Intro to Business › Section B · Ethics and social responsibility › Topic B.1
Understanding business ethics
Every day, people at work face choices that the law alone does not settle: how much to tell a customer, whether to round up an expense claim, who should bear the cost of a cutback. Business ethics gives them ways to recognise these dilemmas and reason through them.
Ethics and ethical issues
Ethics is the body of moral principles people use to decide whether an action is right or wrong. Business ethics applies those standards to decisions at work: how firms treat customers, employees, suppliers, investors and communities. The first skill is recognising an ethical issue, a situation in which someone must choose between actions that may be ethical or unethical. Some cases are clear-cut, such as falsifying a safety test. Others are genuinely hard. Should a struggling small exporter pay the bribes that rivals pay in a foreign market, to save 100 local jobs? Thinking clearly about such cases needs both a way to spot wrongdoing and a way to weigh the options.
Legal is not the same as ethical
The law sets a minimum standard, but ethics often asks more. Some actions are legal yet widely seen as unethical: talking an elderly customer into a costly upgrade he does not need, while stating every fact correctly, or raising the price of an essential medicine many times over simply because a company can. Some actions break a rule yet many people see them as defensible, such as starving disaster victims taking food from abandoned shops. Laws also lag behind new technology and differ between countries. A manager who asks only whether something is legal has answered just one question; the next is whether it is right, fair and honest.
Recognising unethical activities
Researchers at Brigham Young University grouped unethical business conduct into a short list of categories. They include taking things that do not belong to you, from company supplies to padded expense claims; saying things you know are untrue; giving or allowing false impressions, such as a car dealer staying silent about accident damage; buying influence or acting with a conflict of interest, where personal gain could sway official duties; hiding or divulging information, such as concealing a product's side effects or taking trade secrets to a new employer; taking unfair advantage of people who cannot follow complex contracts; abusing power over others; permitting abuse of workers in overseas operations; violating rules; and condoning others' wrongdoing by staying silent.
Worked example: naming the violation
Classify each invented case using the categories. 1. A sales rep adds a family dinner to a client-entertainment claim: taking what is not his. 2. A buyer awards a supply contract to a firm owned by her brother without disclosing the link: a conflict of interest. 3. A drug company's report leaves out a study showing serious side effects: hiding information. 4. A manager humiliates a junior employee in front of customers: abusing power. 5. A clerk sees a colleague forging cheques and says nothing: condoning unethical actions. Check: in every case someone gains, or avoids trouble, at another person's or the firm's expense.
Utilitarianism: judging by consequences
Utilitarianism judges an action by its consequences: the right choice is whichever brings the most benefit to the most people, and an action that harms the majority is wrong. It is practical and familiar in business, where managers weigh costs and benefits. It has three well-known problems. Predicting how a decision will affect many people is very hard. There are always winners and losers, and the losers may be treated harshly for the sake of the total. And some costs, even if small relative to the benefits, strike many people as unacceptable whatever the arithmetic says, such as experiments that cause animals severe suffering.
Duties and rights
Deontology holds that people should meet their obligations and duties, such as keeping promises, telling the truth and obeying the law, because doing one's duty is what is right, whatever the consequences. It produces consistent decisions, but duties can clash: a technician running late must choose between the duty to be on time and the duty to obey speed limits. A closely related approach centres on rights. Human rights, such as life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, are held to belong to everyone and cannot be taken away arbitrarily. Legal rights are those that laws and constitutions guarantee, such as freedom of speech and religion, and protection against discrimination.
Justice and virtue
Justice asks what is fair according to society's standards: an equitable distribution of burdens and rewards. Societies disagree about what fair means. Many market economies accept that people are paid according to the value markets place on their work, so a surgeon earns more than a shop assistant, while others stress need or equality. In business, justice raises questions about fair pay, fair treatment and fair procedures. Virtue ethics takes a different angle, asking not "What rule applies?" but "What would a person of good character, honest, courageous and fair, do here?" Each framework highlights something the others can miss, so careful decision-makers often test a choice against several.
Worked example: a cutback through four lenses
An invented firm has 25 staff on 40 hours a week, 1,000 hours in all, and must cut to 800 hours. 1. Option A: lay off 5 people, so \(20 \times 40 = 800\) hours. Option B: keep everyone on \(800 \div 25 = 32\) hours. 2. Utilitarian view: A protects 20 full incomes but hits 5 people hard; B spreads a 20% pay cut across all. The total pain may be lower under B if losing a job is far worse than losing hours. 3. Duty view: had the firm promised job security? If so, B honours it. 4. Justice view: is the burden shared fairly, and were selection rules clear? 5. Virtue view: which choice would an honest, caring manager defend openly? The lenses may differ, which is why reasoning must be explicit.
Common ethical issues at work
Some issues come up again and again in business. Conflicts of interest arise when personal gain could influence professional judgement. Bribery and corruption distort competition; US firms are barred from bribing foreign officials by the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act of 1977. Fraud and dishonest accounting mislead investors and lenders. Discrimination and harassment harm employees and break the law. Misuse of customer data and misleading marketing betray customers' trust, and unsafe products can injure them. Many of these problems grow from pressure to hit targets, unclear rules or a culture that rewards results at any cost, a theme taken up in "How organizations shape ethical conduct".
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating legal and ethical as the same thing; the law is a floor, not the whole standard. Second, describing utilitarianism as doing whatever makes the most profit; it weighs the good of everyone affected, not just the firm. Third, assuming deontology always gives one clear answer; duties can conflict. Fourth, overlooking small violations, such as personal use of office supplies, which still belong in the category of taking what is not yours. Fifth, thinking silence is neutral: knowingly overlooking a colleague's wrongdoing is itself listed as an unethical act.
Key takeaways
Ethics is the moral principles used to tell right from wrong, and business ethics applies them at work. The first step is recognising an ethical issue; many unethical acts fall into categories such as taking, lying, false impressions, conflicts of interest, hiding information, unfair advantage, abuse of power and condoning wrongdoing. Utilitarianism judges consequences, deontology judges duties, rights-based thinking protects what people are entitled to, justice asks about fairness, and virtue ethics asks what a good person would do. Legal and ethical are not the same.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Moral principles for telling right from wrong
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A manager chooses the plan that will benefit the largest number of employees and customers, even though a few people lose out. Which approach is she using?
Question 2 of 5
An accountant refuses to backdate a document because she promised to follow the rules, even though doing so would help a client. Which framework fits her reasoning best?
Question 3 of 5
A purchasing manager awards a large contract to a supplier owned by his cousin without telling anyone about the link. Which category of unethical activity is this?
Question 4 of 5
Without saying anything false, a salesperson persuades an elderly customer to buy an expensive upgrade he does not need. No law is broken. Which statement is most accurate?
Question 5 of 5
A firm has 24 staff working 40 hours a week and must cut total hours to 840. If it keeps everyone and shares the cut equally, how many hours will each person work?
