Microeconomics › Section N · Labor markets and income › Topic N.1
The theory of labor markets
Why does a nurse earn more than a barista, and a backhoe operator more than a shovel hand? The theory of labour markets answers with a chain of multiplication: wages trace to what workers produce, what they produce traces to the tools and technology they work with, and what that output sells for. Labour demand is the demand for products, one step removed.
Where income comes from
In a market economy, income flows from ownership of productive resources, and each resource earns its factor payment. For most people the key resource is their own labour - the bulk of income arrives as wages, salaries, commissions and tips, equal to hours worked times the wage rate. Other resources pay their own returns: land earns rent, financial assets earn interest and dividends, ownership shares earn profit. Each factor price is set in its own market, and this section follows the biggest: labour. The other factor markets run on the same machinery, as a later topic on financial capital shows.
Marginal product of labour
How much is a worker worth? Start with what they produce. Marginal product of labour (MPL) is the additional output one more worker-hour adds. With workers assumed homogeneous - same skills, same effort - the MPL depends on what the workers have to work with: a typist types faster on a computer than a manual machine, a digger moves more earth with a backhoe than a shovel. And because capital is fixed in the short run, the MPL eventually declines as more workers crowd the same equipment - diminishing marginal returns. Because the workers are identical, the decline comes from crowding, not from weaker people: a later hire adds less because the machines are already in use.
The demand for labour: VMPL
Output is worth something only when it sells. In a perfectly competitive output market, the firm sells all it wants at the market price P - so each worker's contribution is worth \(MPL \times P\), the value of the marginal product of labour:
This IS the firm's demand for labour: the schedule of what each additional worker is worth to the firm. Since MPL declines with employment, so does VMPL - the demand curve for labour slopes downward, for the same physical reason the marginal product curve does.
Worked example: hiring at the going wage
A firm's workers (with fixed capital) have MPLs of 8, 7, 5, 3 and 1 for workers one through five; output sells at $5 a unit in a competitive market. 1. Compute VMPL: \(8 \times 5 = 40\), then 35, 25, 15, 5 - the firm's labour demand schedule. 2. The market wage is $20 (a competitive labour market: the firm can hire all it wants at this rate). 3. Hire while a worker adds at least the wage: workers 1-3 (40, 35, 25) clear it; worker 4 adds 15 against 20 - stop. 4. Employment: 3 workers. 5. The rule in one line: hire until \(W = VMPL\), the familiar marginal comparison. Assumptions: fixed capital, competitive output and labour markets, homogeneous workers.
Derived demand
Nobody demands labour for its own sake. Firms demand workers because customers demand products - labour demand is the demand for output, translated. The P in \(MPL \times P\) is the transmission: when consumers want more meals, restaurant prices and margins rise, and the value of an extra cook rises with them. The same chain runs through technology (a better machine raises MPL) and through downturns (when product demand collapses, labour demand collapses with it - unemployment is derived demand falling). To understand a labour market, look first at the product market beneath it.
Market power in the output market
The competitive rule assumed the firm sells at a fixed price. But a firm with market power - monopoly, oligopoly, monopolistic competition - faces a downward-sloping demand for its output: to sell more, it must lower the price on ALL units. What an extra worker brings is then valued at MARGINAL REVENUE, not price:
With MR below price beyond the first unit, the market-power firm's labour demand curve lies below the competitive one, and at any wage it hires fewer workers. This is not an extra cost on top of monopoly's deadweight loss: it is the same output restriction, seen from the labour market as fewer jobs.
Worked example: the same firm with market power
Same firm, same workers (MPLs 8, 7, 5, 3, 1) - but now it faces a downward-sloping demand for its product, with marginal revenues of $5, $4, $3, $2 and $1.20 for the output each successive worker adds. 1. Compute MRPL: \(8 \times 5 = 40\), then 28, 15, 6, 1.2. 2. At the same $20 wage: hire workers 1 and 2, stop - worker 3 adds only 15. 3. Employment: 2 workers, against 3 in the competitive version - the SAME people, the SAME capital, one fewer job, purely because the firm holds market power in the output market. 4. The gap's source: marginal revenue below price. Assumptions: as before, with the MR schedule as stated.
Do employers exploit labour?
Critics point out that the firm pays every worker a wage equal to the value added by the LAST hire, while earlier hires in the schedule added more (40 and 35 against a $20 wage). Since the workers are identical, that gap reflects the order of hiring over fixed capital, not better people. The standard neoclassical reply is that the extra value comes partly from capital and technology someone else paid for, so the difference between output value and wages pays for those tools and for the profit that keeps the firm open. Marxian economists reject that reading, and the reply assumes a competitive labour market: where an employer has power over wages, the next topic shows a real gap opening between pay and value.
What sets the going wage?
The individual firm takes the market wage as given; the market sets it. The market demand for labour is the horizontal sum of all firms' VMPL (or MRPL) curves, and the market supply is the sum of workers' willingness to supply hours - upward-sloping as higher wages pull in more workers and more hours. Where they cross, the going wage - a genuine market price, determined like the goods prices of earlier topics, except that the demand is derived from product markets and the supply comes from people's choices about time. Changes on either side ripple through wages the four-step way.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, forgetting that labour demand is DERIVED: output demand shifts labour demand, not the reverse. Second, valuing output at price for a firm with market power - only competitive firms use P; market power uses MR, and the difference is jobs. Third, reading 'the wage equals the VMPL' as an insult to earlier workers: all workers get the market wage; the marginal worker is just the ruler that sets it. Fourth, confusing MPL with VMPL: the first is physical, the second is priced. Fifth, assuming the homogeneous-workers assumption is reality: it isolates the machinery - the next topics add unions, discrimination, migration and supply-side power.
Key takeaways
Income flows from factor ownership, labour first among equals - and labour's price is set in a market like any other. The demand for labour is the value of workers' marginal product: \(VMPL = MPL \times P\) for competitive-output firms (the worked firm hired 3 workers at a $20 wage against VMPLs of 40, 35, 25, 15, 5), declining because MPL declines over fixed capital. The demand is DERIVED from product demand - the P transmits consumer wants into hiring. A firm with output-market power values labour at \(MRPL = MPL \times MR\) and hires less at any wage (2 workers instead of 3 in the twin example) - monopoly's output restriction seen as jobs. The standard reply to the 'exploitation' charge is that the gap pays for capital, technology and profit, a view critics contest. And the going wage is set where market labour demand meets labour supply.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Wages for labour, rent for land, interest for capital, profit for enterprise
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A competitive-output firm's workers have MPLs of 8, 7, 5, 3, 1 and output sells at $5. At a market wage of $20, how many workers does it hire?
Question 2 of 5
Why is the demand for labour called a DERIVED demand?
Question 3 of 5
The same firm now has market power: marginal revenues are 5, 4, 3, 2, 1.2. With MPLs 8, 7, 5, 3, 1 and wage $20, what changes?
Question 4 of 5
How does the standard reply address the claim that paying all workers the last worker's VMPL exploits the earlier ones?
Question 5 of 5
What sets the going market wage that an individual firm takes as given?
