Anthropology › Section M · Religion and culture › Topic M.4
Rituals of transition and conformity
Rituals turn beliefs into action. Some bind a congregation together every week, some carry a person from one stage of life to the next, and some deal with illness and misfortune. Studying them shows how communities make people, mark change and keep order, sometimes by briefly turning order upside down.
What makes an act a ritual
A ritual, or rite, is a formal, patterned sequence of acts and words, repeated according to rules that participants did not invent themselves. It is usually performed at set times or in set places, carries symbolic meaning and is social, learned and shared, even when performed alone. Rituals communicate: by taking part, people publicly show that they accept a group's order, which is one reason ritual supports conformity. Anthropologists sort religious rituals into several broad kinds. Rites of intensification strengthen a group, rites of passage move people between social statuses, and rites of affliction respond to illness or misfortune. Secular rituals, such as graduations, follow similar patterns.
Rites of intensification
Rites of intensification renew the bonds of a community and its relationship with the sacred. Many are calendrical, held daily, weekly or yearly, so their familiar structure lets everyone take part. Weekly worship in churches, synagogues and temples is the commonest example. Muslim salat, prayer performed five times a day facing the Ka'ba in Mecca, links each believer to a worldwide community making the same movements towards the same centre. Other rites of intensification answer a shared crisis, such as prayers for rain in a drought or a memorial service after a disaster. Durkheim's idea of collective effervescence, from the Sociology course, describes the unity they can create.
Rites of passage revisited
Cultural groups and aggregates introduced Arnold van Gennep's three stages (1909): separation, transition and incorporation. Van Gennep also called them preliminal, liminal and postliminal, from the Latin limen, a threshold. The stages often enact a symbolic death and rebirth: the old self is set aside, and a new person returns with new rights and duties. Separation may involve seclusion, special clothing or cutting hair; incorporation may bring a new name, new dress or a feast. Rites of passage mark birth, puberty, marriage and death, but also entry into offices, professions and religious communities. The stages can last minutes, as in a wedding vow, or years.
Liminality and communitas
Victor Turner, drawing on fieldwork with the Ndembu of Zambia in the 1950s, studied the middle stage closely. In The Ritual Process (1969) he described liminal people as betwixt and between: stripped of former status, often dressed alike, expected to be humble and obedient to ritual elders, and sometimes treated as invisible or dangerous. Among Ndembu boys in the Mukanda circumcision rite, the initiates lived apart in a lodge in the bush. People passing through liminality together often feel communitas, an intense sense of equality and fellowship that contrasts with ordinary social structure. Turner saw communitas also in pilgrimage, monastic life and some social movements.
Worked example: the Kinaaldá
Diné (Navajo) families hold the Kinaaldá, a four-day ceremony, soon after a girl's first menstruation, recalling Changing Woman, who had the first Kinaaldá. Map it onto van Gennep's stages. 1. Separation: she is dressed in special clothing and jewellery, and a respected woman moulds her body, shaping her into a strong woman. 2. Transition: for four days she grinds corn, works hard and runs towards the east each morning, with others following; she and her family prepare a large corn cake, the alkaan, baked in the ground. 3. Climax: on the last night, songs are sung until dawn. 4. Incorporation: her hair is washed with yucca suds, and she gives out the cake, which she does not eat herself, as a young woman. 5. Check: each stage changes how others treat her.
Worked example: basic training
Rites of passage are not only religious. Analyse military basic training as one. 1. Separation: recruits leave home, have their hair cut short, hand in personal clothing and receive identical uniforms. 2. Liminality: for weeks they are neither civilians nor soldiers, lose control of their own time and must obey instructors without question. 3. Communitas: shared hardship produces strong bonds among recruits of different backgrounds. 4. Incorporation: a graduation parade before families confers a new status, title and duties. 5. Conformity: the rite teaches discipline and loyalty to the institution, showing how ritual can produce the kind of person a group needs. 6. Check: every feature Turner described appears.
Rites of rebellion
Some rituals temporarily overturn the normal order. Max Gluckman, in Rituals of Rebellion in South-East Africa (1954), described the Incwala, the national kingship ceremony of the Swazi, now held in Eswatini, during which people sang songs expressing hostility towards the king. Gluckman argued that letting tensions out within a ritual frame strengthened the kingship, because the challenge was to the person, not to the system. Other scholars, such as T. O. Beidelman (1966), read the Incwala instead as a rite about the king's cosmic and sacred power. Carnival and Halloween also play with inversion, but whether such licence defuses protest or rehearses it remains debated.
Rites of affliction
Rites of affliction are performed when something has gone wrong: illness, infertility, bad luck or conflict. Unlike calendrical rites, they occur when needed. Turner's The Drums of Affliction (1968) described Ndembu rituals in which misfortune was traced to an offended ancestor and healed by a cult of people who had suffered the same affliction. Divination, seeking hidden knowledge about causes or the future, often comes first. In Yoruba Ifá divination, a priest called a babaláwo casts palm nuts or a divining chain to select one of 256 sacred verse groups, the odu. In many Pentecostal churches, believers lay hands on a sick person and pray for healing.
Pilgrimage
A pilgrimage is a journey to a sacred place, undertaken for devotion, healing, penance or fulfilment of a duty. The Hajj to Mecca is one of the Five Pillars of Islam, required once in a lifetime of every Muslim who is physically and financially able. It takes place in the month of Dhu al-Hijjah, so its date moves through the solar year. Rites include circling the Ka'ba seven times anticlockwise, walking between the hills of Safa and Marwa, standing in prayer at Arafat and the symbolic stoning of pillars at Mina. Men wear simple white garments, ihram, which erase signs of wealth and rank, a strong example of communitas.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating any habit as a ritual: rituals follow received rules and carry shared meaning. Second, assuming rituals are only religious; graduations and basic training follow the same structure. Third, skipping liminality, the stage where much of the transformation happens. Fourth, confusing communitas with ordinary friendship; it is a sense of equality that arises when normal status is stripped away. Fifth, reading rites of rebellion as real revolts; Gluckman argued they can strengthen the order they mock, though this is debated. Sixth, describing Hajj circling as clockwise; pilgrims circle the Ka'ba anticlockwise.
Key takeaways
Rituals are formal, rule-governed, symbolic and social, and taking part signals acceptance of a group's order. Rites of intensification, such as weekly worship and salat, renew bonds. Van Gennep's rites of passage (1909) move people through preliminal, liminal and postliminal stages, often a symbolic death and rebirth. Turner (1969) described liminal people as betwixt and between and identified communitas. The Diné Kinaaldá and military basic training both fit the pattern. Gluckman (1954) saw the Swazi Incwala as a rite of rebellion. Rites of affliction, such as Ndembu healing cults and Ifá divination, answer misfortune. The Hajj shows pilgrimage and communitas.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A formal, patterned, rule-governed sequence of symbolic acts and words
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A town holds a special prayer service during a long drought, and people from every congregation attend. Which kind of ritual is this?
Question 2 of 5
During basic training, recruits from very different backgrounds form unusually strong bonds of equality. What did Victor Turner call this?
Question 3 of 5
In the Diné Kinaaldá, at which stage is the girl's hair washed with yucca suds and the alkaan given out?
Question 4 of 5
What did Max Gluckman argue about rituals of rebellion such as the Swazi Incwala?
Question 5 of 5
Why are male Hajj pilgrims' white ihram garments a good example of communitas?
