per mil gives 1 ÷ 14, about 7%. Real studies refine this, since protein and marine foods shift the values.
The daily grind
Grinding stones are among the most common food tools. Jennie Ebeling and Yorke Rowan, writing in 2004 about the southern Levant, showed how mortars, pestles, hand stones and grinding slabs changed from foragers to early farmers, and how prized stones such as basalt were traded. Skeletons add the human cost. At Abu Hureyra in Syria, a village of early farmers about 10,000 years ago, Theya Molleson reported in the 1990s that many women's toes, knees and lower backs showed damage consistent with long hours kneeling at a grinding slab. Dental decay also became more common as starchy cereals became staples.
Residues in pots
Residue analysis identifies the chemical traces of what a container once held. In 2002, W. Jeffrey Hurst and colleagues detected theobromine, a compound found in cacao, in Maya vessels from Colha in Belize dated to about 600 BCE, pushing back the evidence for cacao drinks. Fats absorbed into unglazed pottery can show whether a pot held milk, meat or fish. Because elite and commoner households often used different vessels, residues can reveal how foods marked rank as well as what people ate.
Worked example: reading a midden
A coastal midden has two layers. The lower layer yields 240 oyster shells, 40 fish bones and 20 deer bone fragments; the upper yields 60 oyster shells, 30 fish bones and 210 charred maize cob fragments. Interpret the change. 1. Percentages: oysters fall from 240 ÷ 300 = 80% of finds to 60 ÷ 300 = 20%. 2. New element: maize, absent below, is 70% of upper finds. 3. Caution: counts are not calories, and one cob breaks into many fragments, so 70% does not mean 70% of the diet. 4. Cross-check with isotopes or starch on tools. 5. Conclusion: the evidence points to a shift towards farming, but its scale needs other evidence.
Living foodways and heritage
Food is also cultural heritage: practices handed down and used to say who a people are. Ramps, wild leeks of the Appalachian mountains, have long been gathered by citizens of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians, whose land, the Qualla Boundary, borders Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Cherokee anthropologist Courtney Lewis (2012) analysed the conflict after the park banned ramp gathering and Cherokee harvesters were prosecuted: courts tended to favour park scientists over Cherokee knowledge of sustainable harvesting. In 2019 the park signed an agreement allowing Eastern Band citizens to gather sochan, another traditional green, within its boundaries.
Food on the world's heritage lists
UNESCO's 2003 Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage covers living traditions as well as monuments, and many entries concern food. Traditional Mexican cuisine and the French gastronomic meal were inscribed in 2010, Japanese washoku and Korean kimjang, the communal making of winter kimchi, in 2013, and the art of the Neapolitan pizzaiuolo in 2017. Listing honours the knowledge of cooks and growers, but anthropologists note that it can also freeze a tradition into one official version or turn it into a tourist brand.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, calling stable isotopes radioactive: they are stable, and radiocarbon dating uses a different, unstable isotope. Second, reading counts of bones or seeds as shares of the diet; fragments, preservation and recovery methods all distort counts. Third, trusting one line of evidence when bones, plants, residues and isotopes should be combined. Fourth, treating disputed finds, such as the Dikika cut marks, as settled. Fifth, assuming food preparation was too ordinary to study; daily grinding shaped bodies and labour. Sixth, treating heritage foods as relics, when communities such as the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians actively manage and defend them.
Key takeaways
Food is a material artifact whose traces show diet, work, technology and rank. Cut-marked bones about 2.5 million years old and charred starches at Klasies River about 120,000 years ago are early milestones. Evidence includes bones, plant remains, middens, coprolites, tools and residues, such as cacao at Colha about 600 BCE. Carbon isotopes separate C3 from C4 foods like maize, and nitrogen isotopes track position in the food chain. Grinding stones and skeletons such as those at Abu Hureyra reveal the labour of food. Today, food heritage is lived and contested, from Cherokee ramps to UNESCO listings.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The whole chain of getting, preparing, sharing, eating and discarding food, with its meanings
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why can carbon isotopes in bone show whether people ate maize?
Question 2 of 5
Using the simplified model with −21 per mil for a pure C3 diet and −7 per mil for a pure C4 diet, what share of C4 food does a value of −17.5 per mil suggest?
Question 3 of 5
A midden layer contains 210 maize fragments among 300 finds. What is the safest conclusion?
Question 4 of 5
What did skeletons from Abu Hureyra reveal about early farming?
Question 5 of 5
Courtney Lewis's study of Cherokee ramp gathering is best described as an example of what?
