Chemistry › Section L · Kinetics › Topic L.6

Reaction mechanisms

A balanced equation shows where a reaction starts and finishes, not how it gets there. A mechanism is the proposed sequence of simple steps along the way, and the rate law is the main evidence for deciding which sequence is right.

The equation is only a summary

Consider

\mathrm{H_2(g) + 2ICl(g) \rightarrow I_2(g) + 2HCl(g)}\,.

Read literally, it suggests one hydrogen molecule and two ICl molecules meeting at the same instant, which is extremely unlikely. In fact the reaction goes in two separate steps, each involving just two molecules. Most reactions work this way: a series of simple molecular events adds up to the overall change. That series is the reaction mechanism. Mechanisms cannot be watched directly, so chemists propose them and then test them against evidence, above all the experimentally measured rate law.

Elementary steps and molecularity

An elementary step is a single molecular event exactly as written: the particles shown on the left collide, or one particle falls apart or rearranges. Its molecularity is the number of reactant particles involved. A unimolecular step has one, such as the rearrangement of cyclopropane to propene. A bimolecular step has two, such as \(\mathrm{NO + O_3 \rightarrow NO_2 + O_2}\). A termolecular step has three, as in ozone formation high in the atmosphere, \(\mathrm{O + O_2 + M \rightarrow O_3 + M}\), where M is any molecule that carries away excess energy. Termolecular steps are rare, because three particles seldom collide at once, and four-particle steps are not expected at all.

Rate laws of elementary steps

For an elementary step, and only for an elementary step, the rate law can be written straight from the equation, because the step happens by the very collision it describes. A unimolecular step \(\mathrm{A \rightarrow products}\) has rate = k[A], first order. A bimolecular step \(\mathrm{A + B \rightarrow products}\) has rate = k[A][B], and \(\mathrm{2A \rightarrow products}\) has rate = k[A]². A termolecular step \(\mathrm{A + B + C \rightarrow products}\) has rate = k[A][B][C]. So the coefficients of an elementary step are its orders. That is not true for an overall equation, whose orders must still be measured, as the rate-laws topic showed.

Intermediates and catalysts

Adding the steps of a mechanism must give the overall equation. Species that cancel in the sum come in two kinds. An intermediate is made in one step and used up in a later step, like HI below. A catalyst does the opposite: it is used in an early step and regenerated later. In the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide with iodide ions, \(\mathrm{H_2O_2 + I^- \rightarrow H_2O + IO^-}\) is followed by

\mathrm{H_2O_2 + IO^- \rightarrow H_2O + O_2 + I^-}\,.

The sum is \(\mathrm{2H_2O_2 \rightarrow 2H_2O + O_2}\); IO⁻ is an intermediate and I⁻ a catalyst. Neither appears in the overall equation, and an intermediate must never appear in the final rate law.

The rate-determining step

When one step is much slower than the others, it limits the overall rate, just as the slowest checkout sets how fast a queue moves through a shop no matter how fast the others are. This slowest step is the rate-determining step. Steps after it wait on its output, so their speed hardly matters. If the rate-determining step is the first step, the overall rate law is simply that step's rate law. If faster steps come before it, the rate law can contain only species that appear in the overall equation or catalysts, so any intermediate in the slow step must be replaced, as the next cards show.

Worked example: a slow first step

The measured rate law for \(\mathrm{H_2 + 2ICl \rightarrow I_2 + 2HCl}\) is rate = k[H₂][ICl]. Proposed mechanism: step 1, \(\mathrm{H_2 + ICl \rightarrow HI + HCl}\) (slow); step 2, \(\mathrm{HI + ICl \rightarrow I_2 + HCl}\) (fast). 1. Sum:

\mathrm{H_2 + 2ICl + HI \rightarrow HI + 2HCl + I_2}\,;

HI cancels, leaving the overall equation. 2. HI is made in step 1 and used in step 2, so it is an intermediate. 3. Both steps are bimolecular, which is plausible. 4. Step 1 is rate-determining, so the predicted rate law is its own: rate = k₁[H₂][ICl]. 5. Check: this matches the measured rate law, so the mechanism is consistent with the evidence.

A fast equilibrium before the slow step

Sometimes the slow step contains an intermediate formed in a fast, reversible first step. Because that first step runs quickly in both directions, it stays close to equilibrium: its forward rate equals its reverse rate. For a step \(\mathrm{A \rightleftharpoons 2X}\) with forward constant \(k_1\) and reverse constant \(k_{-1}\), this gives \(k_1[\mathrm{A}] = k_{-1}[\mathrm{X}]^2\), so

[\mathrm{X}]^2 = \frac{k_1}{k_{-1}}[\mathrm{A}]

Substituting that into the slow step's rate law removes the intermediate. The constants combine into a single observed k, and the result can then be compared with experiment.

Worked example: hydrogen and iodine

For \(\mathrm{H_2(g) + I_2(g) \rightarrow 2HI(g)}\), the measured rate law is rate = k[H₂][I₂]. One proposed mechanism: step 1, \(\mathrm{I_2 \rightleftharpoons 2I}\) (fast equilibrium); step 2, \(\mathrm{H_2 + 2I \rightarrow 2HI}\) (slow). 1. Sum: 2I cancels, giving the overall equation, so I is an intermediate. 2. Slow step, termolecular but still plausible: rate = \(k_2[\mathrm{H_2}][\mathrm{I}]^2\), which contains the intermediate. 3. From the fast equilibrium: \([\mathrm{I}]^2 = \frac{k_1}{k_{-1}}[\mathrm{I_2}]\). 4. Substitute: rate = \(\frac{k_1k_2}{k_{-1}}[\mathrm{H_2}][\mathrm{I_2}]\). 5. Check: this has the measured form, with \(k = \frac{k_1k_2}{k_{-1}}\). A rate law that looks like one simple collision can hide a two-step path.

Judging a proposed mechanism

An acceptable mechanism must pass three tests. Its elementary steps must add up to the overall balanced equation. The rate law it predicts must match the experimentally measured rate law. And each step must be physically reasonable: unimolecular or bimolecular, or at most termolecular. Passing all three does not prove a mechanism; it only shows it is consistent with the evidence, and the H₂ + I₂ rate law fits both a single bimolecular collision and the two-step path above. Extra evidence, such as detecting an intermediate by its absorption of light, can strengthen the case. One failed test is enough to rule a mechanism out.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, writing an overall reaction's rate law from its coefficients; that shortcut works only for elementary steps. Second, leaving an intermediate in the final rate law instead of replacing it. Third, confusing intermediates with catalysts: an intermediate is formed then consumed, a catalyst is consumed then regenerated. Fourth, assuming the slowest step must come first. Fifth, thinking a mechanism that matches the rate law has been proved correct. Sixth, forgetting to check that the steps add up to the overall equation.

Key takeaways

A mechanism is a sequence of elementary steps that adds up to the overall equation. Molecularity counts the particles in a step: unimolecular, bimolecular or, rarely, termolecular. Only an elementary step's rate law can be read from its coefficients. Intermediates are formed then consumed; catalysts are consumed then regenerated. The slowest step is rate-determining: if it comes first, its rate law is the overall one; if a fast equilibrium comes first, use it to replace the intermediate. A good mechanism matches the measured rate law but is never proved by it.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Reaction mechanism

The sequence of elementary steps by which a reaction occurs

The steps add up to the overall equation.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which rate law belongs to the elementary step 2A + B → C?

Question 2 of 5

A proposed mechanism is: NO₂ + F₂ → NO₂F + F (slow), then NO₂ + F → NO₂F (fast). Which species is an intermediate?

Question 3 of 5

For the same mechanism, NO₂ + F₂ → NO₂F + F (slow) then NO₂ + F → NO₂F (fast), what rate law does it predict?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about the rate-determining step is correct?

Question 5 of 5

Why are termolecular elementary steps rare?

← Previous topicNext topic →