Anthropology › Section G · Economic anthropology › Topic G.2
Modes of subsistence
Every human group has to turn its surroundings into food, shelter, clothing and medicine. Anthropologists call the way it does so a mode of subsistence, and comparing modes helps explain why societies differ in mobility, property, work and values.
Making a living from the environment
A mode of subsistence is the way a group interacts with its environment to meet its basic needs. The term covers more than food. It includes the materials people take from land and water, the techniques and tools they use to process them, and the knowledge that makes those techniques work. Because a way of making a living takes up so much of daily life, it shapes much else: where people live, how often they move, who works with whom, what counts as property and what people admire. Studying modes of subsistence is therefore a holistic exercise, linking ecology, economy and culture.
What every mode must organise
Each mode of subsistence answers the same set of practical questions. First, resources and technology: which plants, animals, minerals or fuels are used, and with what tools. Second, labour: how work is divided by gender, age, skill or class, and how groups such as households or work parties are formed. Third, circulation: how goods move within and beyond the group, through sharing, gifts, tribute or markets. Fourth, values: which qualities, such as generosity, hard work or thrift, a society praises because they help its way of life succeed. Fifth, knowledge: detailed understanding of seasons, soils, animals and weather, often passed on orally.
Four main modes
This course follows a common classification into four modes. Gathering-hunting relies on wild plants and animals collected or hunted where they occur. Pastoralism depends on herds of domesticated animals moved to fresh pasture and water. Plant cultivation grows domesticated crops, either extensively, as horticulture with hand tools and fallow periods, or intensively, as agriculture with ploughs, irrigation and repeated use of the same fields. Industrialism uses machines, fossil fuels and wage labour to mass-produce goods, and its later, service-based form is often called postindustrialism. The next four topics, Gathering and hunting, Pastoralism, Horticulture and agriculture, and Industrialism and postmodernity, examine each in turn.
Other ways to classify
Classifications are tools, not facts of nature, and scholars draw the lines differently. The anthropologist Yehudi Cohen (1974) described five adaptive strategies, counting horticulture and agriculture separately, and many textbooks follow him. Sociologists often use Gerhard Lenski's types of societies, discussed in the Sociology course, which sort societies by subsistence technology. Each scheme highlights something useful: Cohen's stresses the difference between hoe and plough, while the four-mode scheme groups all crop growing together. Whatever the scheme, a label describes a predominant strategy, not everything a group does, and real cases often sit between categories.
Mixing modes
Most societies rely chiefly on one strategy while borrowing practices from others. In E. E. Evans-Pritchard's classic study of the Nuer of South Sudan, based on fieldwork in about the 1930s, cattle were at the centre of life, yet Nuer households also grew millet and fished, moving between villages on higher ground in the wet season and camps near water in the dry season. Many farmers keep animals; many herders plant a crop along their routes; many foragers trade with farming neighbours. Today, city dwellers in industrial economies may grow vegetables in allotments. Mixing spreads risk: if one source of food fails, another may hold.
Intensification
Modes also differ in intensity: how much labour, energy and capital is put into each unit of land. Extensive strategies use large areas lightly; intensive strategies use smaller areas heavily, through ploughing, irrigation, terracing, fertiliser or machinery. More intensive methods usually feed more people per hectare, but they demand more work or more inputs. Thomas Malthus (1798) had argued that population growth would outrun food supply. The economist Ester Boserup (1965) turned the argument around: in her view, rising population density pushes farmers to intensify, so population pressure can drive agricultural change rather than simply being limited by it. Archaeologists and anthropologists still test both ideas against particular cases.
Worked example: reading field notes
Identify the predominant mode in each case and any supplementary ones. 1. Group A plants maize and beans in forest clearings, farms each plot for a few years and then lets it regrow, and hunts in the dry season. Clues: domesticated crops, hand tools, fallow. Predominant: horticulture; supplementary: hunting. 2. Group B moves sheep and goats between summer mountain pastures and winter valleys, and sells wool and cheese for grain. Clues: herds, seasonal movement, trade for crops. Predominant: pastoralism. 3. Group C fishes, gathers shellfish and collects wild plants, living year-round in one village. Clues: no domesticated food sources. Predominant: gathering-hunting, showing that foragers need not be nomadic where resources are rich.
Not a ladder
Nineteenth-century writers such as Lewis Henry Morgan, in Ancient Society (1877), ranked peoples on a scale from what they called savagery through barbarism to civilisation. Anthropologists now reject such ranking, and the terms survive only as historical usage. Modes of subsistence have existed side by side for more than 10,000 years, and groups have moved between them in both directions. The Cheyenne, for example, lived in farming villages in what are now Minnesota and North Dakota before moving onto the Great Plains in the late eighteenth century, where horses made bison hunting their main way of life. Groups change strategies in response to climate, population, trade, new technologies and pressure from states, not because history follows a fixed sequence.
Worked example: farming in an industrial world
World Bank figures based on modelled International Labour Organization estimates put agriculture's share of employment in 2025 at about 26% worldwide but only about 1.5% in the United States. Interpret this. 1. Convert to counts: of every 1,000 workers, about 260 worldwide work in agriculture, against about 15 in the United States. 2. Ratio: 26 divided by 1.5 is roughly 17, so the world share is about 17 times the US share. 3. Explanation: industrial farming in the United States uses machinery, fossil fuels and chemical inputs, so few workers feed many people. 4. Conclusion: industrialism has not replaced farming worldwide; it has transformed where and how farm work is done, and about one worker in four still farms.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating a mode of subsistence as only a food technique: it also organises labour, exchange, values and knowledge. Second, assuming that a society practises one mode only; most combine a predominant mode with others. Third, treating the modes as stages on a ladder of progress, or using historical labels such as savage as if they were neutral. Fourth, confusing horticulture with agriculture: hand tools and fallowing versus ploughs, irrigation and continuous use. Fifth, assuming that all foragers are nomadic or that all farmers are settled. Sixth, thinking industrial economies have no farmers; they have few, using many inputs.
Key takeaways
A mode of subsistence is a way of meeting basic needs from the environment, and it organises resources and technology, labour, circulation, values and knowledge. This course uses four modes: gathering-hunting, pastoralism, plant cultivation (horticulture and agriculture) and industrialism or postindustrialism; Cohen counted five. Most societies mix modes around a predominant one. Modes differ in intensity, and Boserup argued that population pressure drives intensification. The modes are not a ladder of progress. In 2025 about 26% of the world's workers, but about 1.5% of US workers, were in agriculture.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The way a group interacts with its environment to meet basic needs
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these lists the things every mode of subsistence must organise, as taught in this topic?
Question 2 of 5
A group grows yams in forest clearings with digging sticks, lets each plot regrow after a few years, and keeps a few pigs. What is its predominant mode of subsistence?
Question 3 of 5
How did Ester Boserup's argument differ from that of Thomas Malthus?
Question 4 of 5
The Cheyenne farmed before moving onto the Great Plains, where they became bison hunters on horseback. What does this case show?
Question 5 of 5
In 2025 about 26% of workers worldwide, but about 1.5% of US workers, were in agriculture. What is the best interpretation?
