Chemistry › Section D · Stoichiometry of reactions › Topic D.4

Limiting reactants and yields

Real reactions rarely start with reactants in exact proportion, and they rarely deliver every gram the equation promises. The limiting reactant sets the most product you can make, and percent yield measures how close you came.

Something always runs out first

A factory fits each bracket with one bolt and two nuts. With 10 bolts and 14 nuts it can finish only 7 brackets: the nuts run out, and 3 bolts are left over. The nuts limit the output even though there are more of them, because each bracket needs twice as many nuts as bolts. Reactions behave the same way. Until now, stoichiometry problems assumed every other reactant was present in the amount needed. In practice one reactant is usually used up first, and from that moment the reaction stops, whatever remains of the others.

Limiting and excess reactants

The limiting reactant is the one completely consumed first; it fixes the maximum amount of product. The others are excess reactants, and some of each is left over. There are two reliable ways to find the limiting reactant, and both need moles, never grams. Method 1: for each reactant, calculate how much product it could make on its own; the one that makes less is limiting. Method 2: calculate how much of reactant B is needed to use up all of reactant A; if less B is available than that, B is limiting, otherwise A is. Method 1 is safer when there are several reactants, and it hands you the theoretical yield at the same time.

Worked example: the smaller mass is not always limiting

6.00 g of hydrogen and 36.0 g of oxygen react: \(\mathrm{2H_2 + O_2 \to 2H_2O}\). Which is limiting, how much water forms, and what is left? 1. Moles: \(6.00 \div 2.016 = 2.976\) mol \(\mathrm{H_2}\); \(36.0 \div 32.00 = 1.125\) mol \(\mathrm{O_2}\). 2. Water each could make: hydrogen, \(2.976 \times \frac{2}{2} = 2.976\) mol; oxygen, \(1.125 \times \frac{2}{1} = 2.250\) mol. Oxygen makes less, so it is limiting, despite its larger mass. 3. Water: \(2.250 \times 18.02 = 40.5\) g. 4. Hydrogen used: 2.250 mol, so \(2.976 - 2.250 = 0.726\) mol, or 1.46 g, remains. 5. Check: \(6.00 + 36.0 = 42.0\) g at the start, and \(40.5 + 1.46 = 42.0\) g at the end.

Worked example: comparing with the required amount

Aluminium burns in chlorine: \(\mathrm{2Al + 3Cl_2 \to 2AlCl_3}\). A flask holds 10.0 g of Al and 35.0 g of \(\mathrm{Cl_2}\). 1. Moles: \(10.0 \div 26.98 = 0.3706\) mol Al; \(35.0 \div 70.90 = 0.4937\) mol \(\mathrm{Cl_2}\). 2. Chlorine needed for all the aluminium: \(0.3706 \times \frac{3}{2} = 0.5560\) mol. Only 0.4937 mol is present, so chlorine is limiting. 3. Product from the chlorine: \(0.4937 \times \frac{2}{3} = 0.3291\) mol \(\mathrm{AlCl_3}\), or \(0.3291 \times 133.33 = 43.9\) g. 4. Aluminium left over: \(0.3706 - 0.3291 = 0.0415\) mol, or 1.12 g. 5. Check: \(43.9 + 1.12 = 45.0\) g, the starting total. Basing the answer on the aluminium would have given 49.4 g, more than the chlorine could ever supply.

Theoretical, actual and percent yield

The theoretical yield is the amount of product calculated from the limiting reactant, assuming it all turns into product. The actual yield is what you really collect and weigh. Their ratio is the percent yield:

\text{percent yield} = \frac{\text{actual yield}}{\text{theoretical yield}} \times 100\%

Both yields must be in the same unit, grams or moles, so the units cancel. If the aluminium chloride reaction above produced 38.5 g instead of 43.9 g, the percent yield would be \(38.5 \div 43.9 \times 100\% = 87.7\%\). Percent yield measures how well a procedure performed, not which reactant was limiting.

Why actual yields fall short

Several things keep the actual yield below the theoretical one. Side reactions turn some reactant into unwanted products. Some reactions are incomplete: they stop partway, leaving reactants and products mixed. Product is lost on glassware, filter paper and in transfers, and purification steps such as recrystallisation always leave some behind in solution. A percent yield above 100 percent does not mean the reaction beat the equation. It signals an error, most often a product still wet with solvent or contaminated with another substance, or a mistake in the calculation.

Worked example: percent yield of aspirin

Aspirin is made from salicylic acid and acetic anhydride:

\mathrm{C_7H_6O_3 + C_4H_6O_3 \to C_9H_8O_4 + C_2H_4O_2}\,.

A student uses 2.00 g of salicylic acid (138.12 g/mol) with excess acetic anhydride and collects 2.15 g of dry aspirin (180.16 g/mol). 1. Limiting reactant: salicylic acid, since the other reactant is in excess. 2. Moles: \(2.00 \div 138.12 = 0.01448\) mol. 3. Mole ratio 1 : 1, so 0.01448 mol of aspirin at most. 4. Theoretical yield: \(0.01448 \times 180.16 = 2.61\) g. 5. Percent yield: \(2.15 \div 2.61 \times 100\% = 82.4\%\). 6. Check: the answer lies below 100 percent, as expected for a product that has been filtered and dried.

Atom economy and green chemistry

A reaction with a perfect yield can still waste most of its atoms in by-products. Atom economy measures this from the balanced equation:

\text{atom economy} = \frac{\text{molar mass of desired product}}{\text{total molar mass of all reactants}} \times 100\%

counting each molar mass as many times as its coefficient. For aspirin, \(180.16 \div (138.12 + 102.09) \times 100\% = 75.0\%\); the rest leaves as acetic acid. Percent yield judges a single run against the equation; atom economy judges the route itself. Green chemistry favours routes with high atom economy and less hazardous waste, which matters most in drug manufacturing, where waste can outweigh the product many times.

Yields across several steps

Most medicines and materials need several reactions in a row, and the product of one step is the reactant of the next. The overall yield is the product of the step yields, written as decimals. Five steps at 80 percent each give \(0.80^5 = 0.328\), only about 33 percent overall. A four-step route with yields of 90, 85, 75 and 95 percent gives \(0.90 \times 0.85 \times 0.75 \times 0.95 = 0.545\), or 54.5 percent. One poor step drags the whole route down, which is why chemists work to shorten routes and improve their weakest step first.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, picking the limiting reactant by the smallest mass, or the smallest number of moles, without applying the mole ratio. Second, calculating the theoretical yield from the excess reactant. Third, inverting the percent yield fraction: actual goes on top, so a figure over 100 percent is a warning sign. Fourth, mixing units, such as an actual yield in grams over a theoretical yield in moles. Fifth, adding step yields instead of multiplying them. Sixth, confusing atom economy, a property of the route, with percent yield, a property of one run.

Key takeaways

The limiting reactant is used up first and sets the theoretical yield; find it by converting to moles and either comparing the product each reactant could make or comparing what is available with what is needed. The excess left over is the starting amount minus the amount used. Percent yield is actual yield divided by theoretical yield times 100 percent, and values above 100 percent signal an error. Step yields multiply, and atom economy shows how much of the reactants' mass a route can ever turn into product.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Limiting reactant

The reactant used up first, which fixes the maximum product

Find it with moles and the mole ratio, never by mass alone.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

For N₂ + 3H₂ → 2NH₃, a vessel holds 2.0 mol of N₂ and 4.5 mol of H₂. Which reactant is limiting, and how much NH₃ can form?

Question 2 of 5

A reaction has a theoretical yield of 24.0 g, and 18.6 g of product is collected. What is the percent yield?

Question 3 of 5

A student reports a percent yield of 112% for a solid product. What is the most likely explanation?

Question 4 of 5

A three-step synthesis has step yields of 90%, 80% and 50%. What is the overall yield?

Question 5 of 5

For 2Al + 3Cl₂ → 2AlCl₃, which statement about 1.0 mol Al and 1.2 mol Cl₂ is correct?

← Previous topicNext topic →