Anthropology › Section G · Economic anthropology › Topic G.4
Pastoralism
On dry plains, high mountains and Arctic tundra, where crops struggle, people have long made a living by moving herds of animals to grass and water. Pastoralism is a sophisticated way of turning marginal land into food, and its practitioners face some of the strongest pressures of the modern world.
From hunting to herding
Pastoralism is the mode of subsistence based on the care and use of herds of domesticated animals. It rests on animal domestication, which began in Southwest Asia with sheep, goats and cattle roughly 10,000 to 11,000 years ago and happened later and separately elsewhere, with llamas and alpacas in the Andes, for instance. Domestication means controlling animals' breeding over many generations, so herds changed in size, temperament and productivity. Societies that live mainly by herding appear in the archaeological record later than the first domestic animals, and their timing varies by region. Herding and farming have usually developed side by side, often in close trade with each other.
Living from live animals
A hunter gets meat once from an animal; a herder can draw on a living animal for years. The archaeologist Andrew Sherratt (1981) described a secondary products revolution, in which people learned to use milk, wool, hair, traction and transport as well as meat and hides. Dung can be fuel or building plaster, and some East African herders, such as the Maasai, have traditionally drunk blood drawn from a living cow. These products let a herd turn grass, which people cannot digest, into food and materials they can use. That is why pastoralism thrives on drylands, steppes, mountains and tundra, where farming is risky or impossible.
Nomadism and transhumance
Herding requires movement, but the patterns differ. In pastoral nomadism, whole households move with their animals, sometimes many times a year, following pasture and water. In transhumance, herds move seasonally between fixed pastures, such as summer mountain grazing and winter lowland grazing, while some people stay in a settled base. Fredrik Barth's study of the Basseri nomads of southern Iran, published in 1961, described whole households making a long annual migration between winter pastures in the lowlands and summer pastures in the Zagros Mountains, along a route the group held rights to use. Sámi reindeer herders in northern Norway, Sweden, Finland and Russia move herds between winter forests and summer mountain or coastal grazing.
Herds as wealth
Unlike most mobile foragers, pastoralists hold important private property: the animals. A family's standing is often measured by its herd, animals pass from parents to children, and gifts of animals seal marriages, as in the cattle bridewealth that E. E. Evans-Pritchard described among the Nuer. This creates more inequality than among mobile foragers. Yet herd wealth is fragile. Drought, disease, raids or a hard winter can wipe out a rich family's animals in one season, while a poor family can rebuild through births and loans. Wealth among herders therefore rises and falls more quickly than wealth in land, and many pastoral values stress hospitality, courage and self-reliance.
Sharing risk
Pastoralists build social institutions to survive disasters. Herders commonly spread animals among relatives and friends in different areas, so that a local drought or disease outbreak cannot destroy everything. Among the Maasai of Kenya and Tanzania, the anthropologist Lee Cronk and colleagues have studied osotua, a lifelong relationship in which partners give livestock or other help when the other is in genuine need, without keeping strict accounts. Such need-based giving resembles the generalised reciprocity discussed in Exchange, value, and consumption. Work is divided by age and gender: in many groups boys and young men herd and guard animals, while women milk, process milk and manage its distribution.
Worked example: a herd as insurance
A family keeps 60 goats. A drought kills 40% of the animals grazing near home. Compare two strategies, assuming a recovering herd grows by 15% a year. 1. All at home: 60 × 0.6 = 36 goats survive. 2. Recovery time: 36 × 1.15 = 41.4 after one year, 47.6 after two, 54.8 after three and 63.0 after four, so about four years to pass 60 again. 3. Spreading the herd: the family had loaned 20 goats to a partner in an area the drought missed. At home 40 × 0.4 = 16 die, leaving 24 + 20 = 44 goats. 4. Conclusion: spreading animals through social ties cut losses from 24 goats to 16, which shows why loans and stock friendships are rational strategies.
The tragedy of the commons?
In 1968 the ecologist Garrett Hardin argued that land held in common will be overgrazed, because each herder gains from adding animals while the cost of damage is shared. His tragedy of the commons was used to justify fencing, privatising or nationalising pastoral land. Anthropologists and the political economist Elinor Ostrom (1990) replied that Hardin described open access, where no rules apply. Many herding communities manage common pastures through rules about who may graze where and when, enforced by elders or councils. Range ecologists have also found that in many drylands vegetation is driven more by rainfall than by grazing, so mobility is often the best way to use it sustainably.
Worked example: judging a policy claim
A government plans to divide a shared rangeland into fenced private plots, arguing that herders are destroying it. Analyse the claim. 1. Identify the theory: the argument assumes Hardin's tragedy of the commons. 2. Check the property regime: is the land open to anyone, or governed by local rules on seasonal grazing? Fieldwork can answer this. 3. Check the ecology: if rainfall varies greatly, fenced plots may trap herds on poor pasture in a dry year, whereas mobility lets them follow the rain. 4. Ask who benefits: titling can favour wealthy herders or outside investors who can afford fences and wells. 5. Conclusion: the policy may cause the degradation it aims to prevent, unless it builds on existing common-property rules.
Pastoralists today
Estimates of how many people depend on herding vary widely, from about 200 million to more than 500 million, because definitions differ. The United Nations named 2026 the International Year of Rangelands and Pastoralists. The pressures are serious. States have long tried to settle mobile herders, to tax, school and govern them more easily. Rangelands are taken for farms, mines, tourism and conservation parks, sometimes without consent. Climate change makes rainfall less predictable. Many pastoralists respond by combining herding with farming, wage work and trade, using mobile phones to track markets and pasture. Change does not mean disappearance: herding adapts, as it always has.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, equating pastoralism with any keeping of animals: farmers keep animals too, but pastoralists depend mainly on herds. Second, confusing nomadism, where whole households move, with transhumance, where herds move between fixed seasonal pastures. Third, assuming herding always degrades land; the tragedy of the commons describes open access, not managed commons. Fourth, treating pastoral wealth as secure; herds can be lost in a single season. Fifth, assuming pastoralists live apart from farmers; most trade with them or farm themselves. Sixth, treating mobile herders as a vanishing relic rather than people adapting to new conditions.
Key takeaways
Pastoralism relies on domesticated herds, which first appeared in Southwest Asia about 10,000 to 11,000 years ago. Secondary products such as milk, wool and traction let herds turn grass on marginal land into human resources. Nomads move whole households, as in Barth's Basseri study; transhumant herders move animals between fixed seasonal pastures. Herds are property and wealth but are easily lost, so herders spread risk through loans and need-based ties such as Maasai osotua. Hardin's tragedy of the commons is challenged by Ostrom's work on managed commons. Herders today face land loss, settlement policies and climate change.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Making a living mainly from herds of domesticated animals
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What distinguishes transhumance from pastoral nomadism?
Question 2 of 5
Why does pastoralism thrive on drylands, steppes and tundra?
Question 3 of 5
A family with 60 goats loses 40% of the animals near home in a drought. How many survive if all 60 were at home?
Question 4 of 5
How did Elinor Ostrom and many anthropologists respond to Hardin's tragedy of the commons?
Question 5 of 5
Maasai osotua partnerships are best described as:
