Intro to Business › Section B · Ethics and social responsibility › Topic B.2
How organizations shape ethical conduct
People bring their own values to work, but the organisation around them matters just as much. What leaders reward, what training teaches, what the code of conduct says and whether it is safe to speak up all shape whether employees do the right thing under pressure.
Why the organisation matters
Individuals choose between right and wrong using their personal ethics, but the ethical environment their employer creates pushes them one way or the other. When targets are extreme and bad news is punished, decent people cut corners; when leaders model integrity and reward honesty, most people follow. Ethical failure is costly. It can bring fines, lawsuits, lost customers, collapsing share prices, prison sentences for those involved and, in the worst cases, bankruptcy. Organisations reduce those risks in three main ways: leading by example, training employees to handle dilemmas, and setting out a formal code of ethics backed by ways to report concerns.
Lessons from major scandals
Several scandals show what happens when the culture goes wrong. Enron, once one of the largest US energy companies, filed for bankruptcy in 2001 after using accounting tricks to hide debts; employees lost jobs and retirement savings. Bernard Madoff ran a huge investment fraud and was sentenced in 2009 to 150 years in prison. In 2015 Volkswagen admitted fitting diesel cars with software that cheated emissions tests, and the costs ran to tens of billions of dollars. At Wells Fargo, revealed in 2016, employees under aggressive sales targets opened about 2 million accounts without customers' permission (a review later raised the estimate to about 3.5 million), and the chief executive resigned that year.
Leading by example
Employees watch what leaders do far more closely than what they say. Managers set patterns of behaviour that show what is really acceptable, often called the tone at the top. A leader who bends the rules to hit a target signals that results matter more than how they are achieved; one who turns down a profitable but dishonest deal signals the opposite. Pay policy is one visible example. For years the ice-cream maker Ben & Jerry's capped its top salaries at a fixed multiple of its lowest wage, to tie executives' rewards to those of the lowest-paid staff. It dropped the cap in the mid-1990s to recruit an outside chief executive.
Worked example: a pay-ratio cap
An invented cooperative caps its highest salary at 7 times its lowest full-time salary. 1. The lowest full-time salary is 40,000 dollars a year, so the cap is \(7 \times 40000 = 280000\) dollars. 2. The board wants to pay a new chief executive 350,000 dollars. 3. To allow that under the cap, the lowest salary would need to be at least \(350000 \div 7 = 50000\) dollars. 4. Raising every salary below 50,000 dollars to that level is the price of the higher executive pay. 5. Interpret: the rule makes leaders' rewards rise only when the lowest-paid are lifted too, which is the message the policy is designed to send.
Ethics training
Many companies run formal ethics training to make employees aware of questionable practices and to let them practise responding. Effective programmes first teach a method for working through dilemmas, then present realistic cases and ask staff to find the best response. A typical case: your manager tells you not to put any criticism in the performance review of an employee who is clearly underperforming, and you learn that the last reviewer who did so left the company. What are the ethical issues, what options do you have, and should you go above your manager's head? Discussing such cases in groups helps people see blind spots before they face the real thing.
Codes of ethics
A code of ethics is a set of guidelines that tells employees what the firm expects of them in their behaviour towards colleagues, customers, suppliers and others. Most large companies and many small ones have one, often published on their websites. Some are detailed rule books; others are short statements of values and priorities. Do codes work? Critics call some of them public-relations exercises. Research and experience suggest a code changes behaviour only when senior managers follow it themselves, refer to it regularly and act when it is broken. A code that leaders ignore teaches employees that it does not really count.
Laws and speaking up
Scandals have led to new laws. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, passed after Enron and other frauds, requires the chief executive and chief financial officer of public companies to certify their financial reports, and it protects employees who report fraud from retaliation. The Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 created an SEC whistleblower programme: a person whose original information leads to sanctions over 1 million dollars can receive an award of 10% to 30% of the money collected. Inside firms, confidential hotlines and ethics officers give employees a safe route to raise concerns. A culture where people can speak up without fear catches problems early.
Worked example: a whistleblower award
An employee gives the SEC original information about a fraud, and the case ends with sanctions of 8 million dollars. 1. The sanctions exceed 1 million dollars, so the programme applies. 2. Minimum award: \(0.10 \times 8000000 = 800000\) dollars. 3. Maximum award: \(0.30 \times 8000000 = 2400000\) dollars. 4. The SEC decides where in that range the award falls, weighing factors such as how significant the information was and how much the person helped. 5. Interpret: the law gives employees a strong financial reason to report serious wrongdoing, alongside protection against retaliation. Anyone actually considering a report would need advice from a qualified lawyer.
Making the right decision
Many dilemmas have no obviously right answer, but a few questions help. First: is the action legal? If not, choose another course. Second: does it break the firm's code of ethics? If so, look for another way. Third: does it fit my own ethical principles? If it passes all three, two final tests remain. The feelings test asks how the decision makes you feel; lingering discomfort is often conscience at work. The headline or social media test asks how an objective reporter would describe the decision on a front page or in a widely shared post. Both tests are especially good at exposing conflicts of interest.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming a written code of ethics guarantees ethical behaviour; without leaders' example and enforcement it may be ignored. Second, thinking ethical failure only harms the wrongdoers; employees, customers, investors and communities often bear the costs. Third, stopping at the legal question: an action can pass it and still fail the code, personal ethics or the headline test. Fourth, treating ethics training as a one-off lecture; it works best through practice with realistic cases. Fifth, confusing the two laws: Sarbanes-Oxley requires executives to certify accounts, while Dodd-Frank created the SEC's whistleblower awards.
Key takeaways
Organisations shape ethical conduct through leaders' example, ethics training and formal codes of ethics backed by safe ways to speak up. Scandals at Enron (2001), Madoff's fraud (sentenced 2009), Volkswagen (2015) and Wells Fargo (2016) show the cost of failure. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 makes top executives certify financial reports and protects whistleblowers; the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 offers awards of 10% to 30% of sanctions over 1 million dollars. To decide, ask whether an action is legal, fits the code and fits your ethics, then apply the feelings and headline tests.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The pressures and signals an employer creates around right and wrong
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Two companies have almost identical codes of ethics. Which factor is most likely to make one code actually change employees' behaviour?
Question 2 of 5
Before signing a deal, a manager asks: "How would an objective reporter describe this decision in a front-page story?" Which test is this?
Question 3 of 5
Which requirement did the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 introduce?
Question 4 of 5
A whistleblower's original information leads to SEC sanctions of 5 million dollars. Under the Dodd-Frank programme, what is the possible range of the award?
Question 5 of 5
A firm caps its top salary at 5 times its lowest full-time salary of 32,000 dollars. What is the most it can pay its chief executive?
