Electrical Engineering › Section D · Parallel and series-parallel circuits › Topic D.4

Sources in parallel, open circuits, and short circuits

Batteries wired side by side, a broken wire, a stray blob of solder: each changes a circuit in ways that the plain series and parallel rules handle only if you know exactly what an open and a short do. This topic pins those two conditions down and shows when sources may share a load.

Two extreme conditions

Real circuits rarely stay as drawn. Batteries get connected side by side to share a heavy load, a lead breaks inside its insulation, or a tool slips and bridges two terminals. This topic covers voltage sources in parallel, the open circuit and the short circuit. Opens and shorts are the extremes of resistance, infinite and zero, and each fixes one quantity at zero while leaving the other free. They look trivial, yet they cause many slips in analysis, and later methods, such as "Thevenin's theorem", create them on purpose.

Identical voltage sources in parallel

Only sources with equal voltage ratings should share a pair of nodes, and the reason to connect them that way is current capacity. Parallel elements share one voltage, while by KCL the load current is the sum of the source currents, \(I_s = I_1 + I_2\). Two identical batteries can therefore deliver twice the current, and twice the power, at the same voltage. Their internal resistances are also in parallel, so the pair acts like one source of the same EMF with half the internal resistance. One 12.6 V battery with 0.05 Ω inside drives a 1.2 Ω load at 10.1 A and 12.1 V; two in parallel give 10.3 A at 12.3 V, about 5.1 A each.

Unequal sources in parallel

Connect two sources of different voltage in parallel and the higher one drives current into the lower one. For ideal sources this is impossible: KVL around the loop would demand \(E_1 = E_2\), so circuit models never place unequal ideal voltage sources in parallel. Real batteries have internal resistance, as "Internal resistance and voltage regulation" showed, but in a large battery it is only milliohms. That is all that limits the circulating current, so a mismatch of under a volt can drive tens of amperes. The stronger battery discharges uselessly, the weaker one is charged far too fast, and both heat up. The terminal voltage settles between the two EMFs.

Worked example: mismatched batteries

A 12.7 V battery with internal resistance 15 mΩ is connected + to + and − to − with a partly discharged 11.9 V battery whose internal resistance is 25 mΩ. No load is attached. 1. The batteries form one loop with opposing EMFs, so the net driving voltage is \(12.7 - 11.9 = 0.8\,\text{V}\). 2. The loop resistance is \(15 + 25 = 40\,\text{m}\Omega\). 3. The current is \(I = 0.8 / 0.040 = 20\,\text{A}\), leaving the + terminal of the stronger battery and entering the + terminal of the weaker one. 4. Terminal voltage: \(12.7 - 20(0.015) = 12.4\,\text{V}\); check from the other side, \(11.9 + 20(0.025) = 12.4\,\text{V}\). 5. Heat in the internal resistances is \(20^2 \times 0.040 = 16\,\text{W}\). A 6.3 V battery in place of the weaker one would draw 160 A.

The open circuit

An open circuit is a pair of terminals with nothing connecting them. With no conducting path, its current is always zero, but the voltage across it can be any value: the rest of the network decides it. In short, an open circuit can have a voltage across it but never a current through it. Because \(I = 0\), every resistor in series with the open has \(V = IR = 0\), so for voltage purposes it acts like a plain connecting wire. In a single loop, then, the full net source voltage appears across the gap. Open switches, blown fuses and broken traces are all opens, and the voltage across unloaded output terminals is called the open-circuit voltage.

Worked example: resistors beside a gap

"Kirchhoff's voltage law" found the voltage across a gap between two bare batteries; here each source reaches the gap through a resistor. A 15 V source \(E_1\) has its − terminal at ground and its + terminal connected through \(R_1 = 1\,\text{k}\Omega\) to terminal a. Terminal b connects through \(R_2 = 2.2\,\text{k}\Omega\) to the + terminal of a 6 V source \(E_2\), whose − terminal is at ground. Terminals a and b are not connected. Find \(V_{ab}\). 1. There is no closed path, so \(I = 0\) and both resistor drops are zero. 2. So terminal a sits at the + terminal of \(E_1\): \(V_a = 15\,\text{V}\). 3. Likewise \(V_b = 6\,\text{V}\). 4. \(V_{ab} = V_a - V_b = 9\,\text{V}\), with a positive. Check by KVL around the loop through the gap: \(15 - 9 - 6 = 0\). Were \(E_2\) reversed, \(V_b\) would be −6 V and \(V_{ab}\) 21 V.

The short circuit

A short circuit is a direct connection of essentially zero resistance between two points. Its voltage is always zero, since \(V = I \times 0 = 0\), but its current can be anything the rest of the network sets. Any resistor in parallel with a short therefore has zero voltage and so zero current: it is "shorted out" and can be dropped from the analysis. A deliberate short is made with a jumper wire; a closed ideal switch is one too. An accidental short is a fault. A 12 V battery with 20 mΩ of internal resistance shorted directly would try to deliver \(12 / 0.02 = 600\,\text{A}\), which is why every branch needs the protection described in "Circuit breakers, GFCIs, fuses, and safety".

Worked example: a resistor shorted out

Resistors \(R_1 = 1.0\,\text{k}\Omega\), \(R_2 = 2.2\,\text{k}\Omega\) and \(R_3 = 4.7\,\text{k}\Omega\) are in series across a 24 V source. Find the current and \(V_3\) before and after a jumper is connected across \(R_2\). 1. Before: \(R_T = 7.9\,\text{k}\Omega\), so \(I = 24 / 7.9\,\text{k} = 3.04\,\text{mA}\) and \(V_3 = 3.04\,\text{mA} \times 4.7\,\text{k}\Omega = 14.3\,\text{V}\). 2. With the jumper, \(R_2\) is in parallel with 0 Ω, so the pair is 0 Ω, \(V_2 = 0\) and \(R_2\) carries no current. 3. Now \(R_T = 5.7\,\text{k}\Omega\) and \(I = 24 / 5.7\,\text{k} = 4.21\,\text{mA}\). 4. \(V_3 = 4.21 \times 4.7 = 19.8\,\text{V}\) and \(V_1 = 4.21\,\text{V}\). Check: \(19.8 + 4.21 = 24.0\,\text{V}\). The short raised the current by about 39%.

Spotting opens and shorts in a network

Four rules cover most cases. An element in series with an open carries no current. An element in parallel with an open is unaffected, since the open branch draws nothing. A resistor in parallel with a short has no voltage and no current. A short in series with an element is just a wire. For instance, let a 10 V source feed node a through 470 Ω, with a 1 kΩ resistor and a jumper both from a to ground. The jumper holds a at 0 V, so the 1 kΩ resistor carries nothing and all \(10 / 470 = 21.3\,\text{mA}\) flows through the jumper.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming the voltage across an open is zero because its current is zero: the gap often carries the whole source voltage. Second, the mirror slip: assuming a short carries no current because it has no voltage. Third, paralleling batteries whose voltages or states of charge differ. Fourth, giving resistors in series with an open a voltage drop; with no current they drop nothing. Fifth, forgetting that a jumper across one of several parallel branches shorts every branch between those two nodes.

Key takeaways

Parallel voltage sources must have equal ratings; their voltage stays the same while current capacity and power add. Unequal sources in parallel drive a circulating current limited only by their internal resistances. An open circuit has zero current, but its voltage is set by the rest of the network, so the full loop voltage often appears across it. A short circuit has zero voltage, but its current is set by the rest of the network. Resistors in parallel with a short, or in series with an open, carry no current.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Identical sources in parallel

Same terminal voltage; current capacity and power add

Is = I1 + I2 by KCL.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Two identical 9 V batteries are connected in parallel to supply a load. Compared with one battery alone, what does the pair provide?

Question 2 of 5

A 12.6 V battery with 20 mΩ internal resistance is connected in parallel with a 12.0 V battery with 30 mΩ internal resistance. No load is attached. What current circulates?

Question 3 of 5

A 12 V source has its − terminal at ground and its + terminal connected through 1 kΩ to terminal a. Terminal b connects through 2.2 kΩ to the − terminal of a 5 V source whose + terminal is at ground. Terminals a and b are open. What is Vab?

Question 4 of 5

Resistors of 1.5 kΩ and 3.0 kΩ are in series across an 18 V source. A jumper is then connected across the 3.0 kΩ resistor. What are the voltage across the 3.0 kΩ resistor and the source current now?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about an ideal short circuit is correct?

← Previous topicNext topic →