Philosophy › Section H · Value theory › Topic H.5
Aesthetics
Is beauty in the object or in the eye of the beholder, and what turns a urinal or a soap-pad box into art? Aesthetics studies beauty, taste and art, drawing on Greek, European, Indian and Japanese traditions that answer these questions very differently.
What aesthetics studies
Aesthetics is the part of value theory concerned with beauty, taste and art. Its questions include whether judgements of beauty can be correct or mistaken, what makes something a work of art, how artworks should be interpreted, and why art and natural beauty matter to us. Alexander Baumgarten introduced the term in 1735, from the Greek aisthēsis, perception, because he saw aesthetic experience as a kind of knowing through the senses. Aesthetic value covers more than beauty, including the sublime, the tragic and the ugly, and it reaches beyond galleries into nature, crafts and daily life.
Objective beauty and the standard of taste
For Plato, beautiful things share in one Form of Beauty, and beauty is closely tied to harmony and proportion; the sculptor Polykleitos, in the fifth century BCE, set out ideal proportions for the human figure. On this view, beauty is a real feature of things. David Hume, in "Of the Standard of Taste" (1757), grounded beauty instead in human sentiment, yet denied that all tastes are equal. Some critics judge better, and the true judge has "strong sense, united to delicate sentiment, improved by practice, perfected by comparison, and cleared of all prejudice". Works admired by such judges across ages, as Homer has been, set the standard. Critics ask how to identify true judges without already knowing which works are good.
Kant and aesthetic judgement
Immanuel Kant's third Critique (1790) contrasted the merely agreeable, such as liking a flavour of ice cream, with the beautiful. Pleasure in the beautiful is disinterested: it does not depend on wanting to use or own the object. Yet a judgement of beauty speaks with a universal voice, claiming that everyone ought to agree, though it rests on feeling rather than on concepts or rules. Kant distinguished the sublime, the awe of vast or overwhelming things such as storms and mountains. Friedrich Nietzsche later mocked disinterestedness as a spectator's view of art. Frank Sibley (1959) added that aesthetic qualities such as gracefulness depend on non-aesthetic features such as line and colour but follow no rules from them.
Three theories of art
Imitation theories, from Plato and Aristotle, hold that art represents the world; Plato distrusted art as a copy of a copy, while Aristotle valued it for teaching through representation. The objection is that music and abstract painting represent little. Expression theories hold that art expresses emotion: Leo Tolstoy, in What Is Art? (1897), said art passes a feeling from the artist to the audience, and R. G. Collingwood (1938) said it clarifies feeling. The objection is that much art is cool and formal. Clive Bell's formalism (1914) located art's value in significant form, arrangements of line and colour that stir a special emotion. Critics reply that this ignores the content and context of most art.
Worked example: the Brillo box
In 1964 Andy Warhol exhibited wooden boxes printed to look almost exactly like supermarket cartons of Brillo soap pads. Test each theory. 1. Imitation: the boxes copy cartons, but a carton looks the same, so resemblance cannot separate art from merchandise. 2. Expression: the boxes express no obvious emotion. 3. Formalism: the boxes and the cartons have nearly the same form, yet only one is art. 4. Conclusion: whatever makes the boxes art cannot be visible to the eye alone. 5. This is the problem Arthur Danto took up, and it parallels Marcel Duchamp's Fountain of 1917, discussed in "Developing good habits of mind".
The artworld and institutions
Danto, in "The Artworld" (1964), argued that seeing something as art requires an atmosphere of theory and a knowledge of art history; the Brillo boxes were art because they made a statement within that history. George Dickie's institutional theory (1974) held that an artwork is an artefact presented for appreciation by members of the artworld. Jerrold Levinson proposed a historical definition: art is what is seriously intended to be regarded in ways earlier art has been regarded. Critics call the institutional theory circular and ask who belongs to the artworld. Feminist critics, including the activist group the Guerrilla Girls, founded in 1985, add that gatekeepers long excluded women artists and domestic crafts.
Interpretation and morality
Does a work mean what its maker intended? W. K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley (1946) called it the intentional fallacy to judge a poem by its author's intentions, since the work must stand on its own and intentions are often unknown. Actual intentionalists reply that ignoring intentions invites misreading irony or allusion; moderate versions say intentions count when the work supports them. A related debate asks whether moral flaws are aesthetic flaws. Autonomists say the two kinds of value are separate; Berys Gaut's ethicism says a work's endorsement of cruelty can count against it aesthetically.
Rasa theory
Classical Indian aesthetics centres on rasa, often translated as aesthetic flavour or relish. The Nāṭyaśāstra, a treatise on drama traditionally credited to the sage Bharata and dated very roughly to two thousand years ago, lists eight rasas, including the erotic, the comic, the heroic and the furious. The philosopher Abhinavagupta, of about 1000 CE, argued that rasa is not the spectator's personal emotion. A play's situations, gestures and reactions evoke an emotion that is generalised, freed from one's own interests, and savoured by a sensitive spectator, the sahṛdaya, "one with a matching heart". Later writers, Abhinavagupta among them, defended a ninth rasa, peace. The theory locates aesthetic value in refined, shared experience.
Japanese and everyday aesthetics
Japanese aesthetics often prizes the small, simple and passing. Mono no aware, a term the scholar Motoori Norinaga developed in the eighteenth century, names a gentle sorrow at the transience of things, as when cherry blossoms fall. Wabi-sabi values rustic simplicity, age and imperfection, as in a cracked tea bowl. Yuriko Saito, in Everyday Aesthetics (2007), drew on such traditions to argue that aesthetic choices about food, clothing, homes and cleanliness shape our lives and our environment. Environmental aesthetics asks how to appreciate nature; Allen Carlson argued that appreciating a landscape properly requires knowing its natural history, as appreciating art requires knowing its genre.
Worked example: a cracked tea bowl
A potter's tea bowl has an uneven glaze and a mended crack. 1. Imitation: it represents nothing, so on that theory it is not art. 2. Formalism: its irregular shape and texture may have significant form. 3. Institutional: it becomes art if presented for appreciation, as when a museum displays it. 4. Kant: delight in it without wanting to use it may be a judgement of beauty, claiming others' agreement. 5. Wabi-sabi: the irregularity and visible repair are sources of beauty, not defects. 6. Everyday aesthetics: the pleasure of drinking from it counts even if it is never displayed. 7. Lesson: the verdict depends on the theory.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking Hume made taste a matter of mere opinion; he argued that trained judges can be right or wrong. Second, confusing Kant's disinterested pleasure with lack of interest; it means pleasure free of desire to use or own. Third, assuming one theory of art must handle every case; each fits some art and struggles with other kinds. Fourth, treating the intentional fallacy as settled; intentionalists dispute it. Fifth, assuming aesthetics concerns only European fine art; rasa theory, wabi-sabi and everyday aesthetics broaden the field.
Key takeaways
Aesthetics studies beauty, taste and art. Plato tied beauty to a Form and proportion; Hume grounded it in sentiment refined by true judges; Kant described disinterested pleasure with a universal voice, and the sublime. Imitation, expression and formalist theories each capture some art; Warhol's Brillo boxes prompted Danto's artworld, Dickie's institutional and Levinson's historical theories. Interpretation divides intentionalists from followers of Wimsatt and Beardsley. Rasa theory, Japanese, everyday and environmental aesthetics extend the field beyond the gallery.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The study of beauty, taste and art
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which view did Hume defend in "Of the Standard of Taste"?
Question 2 of 5
What does Kant mean by calling pleasure in the beautiful "disinterested"?
Question 3 of 5
Why did Warhol's Brillo boxes trouble imitation, expression and formalist theories of art?
Question 4 of 5
According to Abhinavagupta, what is rasa?
Question 5 of 5
What did Wimsatt and Beardsley call the intentional fallacy?
