Chemistry › Section P · Thermodynamics › Topic P.3

The second and third laws

A system's entropy can fall during a spontaneous change, as when water freezes on a cold night. The second law explains why: what always rises is the entropy of the system and its surroundings together. The third law then gives entropy a true zero, so every substance can be given an absolute entropy value.

The system is not the whole story

Entropy rises when ice melts or a gas spreads out, and those changes are spontaneous. But plenty of spontaneous changes lower the entropy of the system. Water freezes in a freezer; dew condenses on grass at night; burning methane turns three moles of gas into one mole of gas and two moles of liquid. In each case the system releases heat, and that heat spreads into the surroundings, raising their entropy. To predict spontaneity you must therefore count both parts. Together the system and its surroundings make up the universe, in the thermodynamic sense of everything that could be affected.

The second law of thermodynamics

The second law states that in every spontaneous process the total entropy of the universe increases:

\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = \Delta S_{\text{sys}} + \Delta S_{\text{surr}} > 0

This gives a three-way test. If ΔS_univ > 0, the process is spontaneous. If ΔS_univ < 0, it is nonspontaneous, and the reverse process is spontaneous instead. If ΔS_univ = 0, the system is at equilibrium, with no tendency to go either way. A system's own entropy may fall, but only if the surroundings gain at least as much. Because the second law applies to every real process, the entropy of the universe is always growing.

Worked example: why heat flows from hot to cold

A block at 350 K touches a block at 300 K, and 1.00 kJ of heat passes between them. Assume each is large enough that its temperature barely changes. 1. If heat flows from hot to cold, the hot block loses entropy: \(\Delta S = \frac{-1000}{350} = -2.857\) J K⁻¹. 2. The cold block gains \(\frac{+1000}{300} = +3.333\) J K⁻¹. 3. Total: \(\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = +0.476\) J K⁻¹, positive, so this direction is spontaneous. 4. Flowing the other way flips both signs, giving −0.476 J K⁻¹, so it never happens on its own. 5. Check: the same heat produces more entropy at the lower temperature, which is why heat always moves towards the colder body.

Entropy change of the surroundings

The surroundings, such as the air or a water bath, are usually so large that a reaction barely changes their temperature, so they absorb or release heat as if reversibly. The heat they gain is the heat the system loses, \(q_{\text{surr}} = -q_{\text{sys}}\), and at constant pressure \(q_{\text{sys}} = \Delta H\). So

\Delta S_{\text{surr}} = -\frac{\Delta H_{\text{sys}}}{T}

An exothermic process (ΔH < 0) raises the entropy of the surroundings, and an endothermic one lowers it. Dividing by T means the same heat matters more at low temperature, which is why the balance between system and surroundings can change as temperature changes.

Worked example: will water freeze?

Freezing 1 mol of water releases 6.01 kJ and has ΔS_sys = −22.0 J K⁻¹; assume both stay constant near 0 °C. Is freezing spontaneous at −15 °C, and at +15 °C? 1. At −15 °C, T = 258.15 K and \(\Delta S_{\text{surr}} = -\frac{-6010}{258.15} = +23.3\) J K⁻¹. 2. Then \(\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = -22.0 + 23.3 = +1.3\) J K⁻¹: spontaneous. 3. At +15 °C, T = 288.15 K and \(\Delta S_{\text{surr}} = +20.9\) J K⁻¹, so \(\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = -1.1\) J K⁻¹: nonspontaneous, and melting is spontaneous instead. 4. Check: at 273.15 K the two terms cancel exactly, giving zero, the equilibrium condition at the normal freezing point.

The third law of thermodynamics

The third law states that the entropy of a pure, perfectly ordered crystalline substance at absolute zero is zero. At 0 K such a crystal has every particle in its one fixed place with the lowest possible energy, so there is just one microstate: W = 1, and \(S = k \ln 1 = 0\). This gives entropy a true starting point. By measuring how much heat a substance absorbs as it is warmed from near 0 K, through any phase changes, up to 298.15 K, chemists add up its entropy gains and obtain its absolute entropy. Enthalpy has no such zero, which is why only changes in H, measured from chosen reference states, can be tabulated.

Standard molar entropies

The standard molar entropy, S°, is the absolute entropy of 1 mol of a substance in its standard state, at 1 bar, usually tabulated at 298.15 K, in J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹. Every pure substance above 0 K has a positive S°, and that includes elements: unlike ΔH°f, S° of an element is not zero. Some values: graphite 5.74, diamond 2.38, H₂O(l) 70.0, H₂(g) 130.7, CH₄(g) 186.3, H₂O(g) 188.8, N₂(g) 191.6, NH₃(g) 192.8, CO(g) 197.7, O₂(g) 205.2 and CO₂(g) 213.8. The trends from the last topic show up clearly: gases sit far above solids and liquids, and rigid diamond is lower than layered graphite.

Entropy changes for reactions

Because S is a state function with absolute values, a reaction's standard entropy change follows the same pattern as enthalpy from formation values:

\Delta S^\circ = \sum n\,S^\circ(\text{products}) - \sum n\,S^\circ(\text{reactants})

where n is each coefficient in the balanced equation. Every substance contributes, elements included. For ammonia synthesis, \(\mathrm{N_2(g) + 3H_2(g) \rightarrow 2NH_3(g)}\): \(2(192.8) - [191.6 + 3(130.7)] = -198.1\) J K⁻¹. The negative sign fits the drop from four moles of gas to two, a quick check worth making every time.

Worked example: burning methane

Is

\mathrm{CH_4(g) + 2O_2(g) \rightarrow CO_2(g) + 2H_2O(l)}

spontaneous at 298 K? Use ΔH° = −890.5 kJ and the S° values above. 1. Products: \(213.8 + 2(70.0) = 353.8\) J K⁻¹. 2. Reactants: \(186.3 + 2(205.2) = 596.7\) J K⁻¹. 3. \(\Delta S^\circ_{\text{sys}} = 353.8 - 596.7 = -242.9\) J K⁻¹: the system loses entropy. 4. Surroundings: \(\Delta S_{\text{surr}} = -\frac{-890{,}500}{298} = +2988\) J K⁻¹. 5. Universe: \(-242.9 + 2988 = +2745\) J K⁻¹, or about \(+2.75 \times 10^3\) J K⁻¹: strongly spontaneous. 6. Check: the heat released to the surroundings outweighs the system's loss more than tenfold.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, judging spontaneity from ΔS_sys alone; the surroundings must be added. Second, forgetting the minus sign in \(\Delta S_{\text{surr}} = -\Delta H/T\): an exothermic reaction gives the surroundings positive entropy. Third, mixing kJ and J; convert ΔH to joules before combining it with entropies in J K⁻¹. Fourth, setting S° of elements such as O₂(g) or graphite to zero, as you would for ΔH°f. Fifth, forgetting to multiply each S° by its coefficient. Sixth, stating the third law for any substance at 0 K; it applies to a pure, perfect crystal.

Key takeaways

The second law: in every spontaneous process, ΔS_univ = ΔS_sys + ΔS_surr > 0; when ΔS_univ < 0 the reverse is spontaneous, and ΔS_univ = 0 means equilibrium. At constant T and P, ΔS_surr = −ΔH_sys/T, so released heat raises the surroundings' entropy, more strongly at low temperature. The third law: a pure, perfect crystal has S = 0 at 0 K. This makes absolute standard molar entropies possible, all positive, elements included, and ΔS° = Σ n S°(products) − Σ n S°(reactants).

Flashcards

Flashcard

Universe (thermodynamics)

The system plus its surroundings

Everything the process could affect.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Using S° values (J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹) of 197.7 for CO(g), 205.2 for O₂(g) and 213.8 for CO₂(g), what is ΔS° for 2CO(g) + O₂(g) → 2CO₂(g)?

Question 2 of 5

A reaction at constant pressure has ΔH = −100.0 kJ at 400 K. What is the entropy change of the surroundings?

Question 3 of 5

According to the third law, which of these has an entropy of exactly zero?

Question 4 of 5

A process has ΔS(sys) = −50 J K⁻¹ and ΔS(surr) = +80 J K⁻¹. What can you conclude?

Question 5 of 5

500 J of heat flows from a large body at 400 K to a large body at 250 K. What is ΔS(univ)?

← Previous topicNext topic →