Electrical Engineering › Section L · Power (ac) and resonance › Topic L.6

Impedance versus frequency and selectivity

A tuned circuit is only useful if it responds strongly near its resonant frequency and weakly elsewhere. Plotting impedance and current against frequency shows how sharp that response is, and the bandwidth puts a number on it.

Beyond the resonant frequency

The topic "Series resonance and the quality factor" looked at a series R-L-C circuit exactly at \(f_s = 1/(2\pi\sqrt{LC})\). A radio, a filter or a sensor also needs to know what happens just off resonance: how quickly the current falls as the frequency moves away from \(f_s\). A circuit that responds over only a narrow band of frequencies is called selective, because it picks out signals in that band and largely ignores the rest. This topic follows the impedance, phase and current of the series circuit across the whole frequency range, then defines bandwidth, the standard measure of selectivity.

Impedance versus frequency

Each element behaves differently with frequency. The resistance \(R\) is taken as constant over the range of interest. The inductive reactance \(X_L = 2\pi fL\) is a straight line through the origin with slope \(2\pi L\). The capacitive reactance \(X_C = 1/(2\pi fC)\) is a hyperbola, very large at low frequency and falling fast. The lines cross at \(f_s\). The total impedance magnitude is

|Z_T| = \sqrt{R^2 + (X_L - X_C)^2}

It is very large near zero frequency, falls to its minimum \(R\) at \(f_s\), then rises again. On a linear frequency axis the curve is not symmetric: it climbs more steeply below \(f_s\), where \(X_C\) grows quickly, than above it.

Phase versus frequency

The angle of the impedance is

\theta = \tan^{-1}\frac{X_L - X_C}{R}

Below \(f_s\), \(X_C > X_L\), so \(\theta\) is negative: the circuit is capacitive, the current leads the source voltage and the power factor is leading. Far below resonance \(\theta\) approaches \(-90^\circ\). Above \(f_s\), \(X_L > X_C\), so the circuit is inductive, the current lags and the power factor is lagging, with \(\theta\) approaching \(+90^\circ\) at high frequency. At \(f_s\) itself \(\theta = 0\) and the circuit is purely resistive. At the band edges defined below, \(|X_L - X_C| = R\), so \(\theta = \pm 45^\circ\).

The selectivity curve and half-power frequencies

With a fixed source voltage \(E\), the current \(I = E/|Z_T|\) mirrors the impedance curve: it rises to a peak of \(E/R\) at \(f_s\) and falls away on both sides. This plot is the selectivity curve. The frequencies \(f_1\) below and \(f_2\) above \(f_s\) where the current has fallen to \(1/\sqrt{2} = 0.707\) of its peak are the cutoff, band or half-power frequencies. The last name comes from the power: since \(P = I^2R\),

P = (0.707I_{\max})^2R = \tfrac12 P_{\max}

The current falls to 0.707 of its peak exactly when \(|Z_T| = \sqrt{2}\,R\), that is, when \(|X_L - X_C| = R\). The bandwidth is \(\text{BW} = f_2 - f_1\).

Bandwidth and the quality factor

Solving \(|X_L - X_C| = R\) gives the cutoff frequencies exactly:

f_{1,2} = \frac{1}{2\pi}\left[\mp\frac{R}{2L} + \sqrt{\left(\frac{R}{2L}\right)^2 + \frac{1}{LC}}\right]

Subtracting them leaves a strikingly simple result:

\text{BW} = \frac{R}{2\pi L} = \frac{f_s}{Q_s}

The higher the quality factor, the narrower the band and the more selective the circuit. The ratio \(\text{BW}/f_s = 1/Q_s\) is the fractional bandwidth. The cutoffs also satisfy \(f_s = \sqrt{f_1f_2}\): the resonant frequency is their geometric mean, not their average. Since \(Q_s = (1/R)\sqrt{L/C}\), reducing \(R\), or raising \(L/C\) at the same \(f_s\), narrows the band.

The high-Q shortcut

When \(Q_s \ge 10\), the curve near its peak is very nearly symmetric, so \(f_s\) sits almost exactly midway between the cutoffs:

f_1 \approx f_s - \frac{\text{BW}}{2},\qquad f_2 \approx f_s + \frac{\text{BW}}{2}

This approximation is widely used, and for \(Q_s = 20\) it is off by less than 0.1%. For low \(Q_s\) it fails badly, and the exact formula must be used. Whatever \(Q_s\) is, \(\text{BW} = f_s/Q_s\) is exact for the series circuit; only the placement of \(f_1\) and \(f_2\) around \(f_s\) is approximate.

Worked example: a low-Q circuit

A series circuit has \(R = 100\,\Omega\), \(L = 10\) mH and \(C = 1.0\,\mu\text{F}\). 1. \(f_s = 1/(2\pi\sqrt{10^{-2} \times 10^{-6}}) = 1592\) Hz. 2. \(X_L = 2\pi f_sL = 100\,\Omega\), so \(Q_s = 100/100 = 1.0\). 3. \(\text{BW} = R/(2\pi L) = 1592\) Hz. 4. Exact cutoffs: \(R/(2L) = 5000\) and \(\sqrt{5000^2 + 10^8} = 11\,180\) rad/s, so \(f_1 = (11\,180 - 5000)/(2\pi) = 984\) Hz and \(f_2 = (11\,180 + 5000)/(2\pi) = 2575\) Hz. 5. Check: \(f_2 - f_1 = 1592\) Hz, and \(\sqrt{984 \times 2575} = 1592\) Hz. The band reaches 608 Hz below \(f_s\) but 984 Hz above it, so the shortcut would mislead here.

Worked example: designing for a bandwidth

Design a series circuit resonant at 10.0 kHz with a 500 Hz bandwidth, given a total resistance of 15 Ω. 1. \(Q_s = f_s/\text{BW} = 10\,000/500 = 20\). 2. \(X_L = Q_sR = 300\,\Omega\) at resonance. 3. \(L = X_L/(2\pi f_s) = 4.77\) mH. 4. \(C = 1/((2\pi f_s)^2L) = 53.1\) nF. 5. Since \(Q_s \ge 10\), \(f_1 \approx 9.75\) kHz and \(f_2 \approx 10.25\) kHz; the exact formula gives 9.753 kHz and 10.253 kHz. 6. With a 1.0 V source, \(P_{\max} = E^2/R = 66.7\) mW at \(f_s\), and 33.3 mW at each cutoff.

How VR, VL and VC vary

The resistor voltage \(V_R = IR\) has exactly the shape of the current curve and peaks at \(E\) at \(f_s\). The capacitor voltage starts at \(E\) at zero frequency, where the capacitor is an open circuit, and falls to zero at very high frequency. The inductor voltage does the opposite, rising from zero towards \(E\). For a circuit with \(Q_s\) well above 1, \(V_C\) peaks slightly below \(f_s\) and \(V_L\) slightly above it, each at a little more than \(Q_sE\). When \(Q_s \ge 10\) the shift is negligible: in the \(Q_s = 20\) design, both peaks are within 7 Hz of 10 kHz and exceed \(20E\) by less than 0.1%.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, defining the band edges at half the peak current: they are at 0.707 of the peak current, which is half the peak power. Second, assuming \(f_s\) is the average of \(f_1\) and \(f_2\): it is their geometric mean, and the two are close only for high \(Q_s\). Third, using the symmetric shortcut when \(Q_s\) is small. Fourth, mixing up the phase: below series resonance the circuit is capacitive and the current leads; above, it is inductive. Fifth, thinking a larger \(R\) moves \(f_s\): it widens the band but leaves \(f_s\) alone.

Key takeaways

In a series R-L-C circuit \(|Z_T| = \sqrt{R^2 + (X_L - X_C)^2}\) is a minimum, \(R\), at \(f_s\); the circuit is capacitive below \(f_s\) and inductive above. The current curve peaks at \(E/R\). The half-power frequencies, where \(I = 0.707I_{\max}\), \(|X_L - X_C| = R\) and \(\theta = \pm 45^\circ\), bound the bandwidth \(\text{BW} = f_2 - f_1 = R/(2\pi L) = f_s/Q_s\). Higher \(Q_s\) means narrower bandwidth and greater selectivity. Always \(f_s = \sqrt{f_1f_2}\); for \(Q_s \ge 10\), \(f_s\) is about midway. \(V_C\) peaks just below \(f_s\) and \(V_L\) just above.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Selectivity

Ability to respond to a narrow band of frequencies and reject others

Narrower bandwidth, more selective.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A series resonant circuit has f_s = 50 kHz and Q_s = 25. What is its bandwidth?

Question 2 of 5

For the circuit with f_s = 50 kHz and Q_s = 25, what are the approximate cutoff frequencies?

Question 3 of 5

At a half-power frequency of a series resonant circuit, which statement is true?

Question 4 of 5

A series R-L-C circuit is driven at a frequency below its resonant frequency. How does it behave?

Question 5 of 5

A series resonant circuit has cutoff frequencies of 400 Hz and 900 Hz. What is its resonant frequency?

← Previous topicNext topic →