Anthropology › Section G · Economic anthropology › Topic G.3

Gathering and hunting

For almost all of the human past, people lived by gathering wild plants and hunting wild animals. Studying the groups who still do so overturns old assumptions about a hard, hungry life, and raises sharp questions about how much the present can tell us about the deep past.

Why gathering comes first

Gathering-hunting, also called foraging, is the mode of subsistence in which people live mainly on wild resources: fruits, nuts, roots, honey, shellfish, fish and game. Many anthropologists now put gathering first. The Man the Hunter conference, organised by Richard Lee and Irven DeVore in 1966, treated hunting as the activity that made us human. Sally Slocum's essay Woman the Gatherer (1975) replied that in most warm-climate foraging groups, plant foods gathered largely by women supply most of the calories. In the Arctic, hunting and fishing dominate, so the balance depends on environment.

Who forages today?

Only a few peoples now gain much of their food by foraging, and none live in isolation. Examples include the Ju/'hoansi of Botswana and Namibia, the Hadza of Tanzania, BaYaka groups in the Congo Basin and the Batek of Malaysia. Names matter: Ju/'hoansi, roughly real people, is the people's own name, whereas older writing used outsider labels such as !Kung or Bushmen. Most foragers today also farm part-time, work for wages, receive government support or sell crafts.

Mobility and flexible bands

Most foragers in sparse environments are mobile. They live in bands of a few dozen people that move between waterholes, groves and hunting areas through the seasons. Membership is flexible: groups split when food is scarce or tempers flare, and join up in larger camps when a seasonal food is abundant. This pattern, called fission and fusion, spreads people across the land to match resources. Ties of marriage, friendship and gift exchange between bands give people the right to use neighbours' territory in a bad year, so the social network works as a form of insurance.

Sharing and levelling

Mobile foragers are usually strongly egalitarian. Food, especially meat, is shared widely, and stinginess is treated as a serious fault. Possessions are few, because everything must be carried. Groups also use levelling mechanisms that stop anyone from claiming superiority. Among the Ju/'hoansi, Richard Lee reported in the 1960s, meat belongs to the owner of the arrow that killed the animal, and because arrows are lent and borrowed, credit for a kill is spread around. A successful hunter is expected to play down his catch, and others tease him if he boasts. Decisions are made by discussion until people agree, and no one holds the right to give orders.

Worked example: Eating Christmas in the Kalahari

In a short essay published in 1969, Richard Lee described buying the largest ox he could find as a Christmas feast for the Ju/'hoansi he had studied. People kept telling him it was thin and bony. Analyse the episode. 1. Observation: the ox was in fact fat, and everyone ate well. 2. Puzzle: why insult a generous gift? 3. Explanation: Lee's hosts explained that when a young man brings in a large kill and begins to think of himself as a chief, they belittle his meat to cool his heart and keep him gentle. 4. Interpretation: the joking was a levelling mechanism, applied to the anthropologist as to anyone. 5. Lesson: behaviour that seems rude from outside makes sense once its local purpose is understood.

Not all foragers are alike

These features are tendencies, not rules. Where resources are rich and predictable, foragers can settle. On the Northwest Coast of North America, peoples such as the Kwakwaka'wakw and Tlingit relied on huge salmon runs, preserved and stored food, lived in permanent plank-house villages and had ranked societies with nobles, commoners and, before colonial rule, enslaved captives. Anthropologists sometimes call such groups complex hunter-gatherers. Diet varies too: closer to the equator plant foods are available all year, while in colder regions people depend more on hunting and fishing.

Did women hunt?

Agta women in the Philippines have been documented hunting with knives, bows and dogs, and in 2020 archaeologists reported a burial in the Peruvian Andes, about 9,000 years old, of a woman buried with a hunting toolkit. A 2023 study by Abigail Anderson, Cara Wall-Scheffler and colleagues found records of women hunting in 50 of 63 foraging societies with data, about 79%. In 2024 Vivek Venkataraman and colleagues criticised its sampling and coding, noting that a single recorded instance was enough to count a society. A fair reading of both is that women's hunting is real and varied, while men still do most big-game hunting in most documented groups.

The original affluent society

Farming and industrial societies long assumed foragers lived near starvation. Richard Lee's research among the Ju/'hoansi in the 1960s suggested otherwise: adults spent about two to three days a week getting food, and the diet was varied and adequate. Marshall Sahlins, in a paper presented in 1966 and published in Stone Age Economics (1972), called foragers the original affluent society: affluent not because they had much, but because they wanted little and met those wants easily. Later researchers noted that processing food, making tools and housework add many hours, and that hardship varies between years and groups. The idea is a challenge to assumptions, not a final verdict.

Worked example: how many hours is work?

Suppose a time budget for one foraging camp records adults spending, on average, 20 hours a week getting food, 8 hours making and repairing tools, and 14 hours on housework such as cracking nuts, fetching water and gathering firewood. Interpret these figures. 1. Narrow definition: counting only food-getting gives 20 hours a week. 2. Broad definition: 20 + 8 + 14 = 42 hours a week. 3. Ratio: the broad figure is 42 divided by 20, or 2.1 times the narrow one. 4. Conclusion: whether foragers seem leisured depends heavily on what is counted as work, so always check the definition behind a time budget.

Living people, not living fossils

Today's foragers are not a window onto the Stone Age. In Land Filled with Flies (1989), Edwin Wilmsen argued that Kalahari peoples had traded with herders and farmers for centuries, so regional history shaped their way of life; Lee and others replied that he overstated those links. Either way, foragers are modern people with their own histories, and many have lost land to farmers, ranchers, mines and parks. In Botswana, San residents were removed from the Central Kalahari Game Reserve in waves in 1997, 2002 and 2005, and in 2006 the High Court ruled that their removal had been unlawful.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming hunting always supplied most food; in many warm-climate groups gathered plant foods did. Second, treating all foragers as small, nomadic and equal: Northwest Coast peoples were settled and ranked. Third, swinging to the opposite claim that there is no gendered division of labour; women's hunting is real, but men still do most big-game hunting in most recorded groups. Fourth, reading the original affluent society as proof that foraging is always easy. Fifth, treating present-day foragers as living fossils. Sixth, using outsider names such as Bushmen where a people's own name is known.

Key takeaways

Gathering-hunting relies on wild resources, and in many warm-climate groups gathering supplies most calories, as Slocum's Woman the Gatherer (1975) stressed. Mobile foragers live in flexible bands, share widely, use levelling mechanisms and decide by consensus, though settled, ranked foragers existed on the Northwest Coast. Women hunt in many foraging societies, but gendered divisions of labour remain common. Lee's Ju/'hoansi research and Sahlins's original affluent society challenged the idea of a hungry life, though counting all work changes the picture. Today's foragers are modern peoples facing land loss, not windows onto the Stone Age.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Gathering-hunting

Living mainly on wild plants and animals

Also called foraging.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why do many anthropologists now prefer the term gathering-hunting to hunting and gathering?

Question 2 of 5

In Richard Lee's Eating Christmas in the Kalahari, why did the Ju/'hoansi call his large, fat ox thin and bony?

Question 3 of 5

What does the Northwest Coast case show about gatherer-hunters?

Question 4 of 5

Which conclusion fairly reflects both the 2023 Anderson study and the 2024 Venkataraman critique?

Question 5 of 5

A time budget shows foragers spend 20 hours a week getting food, 8 making tools and 14 on housework. What is the total under the broad definition of work?

← Previous topicNext topic →