Anthropology › Section C · The culture concept › Topic C.6

The paradoxes of culture and cultural change

Culture lasts for generations yet never stands still; it belongs to a place yet travels the world; it is agreed upon yet argued over; it is shared yet different for everyone. These four paradoxes explain how cultures change and why they survive change.

A tent with a solar panel

Visit a herding family on the Mongolian steppe today and you may find a ger much like those of centuries past: round, felt-covered, with its door facing south. Beside it stands a small solar panel, and inside a satellite dish feeds a television and phones are charging. Is this culture surviving or culture changing? It is both. Early anthropologists often pictured each culture as a stable, agreed set of traits tied to one territory. Since the mid-20th century the field has stressed instead that culture holds together through constant tension, which can be summed up as four paradoxes.

Paradox 1: continuous but changing

Culture is handed from older to younger generations, which gives it continuity, yet every handover allows change. Anthropologists distinguish several mechanisms. Invention creates a new element, often by combining existing ones in a new way, such as a new technology or religious movement. Innovation, in this course's usage, modifies an existing element, such as a new style of dance; some writers, including the Sociology course, use innovation as an umbrella term for discoveries and inventions. Diffusion moves elements between societies through trade, travel and migration. Friction arises when elements clash, as when mobile phones let young people bypass elders' control of who they talk to, forcing norms to adjust.

Contact, power and blending

When groups are in continuous contact, both change, a process called acculturation, though the less powerful group usually changes more. Assimilation goes further: a minority adopts the dominant culture until it is no longer distinct. Forced assimilation caused deep harm. From the late 19th to the late 20th century, residential and boarding schools in Canada, the United States and Australia took Indigenous children from their families and punished them for speaking their languages; Canada's Truth and Reconciliation Commission reported on this history in 2015. Contact can also produce syncretism, the blending of traditions into something new, as in Haitian Vodou, which joins West and Central African religions with Catholicism.

Paradox 2: bounded but mobile

Cultures are linked to places, yet their elements travel constantly. Chilli peppers were domesticated in the Americas and spread across the world after 1492; within a few centuries they had become central to dishes from India, Thailand and Sichuan, and red chilli became typical of Korean kimchi. Few people now think of these cuisines as borrowed. Global brands are also adapted locally, a process called glocalisation. Mobility raises questions of power, too. Cultural appropriation means taking elements of another, often marginalised, culture without understanding, credit or permission, for example selling sacred designs as fashion; people debate where respectful exchange ends and appropriation begins.

Paradox 3: consensual but contested

Culture works because people broadly agree on how things are done, yet members of the same culture argue over those same practices. Lobola, the bridewealth that a groom's family gives to a bride's family in many southern African communities, illustrates this. Many South Africans value it as a mark of respect that joins two families. Others, including young couples and women's rights advocates, argue that rising cash demands delay marriages, burden poor families or can be misread as buying a wife. The debate takes place largely among people who share the custom, which is typical: culture is both agreed and contested from within.

Paradox 4: shared but varied

A culture is shared, but no two members hold exactly the same version. Christmas in the United States is a religious festival for some, a secular family holiday for others, and a working day for nurses, many retail staff and people of other faiths. Class, region, gender, age and ethnicity shape how people take part. Even so, almost everyone in the country recognises the season's symbols and expectations. Anthropologists therefore study culture as patterned variation: shared enough to be recognisable, uneven enough that each group's view adds something to the picture.

Revival and invented tradition

Change is not always loss. Anthony Wallace described revitalisation movements (1956), deliberate efforts by a people under stress to build a more satisfying culture, often by renewing older ways. Many Indigenous communities today are reviving ceremonies, languages and land practices. The historians Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger showed in The Invention of Tradition (1983) that some customs presented as ancient are fairly recent; one chapter argued that the Highland kilt in its familiar form took shape in the 18th century. In the 1980s some scholars predicted a single global monoculture; instead many cultural identities have been renewed.

Worked example: tea in Britain

Trace the four paradoxes through British tea. 1. Mobile: tea came from China by trade in the 17th century, and was later grown in British-ruled India. 2. Power: the sugar stirred into it came from Caribbean plantations worked by enslaved Africans. 3. Continuous but changing: tea became a national habit, then shifted from loose leaves to tea bags in the 20th century, while coffee shops spread. 4. Varied: in many northern and working-class homes "tea" also names the evening meal, which others call dinner. 5. Contested: people still argue about milk first or tea first. 6. Check: one drink is local and global, stable and changing at once.

Worked example: naming the change

Classify each case. 1. A new dance step becomes a craze on a social media app: innovation, a change to an existing element. 2. Coffee spreads from Ethiopia and Yemen to Europe: diffusion. 3. Día de Muertos joins Indigenous ways of honouring ancestors with the Catholic All Souls' Day: syncretism. 4. A government bans a minority language in schools: forced assimilation. 5. A First Nation restores a banned ceremony and teaches it to youth: revitalisation. 6. Check: ask whether the element is new or modified, whether it crossed a boundary, and who held the power.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating change as the death of a culture: cultures survive by changing. Second, assuming change is always voluntary, when much has been forced through colonial rule. Third, confusing acculturation, change on both sides through contact, with assimilation, a minority's absorption. Fourth, thinking a recent tradition is fake: invented traditions are still meaningful. Fifth, picturing a culture as uniform, when members share it unevenly and argue over it.

Key takeaways

Culture is continuous but changing, bounded but mobile, consensual but contested, and shared but varied. Mechanisms of change include invention, innovation, diffusion and friction. Contact brings acculturation and sometimes assimilation, which was often forced, as in residential schools; it also brings syncretism and glocalisation. Cultural appropriation raises questions of power. Wallace's revitalisation movements (1956) and Hobsbawm and Ranger's invented traditions (1983) show that cultures also renew themselves. These tensions make culture both flexible and durable.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Four paradoxes

Continuous but changing, bounded but mobile, consensual but contested, shared but varied

Tensions that keep culture alive.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Chilli peppers, first domesticated in the Americas, became central to cooking in India, Thailand and Korea. Which paradox does this best illustrate?

Question 2 of 5

What is the difference between acculturation and assimilation?

Question 3 of 5

Día de Muertos joins Indigenous ways of honouring ancestors with the Catholic All Souls' Day. Which term fits?

Question 4 of 5

Many South Africans value lobola as a mark of respect, while others in the same communities argue it has become a financial burden. What does this show?

Question 5 of 5

Hobsbawm and Ranger (1983) showed that some "ancient" customs, such as the familiar Highland kilt, are fairly recent. What is the best conclusion?

← Previous topicNext topic →