Anthropology › Section M · Religion and culture › Topic M.3

Myth and religious doctrine

In everyday speech a myth is a falsehood; in anthropology it is a sacred story that tells a people who they are. This topic looks at how myths are told, interpreted and used, and how religions that rely on written texts and formal doctrine still depend on the spoken word.

What anthropologists mean by myth

Popular usage treats myth as a mistaken belief, as in the myth that we use only 10% of our brains. Anthropologists use the word differently. A myth is a sacred, authoritative story, usually set in a time of origins outside ordinary history, that explains how the world, people and customs came to be and teaches what matters. Calling a story a myth says nothing about whether it is true; it describes the story's role. Common kinds include creation stories, flood stories, stories of culture heroes who bring fire, farming or law, and stories of tricksters such as Raven, Coyote or Anansi, whose mischief both breaks and reveals the rules.

Earth-diver stories

Some story patterns recur over vast areas. In earth-diver stories, told across much of North America and northern Eurasia, the world begins as water, and an animal dives to the bottom to bring up a little mud from which land is made. The folklorist Alan Dundes analysed the pattern in 1962. Among the Haudenosaunee, in many versions, Sky Woman falls from the Sky World towards a world of water. Birds slow her fall, and after other animals fail, Muskrat brings up a little earth, which is spread on the back of Turtle and grows into the land; this is why many Indigenous people call North America Turtle Island.

Myth as a charter

Bronisław Malinowski, in Myth in Primitive Psychology (1926), argued from his fieldwork in the Trobriand Islands that myths are not idle explanations but charters: they justify present institutions by tracing them to sacred origins. Trobriand subclans tell how their first ancestors emerged from a particular hole in the ground. The story supports the subclan's claim to the surrounding land and to its rank among other groups. When a dispute arises, people retell or challenge the myth, so myth is used in real arguments about land and status. The functionalist approach thus asks what a myth does for the people who tell it.

Structuralism and binary oppositions

Claude Lévi-Strauss, in The Structural Study of Myth (1955) and the four volumes of Mythologiques (1964 to 1971), looked beneath stories for their structure. He argued that the human mind organises experience through binary oppositions, such as nature and culture, raw and cooked, or life and death, and that myths work through contradictions people cannot resolve in daily life. A myth breaks down into mythemes, its smallest meaningful units of action, and its meaning lies in how these are arranged. Mediating figures often bridge the opposed terms. Lévi-Strauss noted that scavengers such as Raven and Coyote, which eat meat they did not kill, appear as tricksters between life and death.

Worked example: a structural reading

Analyse a short teaching story written for this topic. Heron, who lives by water, and Fox, who lives on land, both shiver in winter. Fox finds fire but cannot cross the river; Heron carries an ember across, and since then river people and hill people trade fish for meat. 1. Oppositions: water and land, cold and warm, fish and meat. 2. Mythemes: both lack warmth; one finds fire; the other crosses; exchange begins. 3. Mediator: Heron belongs to water but walks on land, so it can bridge the two. 4. Message: neither group can live well alone, so exchange is necessary. 5. Check: every step names an element in the story.

Critiques and other readings

Structuralism has been criticised as hard to test: a skilled analyst can find oppositions in almost any story, and two analysts may find different ones. It also strips away the teller, the audience and the occasion. Franz Boas had earlier stressed history instead, tracing how story elements spread between neighbouring peoples. Later scholars of performance, introduced in Performativity and ritual speech, studied how a myth's meaning changes with who tells it, how and to whom. Many anthropologists now combine approaches: asking what a myth does, as Malinowski did, how it is structured, and what its tellers say it means.

Oral traditions

Many religions are carried mainly by oral tradition: stories, songs and ceremonies passed between generations without written texts. Oral traditions are not careless; tellers are often trained, and some knowledge is restricted by age, gender or initiation. In Daughters of the Dreaming (1983), Diane Bell described Warlpiri women's yawulyu ceremonies in central Australia, in which songs, dances and body designs re-enact the travels of ancestral beings across Country. The Warlpiri word for the Dreaming is Jukurrpa; the older English term Dreamtime is avoided by many people because it suggests a dream or a time long finished, when the Dreaming is understood as ongoing.

Doctrine and written tradition

Doctrine is the formal, authorised teaching of a religious institution, usually fixed in writing and guarded by specialists. Creeds state it concisely: the Nicene Creed was agreed at church councils in 325 and 381 CE, and many Christians still recite it. In the twelfth century the Jewish scholar Maimonides summarised Thirteen Principles of faith, and the Muslim declaration of faith, the shahada, affirms one God and Muhammad as his messenger. Scholars sometimes contrast traditions stressing orthodoxy, correct belief, with those stressing orthopraxy, correct practice. Jack Goody argued in 1977 that writing fixes a text, making it easier to compare versions and to spot contradictions.

Scripture is also spoken

Written traditions remain deeply oral. The word Qur'an means recitation, and many Muslims memorise the whole text; a person who does so is called a hafiz. In synagogues the Torah is chanted aloud in a weekly cycle of readings. The Vedas of Hinduism were passed down orally with great precision for many centuries before they were written. The Qur'an uses the phrase People of the Book, ahl al-kitab, chiefly for Jews and Christians, as communities that received earlier scriptures. In all these traditions the written text is performed: heard, sung, memorised and explained, not only read in silence.

Worked example: myth, doctrine or both?

Classify four items. 1. A Haudenosaunee elder tells the Sky Woman story, adjusting details for a children's audience: myth in an oral tradition, flexible in wording, authoritative in meaning. 2. A congregation recites the Nicene Creed in set words: doctrine, fixed by councils and repeated exactly. 3. A hafiz recites a chapter of the Qur'an from memory: written scripture transmitted and performed orally. 4. Warlpiri women perform yawulyu for a Dreaming site: myth enacted as ritual, tied to Country. 5. Check: the line between oral and written runs through traditions, not neatly between them, so classify the item, not the whole religion.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, using myth to mean a false story; in anthropology it describes a story's sacred role. Second, assuming oral traditions are vague or unreliable; many are carefully trained and protected. Third, treating structuralism as the only reading, when it ignores teller and context. Fourth, thinking written religions have no oral life; their texts are recited, chanted and memorised. Fifth, saying the Qur'an's phrase People of the Book refers mainly to Muslims; it refers to Jews and Christians. Sixth, using Dreamtime as if it named a finished past, when the Dreaming is understood as continuing.

Key takeaways

A myth is a sacred, authoritative story of origins; the label says nothing about truth. Earth-diver stories, such as the Haudenosaunee Sky Woman account, recur widely. Malinowski (1926) saw myth as a charter for institutions. Lévi-Strauss (1955; 1964 to 1971) found binary oppositions, mythemes and mediators, though critics say structuralism is hard to test. Oral traditions, such as Warlpiri yawulyu (Bell, 1983), carry knowledge with care. Doctrine is formal teaching, fixed in creeds and texts; Goody (1977) linked writing to fixed texts. Scriptures such as the Qur'an, Torah and Vedas remain recited and performed.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Myth

A sacred, authoritative story, usually of origins

Says nothing about truth or falsehood.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

An anthropologist calls the Haudenosaunee Sky Woman account a myth. What does this mean?

Question 2 of 5

Trobriand subclans tell of ancestors emerging from a particular hole, supporting claims to nearby land. Which idea does this illustrate?

Question 3 of 5

In the Heron and Fox teaching story, why does Heron count as a mediator in a structural reading?

Question 4 of 5

Which is a common criticism of Lévi-Strauss's structural analysis of myth?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about written religious traditions matches the reading?

← Previous topicNext topic →