Chemistry › Section G · Chemical bonding and molecular geometry › Topic G.6
Molecular shape and polarity
A Lewis structure is flat, but molecules are not. Counting the electron groups around a central atom lets you predict a molecule's three-dimensional shape, and the shape decides whether the molecule as a whole is polar, which in turn affects what it dissolves in and how it boils.
Molecules in three dimensions
Two numbers describe the geometry of a molecule. The bond length is the distance between the nuclei of two bonded atoms, usually given in picometres (1 pm = 10⁻¹² m) or ångströms (1 Å = 100 pm). The bond angle is the angle between two bonds that share an atom. Water and carbon dioxide are both a central atom with two outer atoms, yet the water molecule is bent and the carbon dioxide molecule is straight. That difference makes water polar and carbon dioxide not.
The VSEPR idea
Valence shell electron-pair repulsion (VSEPR) theory says that the regions of electron density around a central atom repel one another and spread out to be as far apart as possible. Each region is an electron group. A lone pair counts as one group, and so does each bond, whether single, double or triple, because all the electrons of a multiple bond lie between the same two atoms. A single unpaired electron, as in a free radical, also counts as one group. So draw the Lewis structure, count the electron groups on the central atom, and find the arrangement that keeps them furthest apart.
The five electron-pair geometries
The number of electron groups fixes their arrangement, the electron-pair geometry. Two groups lie on opposite sides: linear, 180°, as in \(\mathrm{BeCl_2}\) gas or \(\mathrm{CO_2}\). Three form a triangle in one plane: trigonal planar, 120°, as in \(\mathrm{BF_3}\). Four point to the corners of a tetrahedron: tetrahedral, 109.5°, as in \(\mathrm{CH_4}\). Five form a trigonal bipyramid, with three equatorial positions at 120° around the middle and two axial positions above and below at 90° to them, as in \(\mathrm{PCl_5}\). Six point to the corners of an octahedron, all at 90°, as in \(\mathrm{SF_6}\).
Lone pairs change the shape and the angles
The molecular structure, or shape, describes where the atoms are, so it is named from the bonded atoms only, while lone pairs still occupy their share of the electron-pair geometry. Methane, ammonia and water each have four electron groups and a tetrahedral electron-pair geometry. Methane, with four bonds, is tetrahedral at 109.5°. Ammonia, with three bonds and one lone pair, is trigonal pyramidal. Water, with two bonds and two lone pairs, is bent. A lone pair is held by only one nucleus, so it spreads out more than a bonding pair, and repulsions fall in the order lone pair–lone pair > lone pair–bond pair > bond pair–bond pair. That squeezes the bond angles to about 107° in \(\mathrm{NH_3}\) and about 104.5° in \(\mathrm{H_2O}\).
Five and six groups with lone pairs
In a trigonal bipyramid, lone pairs take equatorial positions, where they have only two neighbours at 90° instead of three. One lone pair gives a seesaw shape (\(\mathrm{SF_4}\)), two give a T-shape (\(\mathrm{ClF_3}\)) and three give a linear molecule (\(\mathrm{XeF_2}\)), with its three lone pairs around the middle. In an octahedron, one lone pair gives a square pyramid (\(\mathrm{BrF_5}\)), and two lone pairs sit opposite each other, leaving a flat square of atoms: square planar (\(\mathrm{XeF_4}\)). A shorthand helps: AX\(_m\)E\(_n\) means a central atom A with m bonded atoms X and n lone pairs E, so water is \(\mathrm{AX_2E_2}\).
Worked example: phosphorus trichloride
Predict the shape and bond angle of \(\mathrm{PCl_3}\). 1. From its Lewis structure, phosphorus has three P–Cl bonds and one lone pair, 26 valence electrons in all. 2. Count electron groups on P: 3 bonds + 1 lone pair = 4. 3. Four groups give a tetrahedral electron-pair geometry. 4. Only three positions hold atoms, so the molecular structure is trigonal pyramidal, \(\mathrm{AX_3E}\), like ammonia. 5. The lone pair pushes the bonds together, so the Cl–P–Cl angle is less than 109.5°; measurements give about 100°. 6. Check: trigonal planar would need three groups and no lone pair, as in \(\mathrm{BF_3}\).
Multiple bonds and larger molecules
Because a multiple bond is one electron group, carbon dioxide's carbon has two groups and is linear, and so is the carbon in hydrogen cyanide, H–C≡N. In formaldehyde, \(\mathrm{H_2CO}\), carbon has two single bonds and one double bond: three groups, trigonal planar. Its H–C–H angle is about 116°, slightly below 120°, because the electron-rich double bond takes up more room. In larger molecules, apply VSEPR to each central atom in turn. In methanol, \(\mathrm{CH_3OH}\), the carbon has four bonds and is tetrahedral, while the oxygen has two bonds and two lone pairs and is bent, like the oxygen in water.
Bond dipoles and molecular polarity
A polar bond is a bond dipole: a separation of partial charges with a size and a direction. Chemists draw it as an arrow pointing to the δ− end, with a small cross at the δ+ end. A molecule's overall dipole moment is the vector sum of its bond dipoles, measured in debye (D). In \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) the two C=O dipoles are equal and point in exactly opposite directions, so they cancel: the molecule is nonpolar, although its bonds are polar. In bent \(\mathrm{H_2O}\) the two O–H dipoles both point partly towards oxygen and add up, giving a polar molecule with a dipole moment of about 1.85 D. Ammonia is polar too, at about 1.47 D.
Predicting polarity
A molecule is polar if it has polar bonds arranged so that they do not cancel. Molecules with identical outer atoms, no lone pairs on the central atom, and one of the five basic shapes are nonpolar: \(\mathrm{CO_2}\), \(\mathrm{BF_3}\), \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\), \(\mathrm{PCl_5}\) and \(\mathrm{SF_6}\). Linear \(\mathrm{XeF_2}\) and square planar \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\) are also nonpolar, because their lone pairs sit symmetrically. Break the symmetry and polarity appears: replace one Cl in \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\) with H to get \(\mathrm{CHCl_3}\), which is polar, and \(\mathrm{NH_3}\), unlike \(\mathrm{BF_3}\), is pyramidal and polar. Polarity matters because like dissolves like: water dissolves polar ethanol and sugar but not nonpolar oils.
Worked example: sulfur tetrafluoride
Predict the shape of \(\mathrm{SF_4}\) and decide whether it is polar. 1. Its Lewis structure has four S–F bonds and one lone pair on sulfur, 34 valence electrons. 2. Electron groups on S: 4 + 1 = 5, so the electron-pair geometry is trigonal bipyramidal. 3. The lone pair takes an equatorial position. 4. That leaves two axial and two equatorial fluorines: a seesaw, \(\mathrm{AX_4E}\). 5. Bond polarity: ΔEN = 3.98 − 2.58 = 1.40, so each S–F bond is polar. 6. The seesaw is not symmetrical, and the four bond dipoles do not cancel, so \(\mathrm{SF_4}\) is polar. 7. Contrast \(\mathrm{SF_6}\): six identical bonds in an octahedron cancel, so it is nonpolar.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, naming the shape from the electron-pair geometry: ammonia's electron groups are tetrahedral, but the molecule is trigonal pyramidal. Second, counting a double or triple bond as two or three groups. Third, forgetting lone pairs on the central atom, which come only from a correct Lewis structure. Fourth, deciding polarity from the bonds alone: \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) and \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\) have polar bonds but are nonpolar. Fifth, assuming every molecule with lone pairs is polar: \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\) is not. Sixth, putting lone pairs in axial positions of a trigonal bipyramid.
Key takeaways
VSEPR theory: electron groups around a central atom, counting each bond (single or multiple) and each lone pair as one group, spread as far apart as possible. Two to six groups give linear (180°), trigonal planar (120°), tetrahedral (109.5°), trigonal bipyramidal (90° and 120°) and octahedral (90°) electron-pair geometries. The molecular shape names only the atoms: \(\mathrm{NH_3}\) is trigonal pyramidal at about 107° and \(\mathrm{H_2O}\) bent at about 104.5°, because lone pairs repel more strongly. A molecule is polar when its bond dipoles do not cancel, as in \(\mathrm{H_2O}\), and nonpolar when they do, as in \(\mathrm{CO_2}\).
Flashcards
Flashcard
Electron groups around a central atom spread as far apart as possible
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What is the molecular structure of ammonia, NH₃?
Question 2 of 5
What is the approximate H–O–H bond angle in water?
Question 3 of 5
Which of these molecules is polar?
Question 4 of 5
XeF₄ has four bonds and two lone pairs on xenon. What is its molecular structure?
Question 5 of 5
In SO₂, sulfur has two bonds to oxygen and one lone pair. What is the shape of the molecule?
