Electrical Engineering › Section M · Transformers and polyphase systems › Topic M.4
Equivalent circuits, coupled coils, and air-core transformers
Real transformers have resistance, leakage and core losses that the ideal model ignores. An equivalent circuit puts those effects back as ordinary R and L elements, and the same thinking, with the dot convention, handles coupled coils and air-core transformers.
Beyond the ideal transformer
The ideal transformer of "The iron-core transformer and power transmission" is an excellent first estimate, but four effects make a real one differ. The windings have resistance, so current heats them: copper loss. Some flux links only one winding: leakage flux, which acts like a small inductance in series with that winding. The core needs a magnetising current to set up its flux. And the core itself wastes energy through hysteresis and eddy currents, as described in "Reluctance, magnetizing force, and hysteresis". An equivalent circuit models each effect with a resistor or inductor around an ideal transformer.
The full equivalent circuit
Start at the primary terminals. In series come \(R_p\), the primary winding resistance, and \(X_p\), its leakage reactance. Next, connected across the circuit, is the magnetising branch: an inductance \(L_m\) that draws the magnetising current, in parallel with a resistance \(R_c\) whose power stands for the core loss. Then comes an ideal transformer of ratio a, and on its secondary side \(R_s\) and \(X_s\) in series before the load. At very high frequencies small capacitances between turns and between windings also matter. Every element except the ideal transformer is one you already know how to handle.
Referring everything to the primary
For load calculations the magnetising branch draws only a few percent of full-load current, so it is often left out. The secondary elements can then be moved to the primary side with the a-squared rule from "Reflected impedance and impedance matching". The resistances combine into an equivalent resistance, and the leakage reactances into an equivalent reactance:
The load appears as \(a^2Z_L\) and its voltage as \(a\mathbf{V}_L\). The whole transformer becomes one series impedance \(R_e + jX_e\) between the source and the reflected load, a single loop that is easy to solve.
Worked example: load voltage and regulation
A transformer with \(a = 4\) has \(R_p = 2.0\,\Omega\), \(X_p = 4.0\,\Omega\), \(R_s = 0.10\,\Omega\) and \(X_s = 0.25\,\Omega\). It must deliver 120 V to a 10 Ω resistive load. Find the source voltage. 1. \(R_e = 2.0 + 16(0.10) = 3.6\,\Omega\) and \(X_e = 4.0 + 16(0.25) = 8.0\,\Omega\). 2. Currents: \(I_s = 120/10 = 12\,\text{A}\) and \(I_p = 12/4 = 3.0\,\text{A}\), taken as the reference at 0°. 3. Reflected load voltage: \(a\mathbf{V}_L = 480\angle 0^\circ\,\text{V}\). 4. Source: \(\mathbf{V}_g = 3.0(3.6 + j8.0) + 480\), which is \(490.8 + j24.0\,\text{V}\), about \(491\angle 2.8^\circ\,\text{V}\) in polar form. 5. The ideal transformer would need only 480 V. Removing the load would raise the secondary to \(491/4 = 123\,\text{V}\): a voltage regulation of \((122.8 - 120)/120 \approx 2.4\%\).
How frequency changes the picture
The equivalent circuit explains why a transformer works well only over a band of frequencies. At low frequencies the magnetising reactance \(\omega L_m\) becomes small and shunts current away from the load, so the output falls; at 0 Hz it is effectively a short and the output is zero. In the mid band \(\omega L_m\) is large and the leakage reactances are still small, so the output is nearly flat. At high frequencies the leakage reactances grow while the winding capacitances shunt the output, so the response falls again, sometimes after a resonant peak.
Coils in series that share flux
"Inductors in series and parallel, and stored energy" added inductances that did not interact. If two coils in series are magnetically coupled, each also has a voltage induced by the other's changing current, and the total depends on whether their fluxes help or fight. With the fluxes aiding, \(L_{T+} = L_1 + L_2 + 2M\); with them opposing, \(L_{T-} = L_1 + L_2 - 2M\). Subtracting the two gives a neat way to measure mutual inductance without knowing k:
Connect the coils one way, measure; reverse one coil, measure again.
Worked example: measuring M
Coils of 30 mH and 50 mH are joined in series. An inductance meter reads 110 mH, and 50 mH after the leads of one coil are swapped. Find M and k. 1. The larger reading is the aiding connection: \(L_{T+} = 110\,\text{mH}\), \(L_{T-} = 50\,\text{mH}\). 2. \(M = (110 - 50)/4 = 15\,\text{mH}\). 3. \(k = M/\sqrt{L_1L_2} = 15/\sqrt{1500}\), so \(k = 15/38.7 = 0.387\). 4. Check: \(30 + 50 + 2(15) = 110\,\text{mH}\) and \(30 + 50 - 2(15) = 50\,\text{mH}\), matching both readings.
The dot convention
A circuit diagram cannot show how coils are wound, so one end of each coupled coil is marked with a dot. The rule: if the reference currents both enter dotted ends, or both leave them, the mutual term has the same sign as the self term (+M, fluxes aiding). If one current enters a dot and the other leaves one, the mutual term is negative (−M). The dots also give polarity: a rising current entering the dotted end of one coil makes the dotted end of the other coil positive. In a mesh equation, coil 2's current \(\mathbf{I}_2\) adds a voltage \(\pm j\omega M\mathbf{I}_2\) across coil 1, with the sign set by the dots.
The air-core transformer
Without an iron core, coupling is looser, k is well below 1, and the turns-ratio equations no longer hold. Instead, write mesh equations with the mutual reactance \(j\omega M\). With primary impedance \(Z_p = R_p + jX_{Lp}\) and secondary impedance \(Z_s = R_s + jX_{Ls}\) feeding a load \(Z_L\), the input impedance is
The second term is the coupled impedance. It is the same for either dot arrangement, because M is squared. When the secondary circuit is inductive, dividing by it gives the coupled term a negative reactance, which cancels part of the primary's inductive reactance. Air-core transformers suit radio frequencies, where iron cores would be too lossy.
Worked example: an air-core input impedance
An air-core transformer has \(Z_p = 5 + j100\,\Omega\), \(Z_s = 2 + j50\,\Omega\) and \(\omega M = 40\,\Omega\), feeding a 48 Ω resistive load; all impedances are in rectangular form. Find \(Z_i\). 1. Secondary loop: \(Z_s + Z_L = 50 + j50\,\Omega\). 2. Coupled impedance: \(1600/(50 + j50) = 16 - j16\,\Omega\). 3. Input: \(Z_i = (5 + j100) + (16 - j16)\), which is \(21 + j84\,\Omega\), or \(86.6\angle 76.0^\circ\,\Omega\) in polar form. 4. The secondary adds 16 Ω of resistance and removes 16 Ω of reactance. Check: \(k = 40/\sqrt{100 \times 50} = 0.57\), well below 1, as expected without a core.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reflecting secondary resistance and reactance without the factor \(a^2\), or adding them straight to the primary values. Second, forgetting the drop across \(R_e + jX_e\): the source voltage is the phasor sum \(a\mathbf{V}_L + \mathbf{I}_p(R_e + jX_e)\), larger than \(aV_L\) for resistive and lagging loads. Third, getting the sign of M wrong: check whether each reference current enters or leaves its dot, inside the coil itself. Fourth, using \(V_p/V_s = N_p/N_s\) for an air-core transformer, whose loose coupling breaks the turns-ratio rules.
Key takeaways
A real transformer is an ideal one plus winding resistances Rp and Rs, leakage reactances Xp and Xs, and a magnetising branch of Lm in parallel with core-loss resistance Rc. Referred to the primary, Re = Rp + a²Rs and Xe = Xp + a²Xs, so Vg = aVL + Ip(Re + jXe). Coupled coils in series give L1 + L2 ± 2M, so M = (LT+ − LT−)/4. Dots set the sign of M: both currents entering or both leaving dots means +M. An air-core transformer has Zi = Zp + (ωM)²/(Zs + ZL).
Flashcards
Flashcard
I²R heating in the winding resistances Rp and Rs
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A transformer with a = 5 has Rp = 1.5 Ω and Rs = 0.08 Ω. What is its equivalent resistance referred to the primary?
Question 2 of 5
Two coupled coils in series measure 90 mH with their fluxes aiding and 42 mH with them opposing. What is their mutual inductance?
Question 3 of 5
In a circuit diagram, the reference current I1 enters the dotted end of coil 1 and I2 leaves the dotted end of coil 2. What sign does the mutual term take?
Question 4 of 5
An air-core transformer has Zp = 4 + j60 Ω, Zs + ZL = 30 + j30 Ω and ωM = 30 Ω. What is its input impedance?
Question 5 of 5
Why does the output of an iron-core transformer fall at very low frequencies?
