Anthropology › Section G · Economic anthropology › Topic G.1

Two ways to study economies

Economists and anthropologists both study how people make a living, but they ask different questions and trust different evidence. Knowing the difference, and the famous debate it produced, is the first step in economic anthropology.

What is an economy?

Anthropologists define an economy as the way a society produces, moves and uses goods, services and information. It is never only technical. It rests on ideas about what is valuable, who owes what to whom, and which activities count as work. It also involves power, because some groups usually gain control over the land, labour or leisure of others. Economic anthropology studies these systems across cultures, past and present, using the same commitments that guide the rest of the discipline.

The economist's lens: universal rules

Mainstream economics, the subject of Honu Learning's Microeconomics and Macroeconomics courses, looks for principles that hold anywhere. It tends to be universalist: it assumes that markets, supply and demand work in much the same way across societies. Its standard actor is a rational individual who weighs costs and benefits to get the most from scarce resources. Economists usually test their models with statistics from large data sets, and many of their questions concern policy, such as how to raise growth or reduce unemployment. The approach is powerful for comparing prices, incomes and trade, and anthropologists use its findings. Its weakness, critics say, is that history, context and meaning often drop out of the analysis.

The anthropologist's lens: people in context

Economic anthropology takes a human-centred approach. Its researchers do long-term fieldwork, asking how people in one place earn their livelihoods, what those activities mean to them, and how they change. Four commitments shape the work. Diversity: economies from the Arctic to the Amazon are compared, not ranked. Holism: making a living is linked to kinship, religion, gender and politics. Environment: subsistence is studied as a relationship with land, water and climate. Cultural relativism: practices are first understood in their own terms, which, as Cross-cultural comparison and cultural relativism explains, is a research method, not a refusal ever to judge. Anthropologists also ask who gains and who loses, so power stays in view.

Formalists and substantivists

In the 1950s and 1960s these differences became a famous debate. Formalists, such as Raymond Firth and later Harold Schneider, argued that the tools of economics apply everywhere: people in every society choose how to use scarce means, so models of maximising can explain a Polynesian fishing village as well as a stock exchange. Substantivists, led by the economic historian Karl Polanyi and the anthropologist George Dalton, replied that the word economic has two meanings, a distinction Polanyi set out in a 1957 essay. Its formal meaning is logical choice under scarcity. Its substantive meaning is simply how people get their living from nature and from one another. Only the second, they argued, is truly universal.

Polanyi and the embedded economy

In The Great Transformation (1944), Polanyi argued that for most of history the economy was embedded in social relationships: land, labour and goods moved through kinship, religion and politics rather than through markets alone. A society in which a self-regulating market treats land and labour as commodities was, he said, a recent and unusual creation of nineteenth-century Europe. In the same 1957 essay he named three main forms of integration. Reciprocity is exchange between people bound by social ties; redistribution moves goods to a centre and back out; market exchange happens at prices that respond to supply and demand. Most societies mix all three, and the topic Exchange, value, and consumption examines each in depth.

Worked example: one farmer, two explanations

A family in a highland village grows maize on most of its land, although an export crop such as coffee would earn more cash per hectare. Explain the choice both ways. 1. Formalist reading: the family is still maximising, but its goal is security rather than average income. Maize can be eaten if prices crash; coffee cannot. Accepting lower but steadier returns is a rational response to risk. 2. Substantivist reading: maize is tied to obligations to kin, to feasts and to identity, so growing it maintains relationships that cash cannot buy. 3. Compare: the first explains the choice with a universal model, the second with local meanings and social ties. 4. Conclusion: the readings can both be partly right, and only fieldwork reveals which reasons the family itself gives.

Moral economy

The historian E. P. Thompson (1971) used the phrase moral economy for the shared sense of fair prices that led eighteenth-century English crowds to protest when dealers raised the price of grain or bread in hard times. The political scientist James C. Scott, in The Moral Economy of the Peasant (1976), studied rice farmers in Burma and Vietnam and argued that they followed a subsistence ethic: they judged landlords and states less by how much they took than by whether they left families enough to survive a bad year. Moral economy shows that ideas of fairness shape economic behaviour, and that breaking them can provoke resistance.

Worked example: one game in fifteen societies

In the ultimatum game, a proposer receives a sum and offers part of it to a responder. If the responder accepts, both keep their shares; if not, both get nothing. A team of economists and anthropologists led by Joseph Henrich ran the game in 15 small-scale societies and published the results in 2001. Interpret them. 1. Prediction: a purely self-interested responder accepts any positive offer, so a proposer with 100 units should offer about 1. 2. Data: mean offers ranged from about 26% among Matsigenka (also called Machiguenga) farmer-foragers in Peru to about 58% among Lamalera whale hunters in Indonesia, against about 44% in typical studies in industrial societies. 3. Pattern: offers tended to be higher where daily life depended more on cooperation and market exchange. 4. Conclusion: no group matched the narrow prediction, and the variation tracked local economic life.

Beyond the old debate

By the 1980s many anthropologists felt the debate had stalled. Political economy approaches, such as Eric Wolf's Europe and the People Without History (1982), traced how colonialism and global trade drew local economies into wider systems of power. Cultural approaches, such as Stephen Gudeman's, studied how communities model their own economies through local images, such as a household that must be kept going. Many economic anthropologists now also collaborate with economists, as the ultimatum game study shows.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming that economics and economic anthropology study different things: both study how people make a living, but with different methods and assumptions. Second, reading substantivism as a claim that people in small-scale societies are irrational; it claims that their choices are organised by different institutions. Third, assuming that embedded exchange disappears in market societies: family support, gifts and taxes still move goods outside markets. Fourth, confusing cultural relativism with approval of every practice. Fifth, treating one experiment, such as the ultimatum game, as a measure of a people's character rather than of behaviour in one setting.

Key takeaways

An economy is how a society produces, moves and uses goods, services and information, shaped by values and power. Economics tends to be universalist and market-centred; economic anthropology is human-centred and fieldwork-based. Formalists applied maximising models everywhere; substantivists, following Polanyi, held that only the substantive economy, getting a living, is universal, and that economies are embedded in social life. Polanyi's three forms of integration are reciprocity, redistribution and market exchange. Moral economy and the ultimatum game show that fairness and local institutions shape economic behaviour.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Economy

How a society produces, moves and uses goods, services and information

Shaped by ideas of value and by power.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which statement best summarises the substantivist position in economic anthropology?

Question 2 of 5

What did Karl Polanyi mean by an embedded economy?

Question 3 of 5

In the 15-society ultimatum game study, mean offers ranged from about 26% to about 58%. What did this variation suggest?

Question 4 of 5

According to James C. Scott's idea of a subsistence ethic, peasants judge a landlord mainly by:

Question 5 of 5

A family grows maize instead of a higher-earning cash crop because maize can still be eaten if prices crash. Which reading of the choice is this?

← Previous topicNext topic →