Philosophy › Section I · Normative moral theory › Topic I.1
What a normative moral theory requires
Everyone has moral opinions; a moral theory tries to organise them into a system that explains why right acts are right and helps us decide hard cases. Before comparing the major theories, it helps to know what job a theory is meant to do and how to judge whether it does it well.
From opinions to theory
Suppose you find a wallet holding $200 and the owner's address. Most people are sure they should return it, but fewer can say why. Is it because returning it causes the most happiness, because keeping it breaks a rule against taking what is not yours, or because an honest person simply would? Each answer points to a different moral theory. A normative moral theory is a systematic account of what makes actions right or wrong, and of what makes people and lives good. It aims to explain the judgements we are confident about and to guide us in the cases where we are not.
Three areas of ethics
Ethics, the branch of philosophy that studies morality, is usually divided into three areas. Metaethics asks the most abstract questions: what moral words mean, whether there are moral facts, and how we could know them. Normative ethics, the subject of this section, asks what we ought to do and what kind of people we ought to be, and offers general standards for answering. Applied ethics brings those standards to particular controversies, such as euthanasia, animal welfare or the ethics of technology. The topic "Metaethics" covers the first area, and the section beginning with "Bioethics" the third.
What a theory must supply
A complete normative theory usually offers two linked accounts. A theory of the right states the criterion of rightness: the feature that makes right acts right, such as producing the best outcome or respecting persons. A theory of the good states what is valuable, such as pleasure, flourishing or harmony. Some theories define the right in terms of the good, so that a right act brings about the most good. Others hold that some acts are right or wrong whatever good they bring about. Many theories also explain moral worth: when a person deserves praise or blame for what they did.
Criterion versus decision procedure
A criterion of rightness says what makes an act right; a decision procedure says how to work out what to do. These can come apart. A theory might hold that the right act is the one with the best results while advising that, in daily life, you will usually get the best results by keeping promises rather than calculating each time. R. Eugene Bales pressed this distinction in 1971. It matters because the objection that a theory is too hard to apply in the moment may hit only its decision procedure, not its account of rightness.
Standards for judging a theory
Theories are judged by several standards. Consistency: the theory must not tell you both to do and not to do the same act. Fit with considered judgements: it should agree with the moral beliefs we hold most firmly after careful thought, such as that torturing for fun is wrong. Explanatory power: it should say why those judgements are true, not just list them. Guidance: it should help in new and hard cases. Impartiality: like cases should be treated alike, with no special exemption for oneself. Liveability: people should be able to follow it without giving up everything else that makes a life worth living.
Reflective equilibrium
How do theory and judgement correct each other? W. D. Ross wrote in 1930 that the moral convictions of thoughtful, well-educated people are the data of ethics, much as sense perceptions are the data of natural science. John Rawls, in A Theory of Justice (1971), described a method he called reflective equilibrium. We move back and forth between general principles and particular judgements, revising whichever seems weaker, until the two fit together. A strong principle can overturn a judgement that turns out to be prejudice, and a firm judgement can overturn a principle. Neither side automatically wins.
Worked example: testing a simple theory
Test the theory "An act is right if and only if the law permits it." 1. Fit with considered judgements: slavery was legal in many places, yet we judge it gravely wrong, so the theory gives a false verdict. 2. Explanatory power: it cannot explain why reformers who broke unjust laws, such as civil rights protesters, could be right, or why we can call a law unjust at all. 3. Guidance: it is silent where the law is silent, as with breaking a promise to a friend. 4. A further cost: when a legislature changes a law overnight, the theory says the act itself became right or wrong overnight. 5. Conclusion: legality and morality overlap, but the law cannot be the criterion of rightness.
The main families of theory
This section examines several answers. Consequentialism judges acts by their outcomes; utilitarianism, its best-known form, counts everyone's well-being equally. Deontology holds that some acts are required or forbidden by duty, whatever the results. Virtue ethics starts from character and asks what a good person would do. These three are the usual Western map, distinguished by what they treat as basic. Daoist ethics and feminist care ethics, also covered here, challenge parts of that map. The labels are tools, not boxes: Mohism, met in "Classical Chinese philosophy", is an early consequentialism, and many theorists combine families.
Worked example: one case, three verdicts
A friend asks you to hide her from a man who has threatened her, and he arrives asking where she is. 1. A consequentialist asks which answer leads to the best outcome; lying protects her, so lying is right. 2. A strict Kantian deontologist holds that lying is wrong in itself; the topic "How philosophers arrive at truth" noted Kant's 1797 view that even this lie is forbidden, though many Kantians disagree. 3. A virtue ethicist asks what courage, loyalty and honesty together require of a good person here. 4. Compare: the theories may agree on the act yet disagree on why, and the reason matters for other cases.
Is any theory possible?
Some philosophers doubt the whole project. Bernard Williams, in Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy (1985), argued that ethical theory distorts moral life by forcing rich, varied concerns into one system. Jonathan Dancy, a moral particularist, argues in Ethics Without Principles (2004) that a feature which makes one act better, such as giving pleasure, can make another act worse, as when the pleasure is cruel. If so, no list of general principles can capture morality. Defenders reply that we still need reasons that carry from case to case, or moral judgement becomes arbitrary.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, confusing the three areas: asking whether moral facts exist is metaethics, not normative ethics. Second, treating a criterion of rightness as if it had to be a step-by-step decision procedure. Third, assuming a theory that matches every gut reaction is best; reflective equilibrium allows principles to correct judgements too. Fourth, thinking that two theories agreeing on an act means they agree; they may give different reasons. Fifth, treating legality, popularity or personal feeling as the same thing as moral rightness.
Key takeaways
A normative moral theory systematically explains what makes acts right and what is good. Ethics divides into metaethics, normative ethics and applied ethics. A criterion of rightness differs from a decision procedure. Good theories are consistent, fit and explain considered judgements, guide action, treat like cases alike and can be lived. Rawls's reflective equilibrium adjusts principles and judgements against each other. The main families judge by consequences, duty or character; Williams and the particularists doubt any theory can succeed.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A systematic account of what makes acts right or wrong and what is good
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A philosopher asks whether the sentence "Cruelty is wrong" can be literally true. Which area of ethics is this?
Question 2 of 5
A critic says a theory is useless because no one can calculate its answer in the moment. What reply does the reading suggest?
Question 3 of 5
What is reflective equilibrium?
Question 4 of 5
Why does the theory "an act is right if and only if the law permits it" fail?
Question 5 of 5
Jonathan Dancy argues that giving pleasure can make one act better and another act worse. What conclusion does he draw?
