Electrical Engineering › Section F · Network theorems (dc) › Topic F.1

The superposition theorem

When a circuit has several sources, you can find the effect of each one on its own and simply add the results. Superposition turns one hard problem into several easy ones, and it shows how much of every current each source is responsible for.

From methods to theorems

Branch-current, mesh and nodal analysis will solve any dc network, but they solve everything at once, in a block of simultaneous equations. Often you want less: one current, one voltage, or a simple model of how a network behaves at two terminals. The network theorems of this section are shortcuts of that kind. They all rest on one property of resistive circuits, linearity, so that is the place to start.

Linearity

A circuit built from resistors and independent sources is linear. That means two things. First, proportionality: multiply every source by a factor \(k\) and every current and voltage in the circuit is multiplied by \(k\), so doubling both batteries doubles every reading. Second, additivity: the response to two sources acting together is the sum of the responses to each alone. Ohm's law, \(V = IR\), is a straight line through the origin, and Kirchhoff's laws are sums, so nothing in a resistive network can break either property. A diode or a lamp whose resistance changes as it heats is nonlinear, and these results no longer hold.

The superposition theorem

In a linear network with several independent sources, the current through any element, or the voltage across it, is found by adding, with signs, the current or voltage that each source produces on its own. Write the contribution of the first source as \(I'\), the second as \(I''\), and so on:

I = I' + I'' + I''' + \cdots

The words "with signs" matter. Each contribution is measured against the same reference direction, so a contribution that flows the other way enters the sum with a minus sign. With \(n\) sources you solve \(n\) single-source circuits, each of which usually needs only series-parallel reduction and a divider rule.

Switching the other sources off

To let one source act alone, every other independent source is set to zero while its internal resistance stays put. An ideal voltage source set to 0 V keeps zero voltage between its terminals whatever current flows, which is exactly a short circuit. An ideal current source set to 0 A passes no current whatever the voltage, which is an open circuit. So the rule is: voltage sources become shorts, current sources become opens. A practical battery is an ideal source in series with its internal resistance, so switching it off leaves that resistance in the branch. Dependent (controlled) sources, which appear later in the course in transistor models, are never switched off, because the circuit itself sets their values.

The method step by step

1. Choose the quantity you want and mark a reference direction for it (or + and − for a voltage). 2. Keep one source, switch off all the others, and redraw the circuit in your head or on paper. 3. Find the contribution with series-parallel rules, the voltage divider or the current divider. 4. Note whether it agrees with the reference direction; give it a minus sign if not. 5. Repeat for each source. 6. Add the signed contributions. 7. Check the total with a quick KCL or KVL test on the original circuit with every source back on.

Worked example: two voltage sources

Node a joins ground (node 0) through three branches. Left: a 12 V source \(E_1\), + towards a, in series with \(R_1 = 1.0\,\text{k}\Omega\). Middle: \(R_2 = 2.2\,\text{k}\Omega\). Right: a 9 V source \(E_2\), + towards a, in series with \(R_3 = 3.3\,\text{k}\Omega\). Find the current \(I_2\) down through \(R_2\). 1. \(E_1\) alone: short \(E_2\), so \(R_3\) sits in parallel with \(R_2\). \(E_1\) sees \(1.0 + 1.32 = 2.32\,\text{k}\Omega\) and supplies 5.17 mA; the current divider sends \(5.17 \times \frac{3.3}{5.5} = 3.10\,\text{mA}\) down \(R_2\). 2. \(E_2\) alone: short \(E_1\). \(E_2\) sees \(3.3 + 0.688 = 3.99\,\text{k}\Omega\) and supplies 2.26 mA, of which \(R_2\) takes \(2.26 \times \frac{1.0}{3.2} = 0.705\,\text{mA}\) downwards. 3. Both point down, so \(I_2 = 3.81\,\text{mA}\) and \(V_a = 3.81 \times 2.2 = 8.38\,\text{V}\). 4. Check: nodal analysis at a also gives 8.38 V.

Worked example: a voltage and a current source

A 15 V source E, + towards node a, is in series with \(R_1 = 4.7\,\text{k}\Omega\) from ground to a. \(R_2 = 10\,\text{k}\Omega\) joins a to ground, and an ideal 2 mA current source draws current out of node a into ground. Find \(I_2\), down through \(R_2\). 1. E alone: open the current source. Now \(R_1\) and \(R_2\) are in series, so \(I_2' = \frac{15}{14.7} = 1.02\,\text{mA}\) down. 2. Current source alone: short E, which puts \(R_1\) in parallel with \(R_2\). The source pulls 2 mA out of a, so current flows up through \(R_2\); its size is \(2 \times \frac{4.7}{14.7} = 0.639\,\text{mA}\), so \(I_2'' = -0.639\,\text{mA}\). 3. Add: \(I_2 = 1.02 - 0.639 = 0.381\,\text{mA}\), giving \(V_a = 3.81\,\text{V}\). 4. Check KCL at a: \(R_1\) delivers \(\frac{15 - 3.81}{4.7} = 2.38\,\text{mA}\), and \(0.381 + 2 = 2.38\,\text{mA}\) leaves. It balances.

Power does not superpose

Currents and voltages add, but power does not, because \(P = I^2R\) is not linear in \(I\). Take the second example. Acting alone, the 15 V source would deliver \((1.02\,\text{mA})^2 \times 10\,\text{k}\Omega = 10.4\,\text{mW}\) to \(R_2\), and the current source alone \(4.09\,\text{mW}\). Their sum is 14.5 mW, yet with both sources on, \(R_2\) absorbs only \((0.381\,\text{mA})^2 \times 10\,\text{k}\Omega = 1.45\,\text{mW}\), ten times less, because the two contributions partly cancel. In general \((I' + I'')^2 \neq I'^2 + I''^2\). The rule is: superpose currents or voltages first, then calculate power from the total.

When superposition is the right tool

Superposition shines when the sources are of different kinds. An amplifier stage typically has a dc supply that sets its operating point and a small ac signal riding on top; engineers analyse the dc and ac parts separately and add them, a habit that runs through the electronics part of this course. It also answers design questions directly, such as how much of an output voltage comes from each input, which is how a resistor summing network is checked. For a single numerical answer in a network with many sources, though, one set of nodal equations is often quicker than many single-source circuits.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, switching sources off the wrong way: a dead voltage source is a short and a dead current source is an open, never the reverse. Second, deleting a battery's internal resistance along with its ideal source; the resistance must stay in the branch. Third, adding contributions without signs, which is why the reference direction must be fixed before you begin. Fourth, adding the powers from each source instead of squaring the total current. Fifth, applying the theorem to a circuit with a diode or other nonlinear element, where additivity fails.

Key takeaways

Resistive circuits with independent sources are linear: responses scale with the sources and add. The superposition theorem says any current or voltage is the signed sum of the contributions from each independent source acting alone. To switch a source off, replace an ideal voltage source with a short and an ideal current source with an open, keep internal resistances, and leave dependent sources on. Give each contribution a sign against one reference direction. Power is not linear, so find the total current or voltage first and calculate power from it.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Linear circuit

Responses are proportional to the sources and add together

Resistors and independent sources qualify; diodes do not.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

While finding one source's contribution by superposition, a 6 V ideal voltage source and a 4 mA ideal current source elsewhere in the circuit must be switched off. What replaces them?

Question 2 of 5

In a linear circuit, source A acting alone drives 3.0 mA down through a 2.0 kΩ resistor, and source B acting alone drives 1.0 mA up through it. What power does the resistor absorb with both sources on?

Question 3 of 5

A 9.0 V source, + towards node a, is in series with 3.3 kΩ from ground to a. A 6.8 kΩ resistor joins a to ground, and a 1.0 mA current source pushes current from ground into a. What is the voltage at a?

Question 4 of 5

A linear resistive circuit with two sources gives an output of 4.0 V. If both source values are doubled, what is the output?

Question 5 of 5

A practical 12 V battery with 0.5 Ω internal resistance must be switched off while you find another source's contribution. What do you put in its place?

← Previous topicNext topic →