Electrical Engineering › Section P · Semiconductor theory, diodes, and transistors › Topic P.6
Inductor commutating and diode switching circuits, and Zener diodes
Diodes earn their keep far beyond rectifiers. One across a relay coil saves the switch from destructive voltage spikes, a few with resistors make logic gates and signal switches, and a diode built to break down safely, the Zener, holds a voltage steady.
Three more jobs for a diode
This topic puts the diode to three new uses, analysed with the constant 0.7 V model: protecting switches from the voltage an inductor produces when its current is interrupted; switching logic levels, power sources and signals; and regulation with the Zener diode, built to work safely in reverse breakdown. The common thread: a conducting diode holds a nearly fixed voltage, about 0.7 V forwards or, for a Zener, its rated voltage backwards.
Inductive kickback
As "Self-inductance, inductor types, and induced voltage" showed, an inductor's voltage is \(v_L = L\,di/dt\), so it resists any sudden change in current. Open the switch feeding a relay coil and the current is forced towards zero almost instantly; di/dt is huge, and the coil produces a large reversed voltage trying to keep its current flowing. Interrupting 30 mA in 1 µs in a 0.20 H coil would demand \(0.20 \times 0.030/10^{-6} = 6000\) V. In practice the voltage rises until something breaks down: an arc across the switch contacts, eroding them, or the junction of a switching transistor, destroying it.
The commutating diode
The simplest cure is a diode across the coil, reverse biased in normal operation: cathode to the coil end joined to the positive supply. While the coil is energised it does nothing. When the switch opens, the reversed coil voltage forward-biases it, and the coil current circulates through it, decaying as the coil's resistance turns the stored energy into heat. The coil is clamped at one drop, so the switch sees only the supply plus about 0.7 V. This commutating, flyback or freewheeling diode has one price: slower release, because a small voltage means a slow change in current.
Worked example: a relay coil
A 12 V relay coil has 400 Ω resistance and 0.20 H inductance, with a commutating diode. 1. Coil current: \(12/400 = 30\) mA. 2. With the diode alone, the switch sees about \(12 + 0.7 = 12.7\) V, and, neglecting the diode drop, the current decays with \(\tau \approx L/R = 0.20/400 = 0.50\) ms, dying away in about \(5\tau = 2.5\) ms. 3. Add 1.0 kΩ in series with the diode: \(\tau = 0.20/1400 = 0.143\) ms, over three times faster. 4. The cost: at the moment of opening, 30 mA flows through 1.0 kΩ, so the switch sees \(12 + 30 + 0.7 = 42.7\) V. 5. Choose the resistor so that peak stays within the switch's rating.
Diode logic and power OR-ing
In a diode AND gate, each input drives a diode's cathode, the anodes join at the output, and a resistor pulls the output up to +5 V. Any input at 0 V makes its diode conduct and pulls the output to about 0.7 V; only if every input is high does the output stay high. Reverse the diodes and pull the output to ground for an OR gate: any high input raises the output to that input less 0.7 V. Early computers used diode logic, but each stage loses a drop and gives no gain. The OR idea survives in power supplies: two diodes let a mains adaptor or a backup battery, whichever is higher, feed one load without back-feeding the other.
Diodes as signal switches
Conducting, a diode is a low resistance; reverse biased, almost an open circuit. So dc bias can switch an ac signal on and off, if control and signal are kept apart. In a radio, a small dc current fed through RF chokes, inductors that pass dc but block radio frequencies, forward-biases a diode that connects a tuning capacitor into a resonant circuit, while capacitors keep the dc out of the signal path. Reverse the bias and the capacitor drops out, raising the resonant frequency. At very high frequencies a reverse-biased junction's own capacitance leaks signal, so PIN diodes are used instead.
Zener diodes
An ordinary diode driven into reverse breakdown is usually destroyed. A Zener diode is heavily doped to break down sharply at a chosen voltage \(V_Z\) and to survive it, provided its power rating, \(P = V_ZI_Z\), is respected. Forward biased, it behaves like any silicon diode. Below about 5 V, breakdown comes mainly from the Zener effect, tunnelling across a very thin depletion region, and \(V_Z\) falls slightly with temperature; above about 6 V avalanche multiplication dominates and \(V_Z\) rises with temperature, so parts near 5 to 6 V drift least. Zeners come in standard steps such as 3.3, 4.7, 5.1, 6.2 and 12 V, commonly with ±5% tolerance. Overloaded, they usually fail shorted.
The Zener shunt regulator
The basic regulator is a series resistor \(R_S\) from the supply to the output, with the Zener across the output, cathode to positive, and the load in parallel with it. While the Zener conducts, the output stays near \(V_Z\) and the resistor drops the rest, carrying \(I_S = (V_S - V_Z)/R_S\). That current divides: \(I_S = I_Z + I_L\). When the load draws less, the Zener takes more: simple, but wasteful. To check whether the Zener conducts at all, remove it and find the voltage the resistor and load alone give. Only if that exceeds \(V_Z\) does it regulate; a Zener limits voltage but cannot make up for too little.
Worked example: a 5.1 V regulator
A 12.0 V supply feeds a 5.1 V Zener through 220 Ω, with a 330 Ω load. 1. Check first: without the Zener, \(12 \times 330/550 = 7.2\) V, above 5.1 V, so it regulates. 2. Series current: \(I_S = (12.0 - 5.1)/220 = 31.4\) mA. 3. Load current: \(I_L = 5.1/330 = 15.5\) mA. 4. Zener current: \(I_Z = 31.4 - 15.5 = 15.9\) mA, so \(P_Z = 5.1 \times 0.0159 = 81\) mW. 5. Worst case is no load: all 31.4 mA, 0.160 W, so a 0.5 W Zener is safe. 6. The resistor dissipates \(6.9 \times 0.0314 = 0.216\) W; use a 0.5 W part. 7. Smallest load that regulates: \(R_L = V_ZR_S/(V_S - V_Z) = 163\,\Omega\).
Worked example: when the Zener drops out
The same regulator now feeds a 100 Ω load, below the 163 Ω limit. 1. Remove the Zener: the resistors form a divider giving \(12.0 \times 100/(220 + 100) = 3.75\) V. 2. Compare: 3.75 V is below 5.1 V, so the Zener cannot break down and carries no current. 3. Result: the output is just 3.75 V and follows every change in the supply. 4. Fix: a smaller \(R_S\) allows heavier loads but raises the no-load Zener dissipation, the circuit's basic trade-off. Breakdown also clips waves: two Zeners in series, facing opposite ways, limit a signal to about \(\pm(V_Z + 0.7)\), one breaking down while the other conducts forwards.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, fitting a commutating diode backwards, which short-circuits the supply. Second, expecting a protected relay to release as fast as an unprotected one. Third, connecting a Zener forward biased in a regulator; it then holds only 0.7 V. Fourth, assuming a Zener always shows \(V_Z\); check the voltage with it removed. Fifth, sizing the Zener for the loaded case; the worst case is no load. Sixth, forgetting that a diode logic output is a drop away from the input.
Key takeaways
Interrupting an inductor's current produces a large reversed voltage, v = L di/dt. A commutating diode across the coil clamps it at about 0.7 V, so the switch sees the supply plus 0.7 V, but release slows, τ ≈ L/R; a series resistor speeds release but raises the spike. Diodes also form AND and OR gates and switch signals. A Zener diode regulates in reverse breakdown: I_S = (V_S − V_Z)/R_S = I_Z + I_L, it regulates only if the voltage without it exceeds V_Z, and its worst-case dissipation is at no load.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A large reversed voltage when an inductor's current is interrupted
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A Zener regulator has a 15 V supply, a 470 Ω series resistor, a 6.2 V Zener and a 1.0 kΩ load. What is the Zener current?
Question 2 of 5
A 9.0 V supply feeds a 5.1 V Zener through 1.0 kΩ, and the load is 470 Ω. What is the load voltage?
Question 3 of 5
A 24 V relay coil draws 50 mA. Its commutating diode has a 330 Ω resistor in series. About what voltage does the switch see just after it opens?
Question 4 of 5
Why does a commutating diode make a relay release more slowly?
Question 5 of 5
Which Zener voltage tends to have the smallest temperature drift?
