Anthropology › Section M · Religion and culture › Topic M.5

Magic and other religious practices

Religious life is not only worship in a church, temple or mosque. People use magic to influence uncertain events, explain misfortune through witchcraft, build whole communities around their faith and treat the nation itself with reverence. Anthropologists study each of these as a serious, coherent part of human experience.

What is magic?

In anthropology, magic refers to practices intended to influence events through supernatural means, usually by carrying out the right technique: a spell, a charm, a ritual act. Older writers drew a sharp line between magic, which tries to compel results, and religion, which petitions gods. Most anthropologists now treat that line as blurry, because prayer, blessings and protective objects appear in every tradition. Calling something magic is also a matter of perspective: people seldom use the word for their own practices. The task is to understand what such practices mean and do.

Frazer's sympathetic magic

James Frazer, in The Golden Bough (first published in 1890), compiled reports of magic from travellers and missionaries; he did no fieldwork himself. He proposed two principles of what he called sympathetic magic. The law of similarity holds that like produces like, so acting on an image or imitation affects what it represents: harming a doll to harm a person. The law of contagion holds that things once in contact remain connected, so hair, nail clippings or clothing can be used to affect their owner. Frazer also proposed an evolutionary sequence from magic to religion to science, which anthropologists have rejected as a ranking of peoples.

Malinowski: magic and uncertainty

Bronisław Malinowski, writing on his Trobriand fieldwork in an essay of 1925, Magic, Science and Religion, noticed that fishers in the calm inner lagoon, where poisoning fish was safe and reliable, used no magic, while those sailing to the open sea, facing danger and unpredictable catches, used a great deal. He concluded that magic is used where knowledge and skill cannot guarantee success, giving confidence in the face of anxiety. His garden magic appears in Performativity and ritual speech. George Gmelch, a former professional player, found the same pattern in baseball in 1971: pitchers and hitters, whose success is uncertain, kept elaborate rituals, while fielders, who succeed almost every time, rarely did.

Witchcraft and sorcery

E. E. Evans-Pritchard's Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande (1937), based on fieldwork in what is now South Sudan in the late 1920s, set out a distinction many anthropologists still use, though it does not fit every society. Among the Azande, witchcraft, mangu, was an inherited substance in a person's body that could cause harm without the witch performing any rite or even knowing it. Sorcery was deliberate harm through medicines and spells, which anyone could learn. The Azande treated both as real causes of misfortune. Evans-Pritchard argued that these beliefs formed a logical, coherent system for explaining events, not a sign of muddled thinking.

Worked example: the collapsing granary

Evans-Pritchard described a granary that collapsed and injured people resting in its shade. Analyse the Azande explanation. 1. The Azande knew that termites had eaten the supporting posts: they did not deny natural causes. 2. They knew people sat under granaries on hot afternoons. 3. Their question was different: why did these posts fall at that moment, on these particular people? 4. Witchcraft answered the why: it brought the two chains of events together. 5. Comparison: science explains how something happens, while witchcraft, like many religious explanations, addresses why it happened to a particular person. 6. Check: an outsider who asks why me after an accident is asking the Azande question.

Oracles and accusations

To identify a witch, the Azande consulted oracles. The most important was the poison oracle, benge: a specialist fed poison to a chicken and asked a question, and the bird's death or survival gave the answer, often checked by a second test. Evans-Pritchard ran his own household by the oracle and found it as workable as any other way of deciding. Witchcraft accusations can also cause grave harm. In Europe, trials from about 1450 to 1750 led to perhaps 40,000 to 60,000 executions. In 2021 the UN Human Rights Council adopted a resolution against harmful practices linked to witchcraft accusations, which still lead to attacks on older women, children and people with albinism.

Worked example: magic in everyday life

Classify four practices with Frazer's and Malinowski's ideas. 1. A woman keeps her late grandmother's ring and wears it for important interviews: the law of contagion, since the ring was once in contact with her grandmother. 2. Protesters burn an effigy of a politician: the law of similarity, acting on an image. 3. A student uses the same pen for every exam but not for homework: Malinowski's principle, a ritual where the outcome is uncertain and stakes are high. 4. A family prays at a shrine for a relative's recovery: a petition to a sacred power, which Frazer would call religion rather than magic. 5. Check: the line between 3 and 4 is blurred, as most anthropologists argue.

Utopian religious communities

A utopian community is an intentional community whose members try to live out an ideal society, often inspired by religion. Rosabeth Moss Kanter, in Commitment and Community (1972), compared nineteenth-century US communities and found that the lasting ones demanded sacrifice, shared property and strong group rituals that bound members together. Physical separation, economic self-sufficiency and a clear authority structure also helped. The Amish, who follow a church order called the Ordnung and limit technology, live in family farms and businesses within wider society. Hutterites hold all property in common in colonies, mainly on the Canadian prairies. The Bruderhof, founded in Germany in 1920, also share property communally.

The Shakers

The Shakers, named for their ecstatic dancing in worship, formed in England in the mid-1700s. Led by Ann Lee, a small group emigrated to America in 1774 and settled near Albany, New York. Shakers lived celibate lives, held property in common and gave women and men equal authority in leadership, unusual for the time. At their peak in the mid-nineteenth century they numbered several thousand in about twenty villages. Their furniture is famous, and their song Simple Gifts (1848) appears in Aaron Copland's Appalachian Spring (1944). Because they are celibate, they grow only through converts; three members remained at Sabbathday Lake, Maine, in 2025.

Civil religion

Durkheim suggested that in worshipping the sacred, people honour their own society. The sociologist Robert Bellah, in Civil Religion in America (1967), argued that the United States has a civil religion alongside its churches: a set of sacred symbols, beliefs and rituals centred on the nation. Presidential inaugurations invoke God; the Declaration of Independence is treated as a sacred text; places such as Arlington National Cemetery and the Lincoln Memorial are visited with reverence; and Memorial Day, flag ceremonies and the Pledge of Allegiance are its rituals. Nationalism can become a secular religion, uniting diverse people but also excluding those defined as outsiders.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating magic as a primitive stage before religion and science: Frazer's sequence has been rejected. Second, assuming people who use magic ignore natural causes; the Azande knew termites weakened the granary. Third, using witchcraft and sorcery interchangeably in Evans-Pritchard's sense: witchcraft is inherent and may be unconscious, sorcery is deliberate technique. Fourth, thinking magic belongs only to other cultures, when athletes and students use it too. Fifth, dismissing witchcraft beliefs as harmless, when accusations can lead to violence. Sixth, assuming the Shakers died out entirely; a small community survives.

Key takeaways

Magic tries to influence events by supernatural technique; its line with religion is blurred. Frazer (1890) named the laws of similarity and contagion, but his evolutionary sequence is rejected. Malinowski (1925) linked magic to uncertainty, as Gmelch (1971) found in baseball. Evans-Pritchard (1937) distinguished Azande witchcraft from sorcery and showed witchcraft explaining why misfortune strikes particular people, with oracles such as benge; accusations can cause real harm. Utopian communities such as the Amish, Hutterites, Bruderhof and Shakers last through commitment, as Kanter (1972) argued. Bellah (1967) described American civil religion.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Magic

Practices meant to influence events through supernatural technique

Its line with religion is blurred.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Malinowski found that Trobriand fishers used magic for open-sea fishing but not in the lagoon. What did he conclude?

Question 2 of 5

Protesters burn a straw figure made to look like a politician. Which of Frazer's principles does this illustrate?

Question 3 of 5

In Evans-Pritchard's account, how did Azande witchcraft differ from sorcery?

Question 4 of 5

When a granary collapsed on people, what question did Azande witchcraft answer?

Question 5 of 5

Which practice best fits Robert Bellah's idea of American civil religion?

← Previous topicNext topic →